Comparison: Best Fireplace Wood Insert (Updated | Dec 19th)
Tired of watching your hard-earned money literally go up in smoke with that old, inefficient fireplace? You’re not alone. But with so many options promising the best performance, how do you choose the right one? We’ve done the heavy lifting for you, sifting through the top models to bring you the ultimate guide to finding the perfect wood insert for your space and budget.
Editor’s Choice
Best for a specific purpose
- Best for powerful wood heating: Buck Stove Fireplace Insert Model 21 | Non-Catalytic
- Best for effortless electric ambiance: LegendFlame 23″ W Free Standing Electric Fireplace Log Set (EF290)
- Best for traditional wood insert: Buck Stove Fireplace Insert Model 21 | Non-Catalytic
- Best for remote-controlled electric: LegendFlame 25″ W Free Standing Electric Fireplace Log Set (EF484)
- Best for infrared heating technology: Electric Fireplace Logs Inserts Heater with Infrared Remote Controller 5 Flame Brightness 24 H Timer Overheating Protection for Home and Office Decor Black
- Best for quiet infrared heating: Riseon Electric Fireplace Logs Inserts Heater 20-Inch
- Best for colorful flame options: PuraFlame 27″ Free Standing Electric Fireplace Log Set Insert
- Best for safety-certified electric: Electric Fireplace Insert Log Heater 21 Inches
- Best for birch log elegance: LegendFlame 23″ W Free Standing Electric Fireplace White Birch Log Set (EF290A-WB)
- Best for heavy-duty wood support: Fireplace Grate 17 Inch Solid Round Steel 3/4″ Bar Heavy Duty Firewood Stove Log Holder Rack Grates Wrought Cast Iron Indoor Outdoor Camping Chimney Hearth Wood Burning Fireplace Accessories Tools
Product Comparison: Best Fireplace Wood Insert
Powerful Wood Heating
Buck Stove Fireplace Insert Model 21 | Non-Catalytic, 28,901 BTUs (Covers 1,800 Square Feet) | Wood Burning with Heat Activated Blower | Black Door with 9″ Faceplate Trim Kit
Buck
The Buck Stove Fireplace Insert Model 21 offers powerful heating with 28,901 BTUs, effectively warming spaces up to 1,800 square feet. This non-catalytic wood insert combines traditional aesthetics with modern efficiency, featuring customizable door colors in Black, Pewter, or Gold to match your decor. The large viewing area enhances the fireplace experience, allowing you to enjoy the mesmerizing flames. Installation is flexible with customizable black trim kits that can be cut to size, ensuring a perfect fit in various fireplace openings. Backed by a 1-year replacement and 5-year limited parts warranty, this American-made insert provides both warmth and peace of mind for homeowners seeking reliable heating solutions.
✓ Reasons to Buy
- Powerful heating capacity
- Customizable appearance options
- Flexible installation kit
- Large viewing area
- Solid warranty coverage
✗ Reasons Not to Buy
- Requires professional installation
- Regular maintenance needed
- Higher initial cost
Effortless Electric Ambiance
LegendFlame 23″ W Free Standing Electric Fireplace Log Set (EF290), Fireplace Insert, Heater 750W/1500W, Crackling Sound, Remote Control
Legend Flame
The LegendFlame 23″ W Free Standing Electric Fireplace Log Set offers the perfect blend of ambiance and convenience for any room. Measuring 23″ W x 20″ H x 10″ D, this versatile unit fits seamlessly into existing fireplace openings or can be used as a standalone feature. The realistic resin logs and ember bed create stunning flame effects that rival traditional wood-burning fireplaces, while the energy-efficient LED technology keeps electricity costs low. With the ability to operate with or without heat, you can enjoy the cozy atmosphere year-round. The heater provides supplemental warmth for spaces up to 400 square feet, making it ideal for bedrooms, living rooms, or offices. CSA certified and backed by a one-year limited warranty, this electric fireplace offers both safety and reliability.
✓ Reasons to Buy
- Realistic flame effects
- Easy installation process
- Year-round usability
- Energy-efficient LED technology
- No ventilation required
✗ Reasons Not to Buy
- Limited heating area
- Not a primary heat source
- Smaller flame display
Traditional Wood Insert
Buck Stove Fireplace Insert Model 21 | Non-Catalytic, 28,901 BTUs (Covers 1,800 Square Feet) | Wood Burning with Heat Activated Blower | Black Door with 12″ Faceplate Trim Kit
Buck
The Buck Stove Fireplace Insert Model 21 delivers exceptional heating performance with 28,901 BTUs, capable of warming areas up to 1,800 square feet efficiently. This non-catalytic wood insert combines traditional craftsmanship with modern heating technology, offering homeowners both style and substance. The customizable appearance options, including door colors in Black, Pewter, or Gold, allow you to match your existing decor perfectly. The generous viewing area enhances the fireplace experience, creating a focal point in any room. Installation is simplified with the included customizable black trim kit that can be cut to size for a seamless fit. Manufactured in America and backed by a comprehensive 1-year replacement and 5-year limited parts warranty, this fireplace insert represents a smart investment in home heating.
✓ Reasons to Buy
- Impressive heating capacity
- Customizable door colors
- Flexible trim kit
- Large viewing area
- Extended warranty protection
✗ Reasons Not to Buy
- Requires chimney installation
- Regular cleaning necessary
- Higher price point
Remote-Controlled Electric
LegendFlame 25″ W Free Standing Electric Fireplace Log Set (EF484), Fireplace Insert, Heater 750W/1500W, Crackling Sound, Remote Control…
Legend Flame
The LegendFlame 25″ Free Standing Electric Fireplace Log Set offers a perfect blend of aesthetics and functionality for your home. Measuring 25″ W x 20″ H x 10″ D, this insert fits seamlessly into various existing openings or cabinets with minimal installation effort. The stunning flame effect rises from realistic resin logs with an ember bed, creating an ambiance that rivals traditional wood-burning fireplaces. Energy-efficient LED technology allows you to enjoy the visual appeal year-round without the heating function. This unit provides supplemental warmth for spaces up to 400 square feet, eliminating the hassle of smoke, dust, or wood-burning regulations. The included remote control with batteries enhances convenience, while the one-year limited warranty ensures peace of mind.
✓ Reasons to Buy
- Realistic flame effect
- Energy-efficient LED technology
- Simple installation process
- Supplemental heating for 400 sq ft
- Remote control included
✗ Reasons Not to Buy
- Not a primary heat source
- Limited to 120V outlets
- Polarized plug requirement
Infrared Heating Technology
Electric Fireplace Logs Inserts Heater with Infrared Remote Controller 5 Flame Brightness 24 H Timer Overheating Protection for Home and Office Decor Black
Riseon
Riseon’s Electric Fireplace Logs Insert Heater brings the cozy ambiance of a traditional fireplace without the maintenance hassles. The realistic 3D flame technology mimics burning logs with rolling and pulsating effects, creating an authentic visual experience. Premium materials and exquisite craftsmanship ensure durability while allowing the flame function to operate independently of heating. Energy-saving features include five brightness levels and two heating modes, making it versatile for all seasons. The fan heating function provides adjustable temperature control while maintaining quiet operation. Safety features include ETL certification and overheating protection with automatic shutdown. The timer function allows programming between 1-24 hours. This portable unit plugs into any 120V outlet and can be freestanding or built-in, making it perfect for various spaces from living rooms to offices.
✓ Reasons to Buy
- Realistic 3D flame effect
- Energy-saving with adjustable settings
- Quiet fan heating function
- Safety certifications included
- Versatile installation options
✗ Reasons Not to Buy
- Limited heating capacity
- Requires 120V outlet
- Not suitable as primary heat source
Quiet Infrared Heating
Riseon Electric Fireplace Logs Inserts Heater 20-Inch, Remote Controller Fireplace Heater, Adjustable Flame Colors, Realistic Fake firewood Flame, Overheat Protection, Timer, Thermostat, 1500W Black
Riseon
The Riseon 20-Inch Electric Fireplace Logs Heater combines powerful heating technology with aesthetic appeal to enhance any living space. This upgraded system delivers up to 1500W of power using advanced quartz tube infrared heating technology, efficiently warming rooms while maintaining comfort. The realistic resin logs with birch appearance create an authentic burning effect with five flame options and five air speed adjustments, allowing you to customize the ambiance. Safety features include automatic shutdown at 230°F and a sleep mode that operates at ≤40dB, ensuring peaceful rest. The flame function works independently of the heater, making it suitable for year-round enjoyment. This no-installation unit fits most furniture styles and works perfectly in living rooms, bedrooms, offices, or stores, providing both warmth and visual appeal wherever you need it.
✓ Reasons to Buy
- Powerful 1500W heating
- Infrared heating technology
- Multiple flame and speed options
- Quiet operation (≤40dB)
- No installation required
✗ Reasons Not to Buy
- Limited to 20-inch size
- Requires 120V power source
- Not ideal for large spaces
Colorful Flame Options
PuraFlame 27″ Free Standing Electric Fireplace Log Set Insert, 750W/1500W Heater, 6 Flame Colors with 5 Brightness, Crackling Sound, Remote Control
PuraFlame
The PuraFlame 27″ Free Standing Electric Fireplace Log Set offers a perfect blend of ambiance and functionality for your home. This versatile insert fits easily into most existing fireplace openings, requiring no installation beyond plugging in. The unit features six customizable flame colors with five brightness levels, creating a realistic wood-burning effect complete with crackling sounds. The dual heating options (750W/1500W) can warm up to 400 square feet, with a thermostat ranging from 60-82°F and a timer function. The LED display clearly shows all settings, making operation intuitive. Perfect for those wanting the cozy feel of a fireplace without the maintenance of a real wood-burning unit.
✓ Reasons to Buy
- Six flame colors
- Realistic crackling sound
- Dual heat settings
- Easy installation
- Clear LED display
✗ Reasons Not to Buy
- Not primary heat source
- Requires dedicated outlet
Safety-Certified Electric
Electric Fireplace Insert Log Heater 21 Inches, 5 Flame Brightness, Multiple Flicker Speed, 750w/1500w Heating, Remote Control, Auto Shut Off
Electactic
The Electactic Electric Fireplace Insert Log Heater combines safety, convenience, and ambiance in one compact 21-inch unit. This ETL certified fireplace features five adjustable flame brightness settings and multiple flicker speeds, allowing you to customize the perfect atmosphere for any occasion. The independent flame and heat controls let you enjoy the visual effects year-round, even without heat. With two heating modes (750W/1500W), you can efficiently warm your space while maintaining comfort. The overheat protection and auto shutoff features ensure safety, making it suitable for homes with children and pets. Installation is effortless—no chimney or venting required—just plug it in and enjoy the warmth.
✓ Reasons to Buy
- ETL certified safe
- Multiple flame settings
- Independent controls
- No venting needed
- Remote included
✗ Reasons Not to Buy
- Limited heating capacity
- Smaller size
Birch Log Elegance
LegendFlame 23″ W Free Standing Electric Fireplace White Birch Log Set (EF290A-WB), Fireplace Insert, Heater 750W/1500W, Crackling Sound, Remote Control
Legend Flame
The LegendFlame 23″ W Free Standing Electric Fireplace with White Birch Log Set brings elegance and warmth to any room. The stunning flame effects rise from realistic resin logs with an ember bed, creating an ambiance that rivals traditional wood-burning fireplaces. The energy-efficient LED technology allows you to enjoy the beautiful flame effects with or without heat throughout the year. This unit can effectively warm spaces up to 400 square feet without the hassle of dust, smoke, or local wood burning regulations. The included remote control (with batteries) adds convenience, while the CSA certification ensures safety and quality. Perfect for those seeking a sophisticated heating solution with minimal maintenance.
✓ Reasons to Buy
- Realistic birch logs
- Energy efficient LED
- Remote control included
- CSA certified
- Year-round ambiance
✗ Reasons Not to Buy
- Not primary heat source
- Limited heating area
Heavy-Duty Wood Support
Fireplace Grate 17 Inch Solid Round Steel 3/4″ Bar Heavy Duty Firewood Stove Log Holder Rack Grates Wrought Cast Iron Indoor Outdoor Camping Chimney Hearth Wood Burning Fireplace Accessories Tools
MYFIREPLACEDIRECT
The MYFIREPLACEDIRECT 17 Inch Solid Round Steel Fireplace Grate offers exceptional durability and performance for your wood-burning fireplace. This patented design features four thickened solid feet plus two additional middle supports to prevent sagging and deformation over time. Constructed from 3/4″ round bar steel, this heavy-duty grate outperforms diamond-shaped steel or flat iron alternatives. The 3-inch elevation from the floor promotes better air circulation for more efficient wood burning, while the 2-inch spacing between bars accommodates various log sizes. With a matte black high-temperature paint finish, this 17″ x 12″ x 4.7″ grate can hold over 80kg (180lb) of firewood and will last for years in your fireplace, fire pit, or wood stove.
✓ Reasons to Buy
- Patented anti-sag design
- Heavy-duty construction
- Improves wood burning
- No assembly required
- High-temperature finish
✗ Reasons Not to Buy
- Limited to 17 inch
- Only for wood burning
Product prices and availability are accurate as of the date/time indicated and are subject to change. Any price and availability information displayed on Amazon.com at the time of purchase will apply to the purchase of this product.
Buying Guide
FAQs
What should I look for in a wood fireplace insert?
Consider the heating capacity to match your room size, efficiency ratings for optimal heat output, and EPA certification for clean burning. Look for features like adjustable airflow, a large glass door for ambiance, and easy-to-clean ash pans. Durability and warranty are also key factors for long-term value.
How do wood inserts compare to traditional fireplaces?
Wood inserts are far more efficient, as they trap and circulate heat instead of losing it up the chimney. They also produce less smoke and require less wood than open fireplaces. Inserts are safer and more environmentally friendly due to their sealed design and EPA compliance.
What features are worth the extra cost?
Blowers or fans can significantly improve heat distribution, making them a worthwhile upgrade for larger spaces. Ceramic glass windows provide better insulation and a clearer view of the fire. Remote controls and programmable thermostats add convenience but may not be essential for all users.
How do I choose the right size insert for my home?
Measure the dimensions of your existing fireplace to ensure a proper fit, and consult the manufacturer’s guidelines for clearance. Match the BTU output to the square footage of the area you want to heat. Oversized inserts can overheat small spaces, while undersized ones may struggle to warm larger rooms.
Are wood inserts energy-efficient?
Yes, modern wood inserts are highly efficient, with many models achieving 70-85% efficiency ratings. They burn wood cleanly and completely, maximizing heat output while minimizing waste. Look for EPA-certified models to ensure compliance with environmental standards.
What’s the difference between catalytic and non-catalytic inserts?
Catalytic inserts use a combustor to burn off smoke and gases, offering higher efficiency and longer burn times. Non-catalytic models rely on air injection and are simpler to maintain but may be slightly less efficient. Choose based on your preference for performance versus maintenance ease.
How much does a wood fireplace insert cost?
Prices typically range from $1,500 to $4,000, depending on size, features, and brand. Installation can add another $500 to $2,000, especially if chimney lining is required. Higher-end models with advanced features will cost more but may offer better long-term savings.
Are wood inserts easy to maintain?
Regular maintenance includes cleaning the glass door, removing ash, and inspecting the chimney for creosote buildup. Annual professional servicing is recommended to ensure safety and efficiency. Some models feature self-cleaning glass or easy-access ash pans to simplify upkeep.