Comparison: Propane And Charcoal Grill (Updated | Jan 14th)
When it comes to firing up the grill, the great debate between propane and charcoal isn’t just about flavor—it’s about lifestyle. Are you a weekend warrior who values convenience and quick heat, or a purist chasing that smoky, char-kissed taste only charcoal can deliver? Both have loyal fans and solid perks. In this no-nonsense comparison, we’ll break down the real differences in taste, cleanup, cost, and control—so you can pick the grill that fits your backyard, your schedule, and your burgers, perfectly.
Key Takeaways
- The top pick offers dual-fuel flexibility for propane and charcoal grilling convenience.
- It delivers powerful 34,000 BTU output for fast, even heating.
- With huge cooking space and a built-in smoker, it excels in versatility.
- Choose based on fuel preference, cooking capacity, and desired features like smoking.
- Prioritize easy ignition and durable construction for long-term grilling success.
Grills House 2-Burner Gas and Charcoal Combo Grill with Offset Smoker & Side Burner
Dual-Fuel Powerhouse
- Dual-fuel flexibility
- Huge cooking space
- Built-in smoker
- BEST FOR DUAL-FUEL POWERHOUSE: Grills House 2-Burner Gas and Charcoal Combo Grill with Offset Smoker & Side Burner Read More ↓
- BEST FOR FAMILY-SIZED FLEX GRILL: Captiva Designs Propane Gas Grill and Charcoal Grill Combo with Side Burner & Porcelain-Enameled Cast Iron Grate Read More ↓
- BEST FOR SMOKER-GRILL PRO: Oklahoma Joe’s Canyon Combo Charcoal and Gas Smoker & Grill Read More ↓
- BEST FOR 3-IN-1 COMPACT MASTER: GRILL DEPOTS Griddle Grill Combo Read More ↓
- BEST FOR SOLID DUAL-FUEL BUILD: Char-Griller® Dual-Function 2-Burner 24 Read More ↓
- BEST FOR GRIDDLE & GRILL MATE: Propane and Charcoal Grill Combo Read More ↓
- BEST FOR CAST IRON VERSATILITY: GRILL DEPOTS Propane Gas and Charcoal Grill Combo | Griddle Grill with Side Burner | BBQ Grills 2-in-1 | 41 Read More ↓
- BEST FOR EASY-MOVE COMBO GRILL: Royal Gourmet ZH3002N Propane Gas and Charcoal Grill Combo Read More ↓
- BEST FOR FLAT TOP DUAL FUEL: Propane Gas Griddle Charcoal Grill Combo Flat Top Griddle W/Dual Lids & 2 Side Shelves Dual Fuel BBQ Grill for Outdoor Barbecue Read More ↓
Product Comparison: Propane And Charcoal Grill
Grills House 2-Burner Gas and Charcoal Combo Grill with Offset Smoker & Side Burner, 34,000 BTU Dual Fuel Grill, 1020 Sq. In. Cooking Area, Ideal for Outdoor Cooking, Black, ZH3005Y-SC
The Grills House 2-Burner Gas and Charcoal Combo Grill is a powerhouse for outdoor cooking enthusiasts who want the best of both worlds. With a massive 1020 sq.
in. cooking surface, it includes dedicated gas and charcoal zones, an offset smoker, and a side burner—perfect for searing, smoking, or simmering sauces.
The 34,000 BTU output ensures fast, even heating, while the piezo ignition offers reliable startup. The adjustable charcoal pan allows precise heat control for slow-cooking or high-heat grilling.
Durable construction and smart features like an ash-access door enhance usability. Ideal for large gatherings, this grill delivers versatility and performance for serious backyard chefs.
✓ Reasons to Buy
- Dual-fuel flexibility
- Huge cooking space
- Built-in smoker
- Powerful 34,000 BTU
- Easy ignition system
✗ Reasons Not to Buy
- Bulky design
- Heavy and hard to move
- Complex assembly
Captiva Designs Propane Gas Grill and Charcoal Grill Combo with Side Burner & Porcelain-Enameled Cast Iron Grate, Dual Fuel BBQ Grill for Outdoor Events & Backyard Barbecue, 690 SQIN Cooking Area
The Captiva Designs Propane and Charcoal Combo Grill blends convenience and flavor in a sleek, user-friendly package. With 690 sq.
in. of cooking area, including porcelain-enameled cast iron grates, it offers even heat distribution and excellent searing capability.
The independently controlled gas and charcoal zones let you cook different foods simultaneously, while the side burner adds extra versatility. Cleanup is a breeze thanks to slide-out grease and ash trays with a tilted design for efficient drainage.
The spacious 61-inch counter provides ample room for food prep. Durable materials and responsive customer service make this a reliable choice for regular grillers who value ease of use and consistent results.
✓ Reasons to Buy
- Easy cleanup system
- Durable enameled grates
- Spacious prep counter
- Independent fuel control
- Excellent customer support
✗ Reasons Not to Buy
- Smaller cooking area
- No smoker included
- Side burner less powerful
Oklahoma Joe’s Canyon Combo Charcoal and Gas Smoker & Grill, Black – 24203004
The Oklahoma Joe’s Canyon Combo is a powerhouse for serious grillers who want both charcoal smoking and gas grilling in one rugged unit. Its 750-square-inch main cooking area handles large cuts like pork shoulders with ease, while the side firebox allows low-and-slow smoking using charcoal and wood chunks.
The 3-burner propane grill delivers 36,000 BTUs for quick searing and even heating. Features like adjustable dampers, a removable ash pan, and handy tool hooks make managing heat and cleanup simple.
Built tough with a durable steel frame, it’s ideal for weekend warriors and BBQ enthusiasts who demand versatility and control in their outdoor cooking.
✓ Reasons to Buy
- Large cooking space
- Dual fuel flexibility
- Excellent heat control
- Durable steel construction
- Easy ash cleanup
✗ Reasons Not to Buy
- Heavy and bulky
- Assembly takes time
- Higher price point
GRILL DEPOTS Griddle Grill Combo, Propane Gas and Charcoal Grill Combo, Outdoor BBQ Grills, 4 Burner Propane Stove with Griddle, Cast Iron Grates, Side Burner & Prep Space
The GRILL DEPOTS Griddle Grill Combo offers impressive 3-in-1 functionality, combining a propane gas grill, charcoal grilling zones, and a stainless steel griddle in one compact design. With 46,750 total BTUs from five burners, it heats up quickly and maintains strong performance across its 340 sq.
in. primary cooking surface.
The removable griddle is perfect for breakfast foods or stir-fries, while the dual charcoal basins add authentic smoky flavor. The included warming rack expands capacity, making it great for entertaining.
Sturdy construction and efficient heat distribution make this a versatile option for those who love diverse cooking styles without needing multiple units.
✓ Reasons to Buy
- 3-in-1 cooking options
- Fast heating burners
- Spacious cooking area
- Great for entertaining
- Easy to clean griddle
✗ Reasons Not to Buy
- Charcoal trays small
- Limited smoker function
- Heavy unit
Char-Griller® Dual-Function 2-Burner 24,000 BTU Propane Gas and Charcoal Combination Grill and Smoker with 870 Cooking Square Inches in Black, Model E5030
The Char-Griller Dual-Function 2-Burner Grill offers the best of both worlds with its propane and charcoal combo design, perfect for grilling enthusiasts who crave versatility. With a massive 870 square inches of total cooking space and 24,000 BTUs, it delivers powerful, even heat.
The porcelain-coated cast iron grates retain heat well and resist rust, while the easy-dump ash pan simplifies cleanup. Its sturdy build and dual fuel options make it ideal for smoking, searing, or slow cooking.
Whether you’re hosting a backyard BBQ or weekday dinner, this grill handles it all with reliable performance and excellent temperature control.
✓ Reasons to Buy
- Large cooking area
- Dual-fuel flexibility
- Durable porcelain grates
- High BTU output
- Easy ash removal
✗ Reasons Not to Buy
- Heavy and bulky
- Assembly required
- Propane tank not included
Propane and Charcoal Grill Combo, Gas Griddle Grill Combo Two Fuel BBQ Grills with Long Silicone Non-Slip Grill Gloves, Dual Fuel Lids and Side Shelves
The LLAMA VIVA Propane and Charcoal Grill Combo blends convenience and flavor in a compact, efficient design. Featuring 12,000 BTU burners and dual fuel zones, it lets you cook with gas on one side and charcoal on the other—perfect for simultaneous grilling and griddling.
The 327 sq. in.
cooking surface includes a cast iron griddle for pancakes, veggies, or burgers. It comes with heat-resistant BBQ gloves (up to 1472°F), side shelves for prep, and handy storage hooks.
The sliding ash tray and grease slot make cleanup easy. Ideal for small patios or tailgating, it’s a smart choice for versatile outdoor cooking.
✓ Reasons to Buy
- Compact and portable
- Dual cooking zones
- Includes heat-resistant gloves
- Easy to clean
- Extra prep shelves
✗ Reasons Not to Buy
- Smaller cooking area
- Lower BTU output
- Less durable than premium models
GRILL DEPOTS Propane Gas and Charcoal Grill Combo | Griddle Grill with Side Burner | BBQ Grills 2-in-1 | 41,500 BTU Output, 673 SQ IN Cooking Area Perfect for Outdoor Events & Backyard Barbecue
The GRILL DEPOTS Propane Gas and Charcoal Grill Combo offers unmatched versatility for serious backyard chefs. With a 4-burner gas grill and charcoal grill side by side, you can sear over charcoal while simmering on gas—perfect for entertaining.
The 673-square-inch cooking surface includes a grooved cast iron griddle and perforated pan for even heating and smoky flavor. Three 10,000 BTU burners and a 9,000 BTU side burner handle large meals with ease.
Durable double-layer stainless steel lid resists warping, while the pull-out drip tray simplifies cleanup. Four wheels allow easy mobility, and the side prep table keeps tools close.
Built to last, it’s ideal for grilling enthusiasts who want the best of both fuel types.
✓ Reasons to Buy
- Versatile dual-fuel design
- Large 673 sq in cooking area
- Durable stainless steel lid
- Includes griddle and griddle pan
- Easy grease management system
✗ Reasons Not to Buy
- Heavy and bulky
- Higher price point
- Assembly takes time
Royal Gourmet ZH3002N Propane Gas and Charcoal Grill Combo, Dual Fuel BBQ Grill with 2 Side Shelves for Outdoor Patio Garden Backyard Barbecue, 20,000 BTUs, Silver & Black
The Royal Gourmet ZH3002N combines propane and charcoal grilling in one efficient unit, perfect for home cooks who want flexibility without sacrificing space. This dual-fuel grill features a 2-burner gas side and a charcoal section, delivering authentic smoky flavor alongside quick gas convenience.
With a massive 759 square inches of cooking area, it can handle up to 30 burgers at once—ideal for gatherings. The two side shelves provide ample prep space, and integrated hooks keep tools handy.
Large wheels and lockable casters make repositioning simple. Cleanup is easy thanks to a slide-out ash tray and removable grease cup.
While compact in footprint, it maximizes cooking real estate for consistent results.
✓ Reasons to Buy
- Huge 759 sq in cooking space
- Easy ash and grease cleanup
- Compact with large capacity
- Affordable dual-fuel option
- Smooth mobility with lockable wheels
✗ Reasons Not to Buy
- Only 2 gas burners
- Less BTU power
- Charcoal side heats unevenly
Propane Gas Griddle Charcoal Grill Combo Flat Top Griddle W/Dual Lids & 2 Side Shelves Dual Fuel BBQ Grill for Outdoor Barbecue
The BESTFIRE Propane Gas Griddle Charcoal Grill Combo offers the best of both worlds with dual fuel capability, letting you switch between propane convenience and charcoal flavor effortlessly. Featuring a U-shaped stainless steel burner with 12,000 BTU output and a generous 327 sq.
in. cooking space, it includes a 187 sq.
in. cast-iron griddle and 140 sq.
in. grill grate—perfect for burgers, pancakes, or searing meats.
Dual lids, side shelves, and a built-in condiment rack enhance usability, while lockable wheels ensure portability. Cleanup is simple thanks to a slide-out grease trap and ash tray.
✓ Reasons to Buy
- Dual fuel flexibility
- Large cooking space
- Easy cleanup design
- Sturdy, portable build
- Ample prep area
✗ Reasons Not to Buy
- Heavy at 75 lbs
- Assembly takes time
- Premium price point
Product prices and availability are accurate as of the date/time indicated and are subject to change. Any price and availability information displayed on Amazon.com at the time of purchase will apply to the purchase of this product.
Buying Guide
FAQs
What should I look for when choosing between a propane and charcoal grill?
Consider your cooking preferences, convenience, and flavor goals. Propane grills offer quick start-up, precise temperature control, and easy cleanup, making them ideal for busy weeknights. Charcoal grills provide a smoky, traditional flavor and higher searing temperatures, preferred by grilling enthusiasts. Think about how much time you want to spend prepping and cleaning versus achieving authentic barbecue taste.
How do propane and charcoal grills compare in terms of cooking performance?
Propane grills heat up faster and maintain consistent temperatures, which is great for even cooking. Charcoal grills take longer to heat but can reach higher temperatures for better searing. Charcoal also imparts a distinct smoky flavor that propane typically doesn’t. However, with smoker boxes, propane grills can mimic some of that flavor.
Which type of grill is more cost-effective over time?
Propane grills usually have a higher upfront cost but are cheaper to operate per use with standard propane tanks. Charcoal grills are often less expensive to buy initially, but ongoing charcoal and lighter fluid costs add up. Propane also reduces waste and cleanup time, adding to long-term value.
Are there maintenance differences between propane and charcoal grills?
Yes, propane grills require checking hoses, burners, and gas connections regularly for safety and performance. Charcoal grills need ash cleanup after every use and are more prone to rust if not properly maintained. Propane models are generally easier to clean, while charcoal grills demand more post-grill attention.
Can I get the same flavor from a propane grill as a charcoal grill?
While propane burns cleaner and lacks inherent smokiness, you can enhance flavor using wood chips or smoker boxes. Soaking wood chips and placing them over burners adds a smoky aroma during cooking. It’s not identical to charcoal, but many find the results satisfactory for everyday grilling.
Which grill type is better for beginners?
Propane grills are typically better for beginners due to their ease of use and consistent results. Igniting is as simple as turning a knob, and temperature adjustments are immediate. Charcoal requires more skill to manage heat and lighting, which can be intimidating for new users.
Do propane grills work well in cold weather?
Propane grills perform reliably in cold temperatures, though propane vaporizes less efficiently below freezing. Keeping tanks upright and outdoors (not indoors) helps maintain performance. Charcoal can also work in cold weather but may require more fuel to maintain heat.
What safety considerations should I keep in mind?
With propane, always check for gas leaks and ensure proper ventilation to prevent carbon monoxide buildup. Charcoal grills produce carbon monoxide too and should never be used indoors or in enclosed spaces. Both types require stable placement and a fire extinguisher nearby for safety.