Comparison: Best Pittmoss Organic Potting Mix (Updated | Nov 11th)
If you’re on the hunt for a top-tier organic potting mix, you’ve probably come across PittMoss. But is it really the best out there? Whether you’re growing herbs on a windowsill or tomatoes in a raised bed, choosing the right mix matters. Let’s break down what makes PittMoss stand out—or fall short—so you can make the smartest choice for your garden.
Editor’s Choice
Best for a specific purpose
- Best for eco 10-quart: PittMoss Plentiful Eco-Friendly
- Best for 2-cu-ft eco: PittMoss Plentiful Eco-Friendly
- Best for bundle eco pack: PittMoss Plentiful Eco-Friendly
- Best for 10-quart duo: PittMoss Plentiful Eco-Friendly
- Best for controlled release: PittMoss Performance Peat Free Potting Mix with Controlled Release Fertilizer
- Best for triple 10-quart: PittMoss Plentiful Eco-Friendly
- Best for single-bag performance: PittMoss Performance Peat Free Potting Mix with Controlled Release Fertilizer
- Best for premium organic blend: Back to the Roots 100% Organic Potting Mix (Value 12 Quart) | Premium Blend | Made in The USA
- Best for compact eco mix: PittMoss Plentiful Eco-Friendly
- Best for soil aeration boost: PittMoss Prime Eco-Friendly
Product Comparison: Best Pittmoss Organic Potting Mix
Eco 10-Quart
PittMoss Plentiful Eco-Friendly, Organic, Peat-Free Potting Mix, 10 Quarts – for Gardens, Houseplants, Mulching & More – Made in USA from Recycled Paper
PittMoss
- Adaptable Feeding: This 10-quart bag of peat-free, organic potting mix has a nutrient composition of N (0.176%) P (0.100%) K (0.024%), which helps improve soil environments and maintain a pH balance that is adaptable to meet the specific requirements of each plant.
- Efficient Watering: Due to its ability to retain applied resources and evenly distribute them throughout the porous particles to make them more readily available to the plant’s roots, this product can reduce water usage by two-thirds.
- Peat-Free Potting Mix: The perfect all-purpose potting mix for raised beds, vegetable gardening, potted plants, seedlings, mulching and any other applications where traditional potting mix is typically applied.
- Organic Garden Safe: This product is OMRI-listed for organic growing and features less dust than traditional soil mediums with no pathogens, bugs, weed seeds, heavy metals and other harmful ingredients.
- Made Responsibly in the USA: Proudly produced in the United States from 99% recycled paper fibers and small amounts of organic bark enriched with poultry manure, bovine compost inoculates and feather meal. All paper ingredients are sourced from local recycling facilities and hand sorted to ensure zero contaminants
2-Cu-Ft Eco
PittMoss Plentiful Eco-Friendly, Organic, Peat-Free Potting Mix, 2 Cubic Feet for Gardens, Houseplants, Mulching & More – Made in USA from Recycled Paper
PittMoss
- Adaptable Feeding: This 2 cubic foot bag of peat-free, organic potting mix has a nutrient composition of N (0.176%) P (0.100%) K (0.024%), which helps improve soil environments and maintain a pH balance that is adaptable to meet the specific requirements of each plant.
- Efficient Watering: Due to its ability to retain applied resources and evenly distribute them throughout the porous particles to make them more readily available to the plant’s roots, this product can reduce water usage by two-thirds.
- Peat-Free Potting Mix: The perfect all-purpose potting mix for raised beds, vegetable gardening, potted plants, seedlings, mulching and any other applications where traditional potting mix is typically applied.
- Organic Garden Safe: This product is OMRI-listed for organic growing and features less dust than traditional soil mediums with no pathogens, bugs, weed seeds, heavy metals and other harmful ingredients.
- Made Responsibly in the USA: Proudly produced in the United States from 99% recycled paper fibers and small amounts of organic bark enriched with poultry manure, bovine compost inoculates and feather meal. All paper ingredients are sourced from local recycling facilities and hand sorted to ensure zero contaminants
Bundle Eco Pack
PittMoss Plentiful Eco-Friendly, Organic, Peat-Free Potting Mix, 2 Cubic Feet (Pack of 2) for Gardens, Houseplants, Mulching & More – Made in USA from Recycled Paper
PittMoss
- Adaptable Feeding: These (2) 2 cubic foot bags of peat-free, organic potting mix have a nutrient composition of N (0.176%) P (0.100%) K (0.024%), which helps improve soil environments and maintain a pH balance that is adaptable to meet the specific requirements of each plant.
- Efficient Watering: Due to its ability to retain applied resources and evenly distribute them throughout the porous particles to make them more readily available to the plant’s roots, this product can reduce water usage by two-thirds.
- Peat-Free Potting Mix: The perfect all-purpose potting mix for raised beds, vegetable gardening, potted plants, seedlings, mulching and any other applications where traditional potting mix is typically applied.
- Organic Garden Safe: This product is OMRI-listed for organic growing and features less dust than traditional soil mediums with no pathogens, bugs, weed seeds, heavy metals and other harmful ingredients.
- Made Responsibly in the USA: Proudly produced in the United States from 99% recycled paper fibers and small amounts of organic bark enriched with poultry manure, bovine compost inoculates and feather meal. All paper ingredients are sourced from local recycling facilities and hand sorted to ensure zero contaminants
10-Quart Duo
PittMoss Plentiful Eco-Friendly, Organic, Peat-Free Potting Mix, 10 Quarts (Pack of 2) – for Gardens, Houseplants, Mulching & More – Made in USA from Recycled Paper
PittMoss
- Adaptable Feeding: These (2) 10-quart bags of peat-free, organic potting mix have a nutrient composition of N (0.176%) P (0.100%) K (0.024%), which helps improve soil environments and maintain a pH balance that is adaptable to meet the specific requirements of each plant.
- Efficient Watering: Due to its ability to retain applied resources and evenly distribute them throughout the porous particles to make them more readily available to the plant’s roots, this product can reduce water usage by two-thirds.
- Peat-Free Potting Mix: The perfect all-purpose potting mix for raised beds, vegetable gardening, potted plants, seedlings, mulching and any other applications where traditional potting mix is typically applied.
- Organic Garden Safe: This product is OMRI-listed for organic growing and features less dust than traditional soil mediums with no pathogens, bugs, weed seeds, heavy metals and other harmful ingredients.
- Made Responsibly in the USA: Proudly produced in the United States from 99% recycled paper fibers and small amounts of organic bark enriched with poultry manure, bovine compost inoculates and feather meal. All paper ingredients are sourced from local recycling facilities and hand sorted to ensure zero contaminants
Controlled Release
PittMoss Performance Peat Free Potting Mix with Controlled Release Fertilizer, 2 cu ft
PittMoss
- Peat Alternative Potting Soil: This 2 cubic foot bag of peat-free, nutrient-rich potting mix serves as the perfect all-purpose, nutrient enhanced potting mix for indoor containers, flower beds, soil improvement, grass seeding, and any other applications where traditional potting mix is typically applied.
- Time-Release Feeding: Pittmoss Performance is fertilized with a custom Controlled Release Fertilizer (CRF) that ensures a steady supply of nutrients to your plants, while also maintaining a pH balance adaptable to the specific requirements of each plant.
- Efficient Watering: Due to its ability to retain applied resources and evenly distribute them throughout the porous particles to make them more readily available to the plant’s roots, this product requires less water and fertilizer.
- Made Responsibly in the USA: PittMoss Performance is proudly produced in the United States from 99.4% recycled paper fibers and small amounts of organic bark. It has a nutrient composition of N (0.24%) P (0.11%) K (0.18%), which helps stimulate biological development.
- Worry-Free Garden Support: PittMoss sources all paper ingredients from local recycling facilities, hand sorts each batch to ensure zero contaminants and conducts extensive testing to create a perfect living soil environment. This soilless growing medium is lightweight and produces less dust than traditional soil mediums. Additionally, it is free from pathogens, weed seeds, heavy metals, and other harmful ingredients.
Triple 10-Quart
PittMoss Plentiful Eco-Friendly, Organic, Peat-Free Potting Mix, 10 Quarts (Pack of 3) for Gardens, Houseplants, Mulching & More – Made in USA from Recycled Paper
PittMoss
- Adaptable Feeding: These (3) 10-quart bags of peat-free, organic potting mix have a nutrient composition of N (0.176%) P (0.100%) K (0.024%), which helps improve soil environments and maintain a pH balance that is adaptable to meet the specific requirements of each plant.
- Efficient Watering: Due to its ability to retain applied resources and evenly distribute them throughout the porous particles to make them more readily available to the plant’s roots, this product can reduce water usage by two-thirds.
- Peat-Free Potting Mix: The perfect all-purpose potting mix for raised beds, vegetable gardening, potted plants, seedlings, mulching and any other applications where traditional potting mix is typically applied.
- Organic Garden Safe: This product is OMRI-listed for organic growing and features less dust than traditional soil mediums with no pathogens, bugs, weed seeds, heavy metals and other harmful ingredients.
- Made Responsibly in the USA: Proudly produced in the United States from 99% recycled paper fibers and small amounts of organic bark enriched with poultry manure, bovine compost inoculates and feather meal. All paper ingredients are sourced from local recycling facilities and hand sorted to ensure zero contaminants
Single-Bag Performance
PittMoss Performance Peat Free Potting Mix with Controlled Release Fertilizer, 1 cu ft
PittMoss
- Peat Alternative Potting Soil: This 1 cubic foot bag of peat-free, nutrient-rich potting mix serves as the perfect all-purpose, nutrient enhanced potting mix for indoor containers, flower beds, soil improvement, grass seeding, and any other applications where traditional potting mix is typically applied.
- Time-Release Feeding: Pittmoss Performance is fertilized with a custom Controlled Release Fertilizer (CRF) that ensures a steady supply of nutrients to your plants, while also maintaining a pH balance adaptable to the specific requirements of each plant.
- Efficient Watering: Due to its ability to retain applied resources and evenly distribute them throughout the porous particles to make them more readily available to the plant’s roots, this product requires less water and fertilizer.
- Made Responsibly in the USA: PittMoss Performance is proudly produced in the United States from 99.4% recycled paper fibers and small amounts of organic bark. It has a nutrient composition of N (0.24%) P (0.11%) K (0.18%), which helps stimulate biological development.
- Worry-Free Garden Support: PittMoss sources all paper ingredients from local recycling facilities, hand sorts each batch to ensure zero contaminants and conducts extensive testing to create a perfect living soil environment. This soilless growing medium is lightweight and produces less dust than traditional soil mediums. Additionally, it is free from pathogens, weed seeds, heavy metals, and other harmful ingredients.
Premium Organic Blend
Back to the Roots 100% Organic Potting Mix (Value 12 Quart) | Premium Blend | Made in The USA
Back to the Roots
- 100% Organic and Peat-Free: Our potting mix is 100% organic and peat-free—made from upcycled plant matter and wood fines from across the U.S. No imported peat, just better soil with a lighter carbon footprint.
- All-Purpose: Our premium potting mix is versatile and well-suited for herbs, veggies, fruits, and flowers. It caters to all your gardening needs, and is proudly made in the USA.
- Better Moisture Control and pH Balance: Our premium soil blend incorporates yucca extract for moisture control and dolomitic limestone for pH balancing.
- 100% Satisfaction Guarantee: Not satisfied? Let us know. Our support team will get you growing with a replacement or refund—no questions asked.
- GROWONEGIVEONE — Share a photo of your growing garden and we’ll donate a Kids Grow Kit and STEM elementary school curriculum to a classroom of your choice.
Compact Eco Mix
PittMoss Plentiful Eco-Friendly, Organic, Peat-Free Potting Mix, 1 Cubic Foot for Gardens, Houseplants, Mulching & More – Made in USA from Recycled Paper
PittMoss
- Adaptable Feeding: This 1 cubic foot bag of peat-free, organic potting mix has a nutrient composition of N (0.176%) P (0.100%) K (0.024%), which helps improve soil environments and maintain a pH balance that is adaptable to meet the specific requirements of each plant.
- Efficient Watering: Due to its ability to retain applied resources and evenly distribute them throughout the porous particles to make them more readily available to the plant’s roots, this product can reduce water usage by two-thirds.
- Peat-Free Potting Mix: The perfect all-purpose potting mix for raised beds, vegetable gardening, potted plants, seedlings, mulching and any other applications where traditional potting mix is typically applied.
- Organic Garden Safe: This product is OMRI-listed for organic growing and features less dust than traditional soil mediums with no pathogens, bugs, weed seeds, heavy metals and other harmful ingredients.
- Made Responsibly in the USA: Proudly produced in the United States from 99% recycled paper fibers and small amounts of organic bark enriched with poultry manure, bovine compost inoculates and feather meal. All paper ingredients are sourced from local recycling facilities and hand sorted to ensure zero contaminants
Soil Aeration Boost
PittMoss Prime Eco-Friendly, Organic, Peat-Free Soil Amendment, 2 Cubic Feet – for Gardens, Grass Seeding, Mulching & More – Made in USA from Recycled Paper
PittMoss
- Aerates Soil and Supports Drainage: This 2 cubic foot bag of peat-free organic soil conditioner is the ideal solution designed to be mixed with compost, fertilizer, or other garden soils for improving and establishing lawns, planting trees and shrubs, and replacing peat in potting soil blends.
- Efficient Watering: Due to its ability to retain applied resources and evenly distribute them throughout the porous particles to make them more readily available to the plant’s roots, this product requires less water.
- Made Responsibly in the USA: PittMoss Prime is proudly produced in the United States from 99.9% recycled paper fibers and small amounts of organic bark.
- Organic Garden Safe: It is OMRI-listed for organic growing, features less dust than traditional soil amendments and is free of pathogens, bugs, weed seeds, heavy metals and other harmful ingredients.
- Worry-Free Garden Support: PittMoss sources all paper ingredients from local recycling facilities, hand sorts each batch to ensure zero contaminants and conducts extensive testing to create a perfect living soil environment.
Product prices and availability are accurate as of the date/time indicated and are subject to change. Any price and availability information displayed on Amazon.com at the time of purchase will apply to the purchase of this product.
Buying Guide
FAQs
What are the main differences between the PittMoss Plentiful and PittMoss Performance mixes?
Plentiful is an all‑purpose, peat‑free blend focused on organic, recyclable paper fibers and a modest nutrient profile (N 0.176%, P 0.100%, K 0.024%). Performance adds a controlled‑release fertilizer with higher nutrients (N 0.24%, P 0.11%, K 0.18%) for faster growth, especially in containers and indoor settings. Both are OMRI‑listed and water‑efficient, but Performance is geared toward gardeners who want built‑in feeding.
How should I choose the right bag size for my garden?
If you are filling raised beds or large outdoor plots, the 2‑cubic‑foot or multi‑bag options (e.g., three 10‑quart bags) give you enough volume without frequent refills. For small container gardening, seed starting, or indoor plants, a 1‑cubic‑foot or single 10‑quart bag is more economical and easier to handle. Consider the total soil volume you need and whether you prefer to buy in bulk for cost savings.
Is PittMoss truly peat‑free and environmentally friendly?
Yes, every PittMoss product is made from 99% recycled paper fibers, with only small amounts of organic bark, poultry manure, or feather meal added for nutrition. The mix is produced in the USA using locally sourced recycled material, which reduces carbon footprint compared to traditional peat‑based soils. It also contains no pathogens, weed seeds, or heavy metals.
How does the Back to the Roots organic potting mix compare to PittMoss?
Back to the Roots offers a 100% organic, peat‑free blend made from upcycled plant matter and wood fines, similar to PittMoss’s recycled paper base. However, it includes yucca extract for moisture control and dolomitic limestone for pH balance, while PittMoss emphasizes water‑saving porosity and optional controlled‑release fertilizer in the Performance line. Pricing and bag sizes differ, so compare your specific garden needs and any brand‑specific guarantees.
Will the PittMoss mixes work for both vegetables and ornamental plants?
Absolutely. The Plentiful mix is marketed as an all‑purpose medium suitable for raised beds, vegetable gardening, seedlings, and ornamental containers. Performance adds extra nutrients that benefit heavy‑feeding vegetables and flowering plants alike. Both mixes maintain a balanced pH and provide excellent aeration, supporting a wide range of plant types.
What value does the controlled‑release fertilizer in PittMoss Performance provide?
The controlled‑release fertilizer (CRF) supplies a steady stream of nutrients over several weeks, reducing the need for frequent supplemental feeding. This can lead to healthier, faster‑growing plants and lower overall fertilizer costs. It also helps maintain consistent pH, which is especially beneficial for indoor growers who cannot easily amend soil.
Are there any special handling or storage tips for these mixes?
All PittMoss products generate less dust than traditional soils, but it’s still a good idea to wear a mask when bagging large volumes. Store bags in a dry, cool place to prevent moisture buildup, which could lead to clumping. Keep the mix sealed until use to preserve its nutrient balance and prevent contamination.
Which product offers the best cost‑per‑cubic‑foot value?
Generally, the multi‑bag options (e.g., three 10‑quart bags or the 2‑cubic‑foot bags) provide a lower cost per cubic foot compared to single‑bag purchases. PittMoss Plentiful’s larger packs tend to be the most economical for bulk applications, while Performance’s higher nutrient content justifies a slightly higher price for growers needing rapid feeding. Compare unit prices on the product page to confirm the best deal.