Comparison: Best Black Gold Organic Garden Soil (Updated | Nov 11th)
If you’ve ever wondered why some gardens burst with life while others struggle, the secret often lies in the soil. In this honest comparison, we dig into what makes Black Gold stand out—its ingredients, performance, and value—while weighing it against top competitors. Whether you’re growing veggies, flowers, or herbs, let’s find the organic soil that truly earns its place in your garden.
- Best for two-pack soil: Black Gold 1302040 8-Quart All Organic Potting Soil 2 Pack
- Best for standard 16-qt: Natural & Organic Potting Mix
- Best for earthworm enriched: SUNGRO HORTICULTURE Black Gold 1302040 16-Quart All Organic Potting Soil
- Best for moisture master: Black Gold Natural and Organic Raised Bed and Potting Mix 1.5 cubic foot
- Best for triple pack value: Black Gold 16-Quart All Organic Potting Soil
- Best for seedling starter: Black Gold Seedling Mix
- Best for all-purpose premium: Sun Gro SUGRBG2 13020402 Black Gold Natural and Organic Soil
- Best for indoor outdoor blend: Black Gold Organic in/Outdoor Potting Soil
Product Comparison: Best Black Gold Organic Garden Soil
SUNGRO HORTICULTURE Black Gold 1302040 16-Quart All Organic Potting Soil
- Ideal for all container-grown flowers, herbs and vegetables
- Enriched with earthworm castings, perlite, pumice and organic fertilizer
- OMRI listed organic
- 16 quart bag
- Packaging may vary
- Listed by the organic materials review institute for the production of organic food and fiber
- Rich, loamy mix is one of the best for all gardening applications
- Perlite and pumice are added to ensure optimum pore and air space for sturdy growth
- Use in hanging baskets, patio containers, herb gardens, vegetable plantings, and anywhere you would like to use an organic soil
- Regionally formulated, western region only , Packaging may vary
Black Gold Natural and Organic Raised Bed and Potting Mix 1.5 cubic foot
- Provides superior moisture
Black Gold Seedling Mix, 8 quart
- Black Gold Seedling Mix 8qt Listed by the Organic Materials Review Institute for the production of organic food and fiber
- This mix combines double screened Canadian Sphagnum Peat Moss and other fine ingredients to give seedlings the aeration and moisture retention they need for strong development
- This product is made in United States
- Listed by the organic materials review institute for the production of organic food and fiber
- Combines double screened Canadian sphagnum peat moss and other fine ingredients to give seedlings the aeration and moisture retention they need for strong development
- Contains Canadian sphagnum peat moss, perlite, dolomite lime, and an organic wetting agent
- Use for germinating seeds in flats, pots, and plug trays
- 8-Quart
Sun Gro SUGRBG2 13020402 Black Gold Natural and Organic Soil, 2 Cubic Feet, Brown
- Not sold in OR
- Natural and organic potting soil plus fertilizer
- This natural and organic potting soils rich, loamy mix is a premium choice for all-purpose gardening applications
- 100 percent organic base consists of screened earthworm castings, canadian sphagnum peat moss, etc
- Blend in perlite and pumice to ensure optimum aeration
- Available in 2-cubic feet
Black Gold Organic in/Outdoor Potting Soil, 16 Quart Bag (2)
Product prices and availability are accurate as of the date/time indicated and are subject to change. Any price and availability information displayed on Amazon.com at the time of purchase will apply to the purchase of this product.
Buying Guide
FAQs
What are the key factors to consider when choosing a Black Gold organic potting soil?
Look at the container size you need, the blend of ingredients (such as earthworm castings, perlite, and peat), and any certifications like OMRI listing. Moisture retention, aeration, and added fertilizer content affect plant health and watering frequency. Also compare price per quart or cubic foot to gauge value.
How does the 8‑Quart 2‑Pack (B07SQ3HXYY) compare to the single 16‑Quart bag (B075WPK921) in terms of cost and convenience?
The 2‑Pack provides 16 quarts total, similar to the single 16‑quart bag, but the smaller packages may be easier to store and allow you to open one bag at a time. Pricing often favors the larger single bag for bulk savings, though promotional deals can make the 2‑Pack competitive. Choose based on your storage space and how quickly you plan to use the soil.
Is there a performance difference between the standard Black Gold potting mix and the Seedling Mix (B004NSBNAQ)?
The Seedling Mix is formulated with double‑screened Canadian sphagnum peat moss and fine ingredients to give seedlings superior aeration and moisture retention, which promotes strong early growth. The standard potting mix contains earthworm castings, perlite, and pumice, making it better suited for mature plants, herbs, and vegetables. Use the Seedling Mix for germination and transplanting, then switch to the regular mix for established plants.
What advantages does the 1.5 cubic‑foot raised‑bed mix (B08DT4QBPX) offer over the 16‑quart bags?
The 1.5 cubic‑foot bag provides a larger volume, reducing the number of bags you need to handle and often delivering a lower cost per unit of soil. It is marketed for raised‑bed applications and promises superior moisture management, which can be beneficial for larger garden projects. If you are filling a raised bed or need a substantial amount of soil at once, this size is more convenient.
How important is the OMRI listing found on some Black Gold products?
An OMRI (Organic Materials Review Institute) listing confirms that the soil meets strict organic standards, which is crucial for growers who want certified organic produce. Products without the listing may still be organic but haven’t undergone the formal certification process. If organic certification matters for your market or personal standards, prioritize the OMRI‑listed options.
Do the added perlite and pumice in the Black Gold mixes affect watering schedules?
Yes, perlite and pumice improve aeration and drainage, helping excess water move through the soil while still retaining enough moisture for roots. This balance often reduces the frequency of watering compared to denser, non‑amended soils. However, exact watering needs will still depend on plant type, climate, and container size.
Which Black Gold product provides the best overall value for a mixed vegetable garden?
For a mixed vegetable garden, the 16‑quart 3‑Pack (B075WPK921) or the 16‑quart single bag (B075WPK921) typically offers the best value, combining a generous volume with the full organic blend of earthworm castings, peat, perlite, and pumice. These mixes are OMRI listed and designed for container‑grown vegetables, providing balanced nutrition and moisture control. Compare the per‑quart price and any bulk discounts to decide which pack fits your budget.