ProGardenReview is reader-supported, which means when you buy through links on this site, I may earn a small commission. Read full disclosure.

Comparison: Best Fireplace (Updated | Dec 18th)

Looking to transform your living space into a warm, inviting sanctuary? The perfect fireplace can be the heart of your home, creating ambiance and comfort during those chilly evenings. That’s why we’ve done the research for you, comparing the top fireplaces across different categories. Whether you prioritize efficiency, aesthetics, or ease of installation, our comprehensive guide will help you find the perfect centerpiece for your home.

Product Comparison: Best Fireplace

Classic Stove Heater

duraflame Freestanding Electric Fireplace Stove Heater with 3D Flame Effect for 1,000 Sq. Ft. Room, Black

duraflame Freestanding Electric Fireplace Stove Heater with 3D Flame Effect for 1,000 Sq. Ft. Room, Black

Duraflame
  • Charming Design: Includes side viewing windows, a glass door that really opens, and a brick-style back panel. This stove heater not only enhances your décor but delivers infrared heat in any room up to 1,000 square feet. Easily carry this portable heater to any room you wish.
  • Money-Saving Heater: Supplemental heating is an effective way to provide comfort to your home, without having to warm every room. Save money on your next energy bill by lowering the thermostat and using this using this heater when and where you need it most.
  • Glowing Logs and 3D Flames: Bring the cozy cabin vibes to your home with the realistic flame effect. The glowing logs and soothing flames help you unwind as you relax on the couch and sip your favorite beverage; or, turn down the brightness levels for a perfect nightlight while you slumber.
  • Year-Round Glow: With independent flame and heat controls, you can enjoy the cozy glow of your fireplace even while the heat is off for a beautiful ambiance in every season.
  • Adjustable Settings:. Enjoy an adjustable thermostat and flame dial that will customize your fire to the ideal look and temperature.

Check price

Smart Safety Choice

Sweetcrispy Freestanding Electric Fireplace Heater, 26”Two Door Fireplace with 3D Flame Effect, Overheating Safe Design, Energy Saving Space Heater with 12H Timer&Remote for Living Room, Bedroom,Black

Sweetcrispy Freestanding Electric Fireplace Heater, 26”Two Door Fireplace with 3D Flame Effect, Overheating Safe Design, Energy Saving Space Heater with 12H Timer&Remote for Living Room, Bedroom,Black

Sweetcrispy
  • Powerful Fireplace Heater: This freestanding electric fireplace heater offers adjustable heat settings ranging from 750W for a gentle warmth to 1500W for a powerful heat. Whether it’s chilly mornings or cold nights, the powerful heater provides consistent and efficient warmth, keeping your space comfortable throughout the seasons
  • Safety Features: For your peace of mind, Sweetcrispy electric fireplace includes built-in overheating protection that automatically turns off the unit if it gets too hot. The child lock function ensures safety in homes, preventing accidental adjustments. Enjoy a safe and secure environment while relaxing by the fire
  • Free Control: Take complete control with the included remote or use the easy-to-operate control panel on the unit itself. Adjust the temperature, flame intensity, and other settings effortlessly from across the room or directly at the stove. The flexibility of both options provides maximum convenience
  • Various Flame Effects: With the dazzling 3D flame effect of this led fireplace, you can personalize your atmosphere. There are various flame lightness to choose from to suit your mood or decoration style, turning any room into a cozy and pleasant place to relax
  • Energy-Saving Timer: Sweetcrispy fireplace heater is designed with energy-saving in mind. The built-in timer allows you to set it to automatically turn off after a preset time, reducing unnecessary energy consumption

Check price

Premium Glass Design

LumaForest 48-3 Sided Glass, Mirrored Back Electric Fireplace, Split logs, Remote, Realistic Flame, Multiple Flame Settings, and Mobile app

LumaForest 48-3 Sided Glass, Mirrored Back Electric Fireplace, Split logs, Remote, Realistic Flame, Multiple Flame Settings, and Mobile app

Amantii
  • Hardwireable for 10,000 BTU: Upgrade to hardwiring for enhanced heating power and performance.
  • Flame Color Options: Enjoy vibrant yellow, orange with the ability to create personalized color blends.
  • Canopy and Tray Lighting: Enhance the ambiance with customizable lighting effects.
  • Three-Sided Glass Design: Adaptable for any room size or layout, with options for corner, fully-inset, or wall-hung installations. Includes 11 customizable lighting effects.
  • Efficient Heat Distribution: Provides a warm and cozy environment while maintaining energy efficiency.
  • User-Friendly Remote Control: Easily adjust settings and personalize your experience with the included remote.
  • Customizable Ambiance Settings: Create the perfect atmosphere to suit your mood.
  • 1-Year Warranty: Enjoy peace of mind with reliable warranty coverage.
  • TV-Safe Installation: Can be safely installed beneath a TV without the risk of heat damage.
  • Variable Heat with Thermostat: Adjustable heat settings with a programmable thermostat for personalized comfort.

Check price

Vintage Compact Heater

ZAFRO Electric Fireplace Stove, 5100 BTU Quick Heating Electric Fireplace Heater with Adjustable Flame Brightness, 1000W/1500W Thermostat, for Living Room, Bedroom

ZAFRO Electric Fireplace Stove, 5100 BTU Quick Heating Electric Fireplace Heater with Adjustable Flame Brightness, 1000W/1500W Thermostat, for Living Room, Bedroom

ZAFRO
  • Charming Design: This electric fireplace stove adopts a vintage – style stove body design, paired with highly realistic simulated flames and transparent glass viewing windows. And it blends classic stove rack and door – shape details in an ebony finish. The exquisite design infuses a retro-romantic vibe into your home space
  • High-Efficiency Heating: This fireplace heater has a powerful 5100 BTU heating function with two modes of 1000W and 1500W, quickly providing you with a warm environment
  • Realistic flame effect: This electric fireplace adopts 3D dancing flame technology with freely adjustable flame brightness from dim to bright, creating a lifelike flame effect to infuse your home life with a warmer and more vibrant atmosphere
  • Dual Safety Protection: Equipped with an overheat protection mechanism, the electric stove automatically shuts off when overheated, effectively preventing potential safety hazards. And its outwardly expanding feet widen the contact area with the ground, forming a more stable support structure to reduce tipping risks, ensuring a safer home environment for you
  • Compact&Freestanding: This electric fireplace boasts a space-saving compact design and a freestanding structure with dimensions of 15.35”Wx9.45”Dx22”H. It is easy to move and flexibly place, effortlessly fitting into various spaces

Check price

Ultra-Thin Wall Mount

R.W.FLAME Electric Fireplace 50 inch Recessed and Wall Mounted,The Thinnest FireplaceLow Noise, Fit for 2 x 6 Stud, Remote Control with Timer,Touch Screen,Adjustable Flame Colors and Speed

R.W.FLAME Electric Fireplace 50 inch Recessed and Wall Mounted,The Thinnest FireplaceLow Noise, Fit for 2 x 6 Stud, Remote Control with Timer,Touch Screen,Adjustable Flame Colors and Speed

R.W.FLAME
  • Attractive and Practical Design:3.86″D x 50″W x 18.11″H ,The thickness of the new style is only 3.86 inches while the old one is 6 inches. And it opearates the same as the old one. Also we redesign the location of main power and power cable, which makes the new fireplace more attractive and practical.
  • Multi Operation Modes:Touch screen and remote control;12 flame & LED flame bed color modes;5 flame speed modes;5 flame brightness levels; Specially automatic flame design(the flame color and brightness changed.
  • Energy Saving: 750W & 1500W modes can be adjusted accordingly for both warm and energy saving purpose. The supplemental zone heating is for up to 400 square feet.
  • Safety and comfort: ETL Certificate Approved. It also has auto-heat kill safety to avoid the super heating. The heat is good for maintaining the natural humidity within the air without making the room too dry.
  • Let R.W.FLAME electric fireplace warm your home and life.

Check price

Wide Screen Fireplace

R.W.FLAME 60″ Recessed and Wall Mounted Electric Fireplace, Low Noise, Fit for 2 x 6 Stud, Remote Control with Timer, Touch Screen, Adjustable Flame Color and Speed, 750-1500W

R.W.FLAME 60

R.W.FLAME
  • Attractive and Practical Design: 3.86″D x 60″W x 18.11″H,The thickness of the new style is only 3.86 inches while the old one is 6 inches. And it operates the same as the old one. Also we redesign the location of main power and power cable, which makes the new fireplace more attractive and practical.
  • Multi Operation Modes: Touch screen and remote control;12 flame & LED flame bed color modes;5 flame speed modes;5 flame brightness levels; Specially automatic flame design(the flame color and brightness changed
  • Energy Saving: 750W & 1500W modes can be adjusted accordingly for both warm and energy saving purpose. The supplemental zone heating is for up to 400 square feet.
  • Safety and Comfort: ETL Certificate Approved. It also has auto-heat kill safety to avoid the superheating. The heat is good for maintaining the natural humidity within the air without making the room too dry.
  • Let R.W.FLAME electric fireplace warm your home and life.

Check price

Easy Insert Solution

Innoflame 42″ Electric Fireplace Insert, Adjustable Thermostat & Flame Brightness, Remote Control, 8H Timer, 1500W Fireplace Heater with Removable Trim Kit, Black

Innoflame 42

Innoflame
  • Perfect Home Decoration: Elevate your space instantly with this electric fireplace! Its realistic dancing flames and hand-painted log set create an enchanting glow, adding warmth and visual charm to any room. The sleek, versatile design seamlessly complements rustic, modern, or cozy interiors, transforming blank walls into a captivating focal point. Even when turned off, its elegant silhouette adds sophistication, making it a timeless decor piece, enhances your home’s ambiance year-round
  • Realistic Flame Effect: Create the perfect atmosphere with four adjustable flame brightness levels, from soft and gentle for quiet reading to vibrant and lively for social gatherings. The lifelike flames mimic a real wood fire, this fireplace insert providing a cozy ambiance with or without heat for year-round enjoyment. Effortlessly match any mood or occasion, whether it’s a romantic evening, family movie night, or relaxed weekend lounging. The realistic effect adds depth and character, making every moment feel special
  • Efficient Heating: Enjoy supplemental warmth with this powerful fireplace inserts electric heater, delivering 5000 BTU of heat via infrared quartz technology, warm the rooms up to 400 sq ft. It maintains natural humidity while efficiently heating your space. You can use the flame effect alone for ambiance or combine it with heat for added comfort. The included remote lets you adjust temperature (64°F–82°F) easily, balancing energy efficiency and year-round coziness
  • Easy to Install: Designed for hassle-free setup, this fireplace inserts slides into existing fireplace openings or TV stands—no expensive renovations required! The pre-wired plug (120V, 12A max) fits standard outlets, and the trim kit conceals gaps for a seamless, built-in look. Compatible with wall cutouts (41.7″W × 18.7″H) or TV stands (42.2″W × 17.6″H), it requires no chimney, gas lines, or ash cleanup. Ready to use in minutes, it’s ideal for renters and homeowners alike
  • Easy to Use: Enjoy effortless warmth with this intuitive electric fireplace heater, designed for unmatched convenience. Featuring a remote control and dual-side carry handles, it puts comfort and flexibility at your fingertips—adjust heat, power on/off, or set timers from your seat, ideal for cozy moments in living rooms or bedrooms. The sturdy side handles also make installation or repositioning a breeze, ensuring you can move it wherever warmth is needed
  • Safety: Rest easy with advanced dual safety protections. Overheat protection automatically shuts off the unit if temperatures rise too high, while a customizable 1–8 hour timer ensures stress-free overnight use. The front-tempered glass stays cool to touch, making it safe for children and pets. Built with safety in mind, this recessed electric fireplace combines warmth and peace of mind for all households

Check price

Colorful Flame Options

EUHOMY 60 Inch Electric Fireplace Wall Recessed and Wall Mounted with Adjustable Flame Color, Fireplace Heater with Remote Control, Linear Fireplace with Timer, Touch Screen, Log & Crystal, 750/1500W

EUHOMY 60 Inch Electric Fireplace Wall Recessed and Wall Mounted with Adjustable Flame Color, Fireplace Heater with Remote Control, Linear Fireplace with Timer, Touch Screen, Log & Crystal, 750/1500W

EUHOMY
  • Package Inclusions & 2-Year Technical Support: : The EUHOMY electric fireplace is equipped with 1* carbon log, 1* pack crystal stone, 1* installation manual and hardware accessories. ETL Certificate Approved. And the wall mount fireplace electric comes with 2 years of technical support. If you have any questions about our fireplaces, please contact EUHOMY and we will help you as soon as possible
  • Multiple Installation Options & Sleek Design: This electric wall fireplace features a black tempered glass front panel that enhances the brightness and brilliance of the flames, adding a warm and inviting touch to your room. Our electric fireplace heater can be fully recessed or wall-mounted, seamlessly blending with a variety of home décor styles. It is suitable for living rooms, bedrooms, dining rooms, offices, home theaters, and even RVs. Overall dimensions: 60” x 4.13” x 17.01”
  • Adjustable Flame Color & Rate: This electric fireplace inserts into wall features a sleek design paired with stunning flame effects. You can mix and match from 12 flame colors and 12 LED fuel bed colors, along with 5 independently adjustable flame brightness. The high-intensity LED lights on the large display create realistic flame visuals, and the electric fire place can operate with or without heat, allowing you to enjoy a cozy ambiance in any season
  • Timer & Energy Saving: This fireplace electric insert has a 750W energy-saving mode and a 1500W efficient heating mode. You can switch between them as needed. Our wall mounted fireplace has an adjustable temperature range of 62°F to 82°F, a 1-8 hour timer control and an automatic heat-off safety feature, allowing you to easily customize the warmth for your ideal comfort. Supplemental zone heating up to 400 square feet with this chimenea eléctrica
  • Dual Control & Quiet Operation: Equipped with both a remote control and a touchscreen, this wall fireplace electric with remote control lets you easily choose the features you need. The wall mounted electric fireplace heater operates at a low noise level of only 45 decibels, ensuring you can relax and enjoy a warm and cozy atmosphere without any disturbance

Check price

Entertainment Center Choice

VASAGLE Fireplace TV Stand for TVs up to 65 Inches, 18-Inch ELectric Fireplace with Remote, Farmhouse Entertainment Center, Media Console Table for Living Room, Rustic White and Honey Brown ULTV540W01

VASAGLE Fireplace TV Stand for TVs up to 65 Inches, 18-Inch ELectric Fireplace with Remote, Farmhouse Entertainment Center, Media Console Table for Living Room, Rustic White and Honey Brown ULTV540W01

VASAGLE
  • Cozy Warmth, Inviting Ambiance: Create your ideal retreat with the 18″ electric fireplace, offering 10 temperature settings and 4 flame brightness levels. Easily set the perfect atmosphere for movie nights or gatherings—all with the remote or touch panel
  • Perfect for TVs up to 65″: With a tabletop measuring 58″L x 16″W, this media console table is ideal for 40″, 43″, 50″, 55″, 60″ and 65″ TVs, making it the perfect centerpiece for your living room
  • Ample & Adaptable: Organize media devices and daily items in 4 compartments, separated by 2 adjustable shelves to fit items of various sizes. Slide the barn doors of this farmhouse TV stand to hide or display items as you like
  • Solid Construction: Crafted from premium MDF and particleboard panels, the top of this entertainment center can hold up to 170 lb, providing reliable support for your TV and decorative items
  • Easy Assembly: This fireplace TV stand comes with labeled parts and clear instructions, making assembly a breeze

Check price

Infrared Heating Stove

duraflame Freestanding Electric Fireplace Stove Heater with 3D Flame Effect for 1,000 Sq. Ft, Bronze

duraflame Freestanding Electric Fireplace Stove Heater with 3D Flame Effect for 1,000 Sq. Ft, Bronze

Duraflame
  • Charming Design: Includes side viewing windows, a glass door that really opens, and a brick-style back panel. This stove heater not only enhances your décor but delivers infrared heat in any room up to 1,000 square feet. Easily carry this portable heater to any room you wish.
  • Money-Saving Heater: Supplemental heating is an effective way to provide comfort to your home, without having to warm every room. Save money on your next energy bill by lowering the thermostat and using this using this heater when and where you need it most.
  • Glowing Logs and 3D Flames: Bring the cozy cabin vibes to your home with the realistic flame effect. The glowing logs and soothing flames help you unwind as you relax on the couch and sip your favorite beverage; or, turn down the brightness levels for a perfect nightlight while you slumber.
  • Year-Round Glow: With independent flame and heat controls, you can enjoy the cozy glow of your fireplace even while the heat is off for a beautiful ambiance in every season.
  • Adjustable Settings:. Enjoy an adjustable thermostat and flame dial that will customize your fire to the ideal look and temperature.

Check price

Product prices and availability are accurate as of the date/time indicated and are subject to change. Any price and availability information displayed on Amazon.com at the time of purchase will apply to the purchase of this product.

Buying Guide

Buying Guide: Best Fireplace

Type & Fuel Source

  • Choose between wood-burning, gas, electric, or ethanol
  • Consider availability and cost of fuel
  • Check local regulations for fireplace installation
  • Evaluate maintenance requirements for each type

Heating Capacity

  • Calculate the square footage of the area to heat
  • Check BTU output for adequate heating
  • Consider ceiling height and insulation of your space
  • Look for adjustable heat settings

Installation & Placement

  • Determine if you need a chimney or venting system
  • Consider wall, corner, or freestanding options
  • Check clearance requirements from combustible materials
  • Evaluate floor protection needs
  • Assess accessibility for installation and maintenance

Design & Aesthetics

  • Choose a style that complements your home decor
  • Consider materials like stone, brick, metal, or wood
  • Decide between traditional or modern appearance
  • Look for customizable options like mantels and surrounds
  • Check for viewing area size and flame presentation

Safety Features

  • Look for automatic shut-off mechanisms
  • Check for safety barriers or screens
  • Consider cool-touch exteriors
  • Ensure proper certification from safety organizations
  • Evaluate child lock features for electric models

Energy Efficiency

  • Check EPA certification for emissions
  • Look for high efficiency ratings
  • Consider programmable thermostats
  • Evaluate heat loss through chimney
  • Look for models with zone heating capabilities

FAQs

What should I look for when buying a fireplace?

Consider the type of fireplace—electric, gas, or wood-burning—based on your home’s setup and heating needs. Look for energy efficiency ratings, safety features, and ease of installation. Also, check the heating capacity to ensure it matches the size of your room.

How do electric and gas fireplaces compare?

Electric fireplaces are easier to install and more energy-efficient but may lack the realism of gas models. Gas fireplaces provide more heat and a realistic flame but require professional installation and a gas line. Electric options are better for small spaces, while gas is ideal for larger areas.

What features should I prioritize for convenience?

Look for remote controls, adjustable thermostats, and timer settings for easy operation. Some models offer flame brightness controls and multiple heat settings for customization. Smart home compatibility is a bonus for tech-savvy shoppers.

Are wood-burning fireplaces worth the maintenance?

Wood-burning fireplaces offer a traditional ambiance and high heat output but require regular cleaning and chimney maintenance. They’re less energy-efficient and produce emissions, so consider local regulations. Gas or electric options are lower-maintenance alternatives.

How do I determine the right size fireplace for my room?

Measure the square footage of your room and match it to the fireplace’s heating capacity, usually listed in BTUs. A larger room may need a higher BTU rating, while smaller spaces can suffice with lower output. Don’t forget to consider ceiling height and insulation for optimal performance.

What’s the difference between vented and ventless fireplaces?

Vented fireplaces expel exhaust outside, making them safer but more complex to install. Ventless models are easier to set up but may produce indoor air pollutants, so check local codes. Vented options are better for homes with poor ventilation.

How can I ensure I’m getting good value?

Compare upfront costs with long-term energy savings and maintenance requirements. Look for warranties and customer reviews to gauge durability and performance. A slightly higher initial investment may pay off in efficiency and lifespan.

Are there eco-friendly fireplace options?

Electric fireplaces are the most eco-friendly, producing no emissions and using renewable energy if sourced properly. Gas fireplaces are cleaner than wood but still rely on fossil fuels. Ethanol fireplaces are another low-emission option for small spaces.

Similar Posts