Comparison: Best Fireplace Company (Updated | Dec 16th)

Gas fireplaces offer convenience with a flip of a switch and high heat output, but require a gas line. Electric models are the easiest to install and are perfect for ambiance without needing a vent, though they produce less heat. Wood-burning units provide a traditional experience and high heat but require the most maintenance, including a chimney and wood storage.

The key is to match the fireplace’s BTU (British Thermal Unit) output to the size of your space in square feet. A unit that is too large for the room can make it uncomfortably hot, while one that is too small will struggle to heat the area effectively. Always check the manufacturer’s recommendation for heating capacity to ensure optimal performance and comfort.

A fireplace insert is designed to be installed inside the firebox of an existing, masonry wood-burning fireplace to improve efficiency. A new fireplace unit, whether zero-clearance or built-in, is a complete system installed into a new wall or opening where no fireplace previously existed. Choosing between them depends on whether you are upgrading an old fireplace or starting a new installation.

Look for a model with a high Annual Fuel Utilization Efficiency (AFUE) rating, which measures how effectively the unit converts fuel to heat. A programmable thermostat or remote control allows for precise temperature management, preventing energy waste. Direct vent technology is also highly efficient as it uses outside air for combustion, ensuring it doesn’t draw warm air from inside your home.

Installation costs vary significantly based on the fuel type and whether you need to run a gas line, electrical outlet, or venting system. Gas and wood fireplaces require annual professional servicing to check the vents, pilot light, and safety components for optimal performance. Electric fireplaces have virtually no maintenance costs beyond an occasional lightbulb change, making them the most budget-friendly long-term option.

The aesthetic is a major factor as the fireplace is often a room’s focal point. You can choose from a wide variety of surrounds, including traditional mantels made of wood or stone, or modern, minimalist designs with glass or metal. Consider options like different firebed media (logs, glass, stones) and interior liner colors to perfectly match your home’s decor.

Yes, always ensure the fireplace is certified by a nationally recognized testing laboratory like UL (Underwriters Laboratories) or CSA (Canadian Standards Association). This certification confirms the product has been rigorously tested for safety and meets strict performance standards. Additionally, check for features like an automatic safety shutoff and cool-to-the-touch glass, especially important for homes with children or pets.