Comparison: Best Fireplace Doors Consumer Reports (Updated | Dec 16th)
We’ve tested dozens of options to bring you the top performers that keep warm air in, cold air out, and add elegance to your hearth. Whether you’re upgrading for energy savings or aesthetics, our expert insights will help you choose the perfect doors that combine function with form, ensuring your fireplace becomes the cozy centerpiece it’s meant to be.
- Best for spacious masonry door: Pleasant Hearth AT-1002 Ascot Fireplace Glass Door
- Best for compact bi-fold design: Pleasant Hearth Ascot Small Glass Fireplace Doors
- Best for heatilator perfect fit: Fireplace Glass Door Set for Heatilator Fireplace Model# E36
- Best for universal safety guard: TOCRETOARE Fireplace Door
- Best for easy-install cabinet style: Bluegrass Living Harland Fireplace Glass Doors with Screen
- Best for heatilator model specific: Heatilator Replacement Glass Fireplace Doors (Black) | ONLY for Model# E36
- Best for premium smoked glass: Pleasant Hearth Carlisle Fireplace Glass Door
- Best for marco model match: Fireplace Glass Doors for Marco Fireplace (Black Finish)
- Best for elegant gold trim: Pleasant Hearth AR-1022 Arrington Fireplace Glass Door
- Best for decorative cabinet style: Stanbroil Fireplace Glass Cabinet-Style Door
Product Comparison: Best Fireplace Doors Consumer Reports
Pleasant Hearth AT-1002 Ascot Fireplace Glass Door, Black, Large
- Large size dimensions: Overall frame dimensions 43.5” x 33”. / Fits a fireplace opening of Width: 36” – 43” and Height: 25.5” – 32.5”.
- For Masonary Fireplaces Only: Not for prefabricated fireplaces
- Standard Mesh Panel
- Bi-fold Doors
- 4 in. “easy grip” handles.
- 3/16 in. clear tempered glass doors open 180 for a full view of fireplace
- Black Finish with Clear Glass
Pleasant Hearth Ascot Small Glass Fireplace Doors
- Small size dimensions: 30-37-Inch width of firebox opening and 22.5-29.5-Inch height of firebox opening, with 37.5-30-Inch overall frame dimensions
- Black Finish with Clear Glass.3/16 inch clear tempered glass doors open 180° for a full view of fireplace
- Standard Mesh Panel
- Bi-fold Doors; Air control slide
- 4-Inch”easy grip” handles
- The Ascot doors can’t be installed on pre-fabricated fireplaces.
Fireplace Glass Door Set for Heatilator Fireplace Model# E36, E-36I, EC36, EC-36I, EL36, BC36R, BC36C (Black Finish)
- Fits E36, E-36I, EC36, EC-36I, EL36, BC36R, BC36C
- Please Do Not Order Unless Your Model Matches One Listed. These doors will not fit your unit unless you have one of the models listed. Sometimes A Tag Containing Model#, Make, Date Of Manufacture Can Sometimes Be Found On Inside Sheet Metal Wall Of Firebox. IMPORTANT: Please also confirm the manufacturer of your firebox before processing your order.
- For Installation Instructions Visit https://youtu.be/6JVdCl6X-7Y
TOCRETOARE Fireplace Door, Fire Places Doors with Screen and Glass Decor Iron Mesh Guard and Magnetic Panels Fits Masonry Fireplaces Size 30.5in to 37in W x 23.5in to 29.5in H
- UNIVERSAL SIZE: The overall frame dimensions is 37.5-30″. The width of the firebox opening is 30.5-37-Inch, the height of the firebox opening is 23.5-29.5-Inch. Please measure your fireplace before purchasing.Please choose the right size for your fireplace size, our fireplace doors are not adjustable. For Masonry Fireplaces Only.
- SAFETY GUARD : Large and solid fireplace glass doors are able to block popping embers, keep your people and pets away from fire and keep your living room or bedroom safe.
- BI-FOLD STYLE: The two doors use small but strong magnets to prevent errant sparks from escaping while providing easy access to tend your fire.
- RELIABLE MATERIAL: The glass fireplace doors are sturdy and durable steel structure frame and is equipped with safety tempered glass, which can protect your safety to the greatest extent while ensuring perspective.
- HOME DECOR: Black powder-coated finish adds a rustic, classic, traditional look to the fireplace and ensures long-lasting use. Perfect for home decor, fireplace grates, also an excellent gift.
Bluegrass Living Harland Fireplace Glass Doors with Screen, Small – Model# HLFD-SM
- High-heat, powder coated, classic black finish for lasting durability and beauty
- 3/16 in. clear tempered glass doors open completely for a full view of fireplace. Cabinet-style doors have easy-catch magnets and easy-grip handles.
- Premium mesh panels help keep embers and sparks contained. For masonry fireplaces only, not prefabricated.
- Minimal assembly required. Surface-mount desgin is easy to install in 3 simple steps.
- To ensure correct size, measure the opening width and height of your fireplace before ordering. Fits openings 30 in. to 37 in. W and 22.5 in. tall to 29.5 in. tall.
Heatilator Replacement Glass Fireplace Doors (Black) | ONLY for Model# E36, EC36, BC36R, BC36C | Verify Model Number On Metal Tag Inside Firebox | Fireplace Glass Door Set
- Only compatible with “Heatilator” model numbers: E36, EC36, BC36R, BC36C. The metal tag containing the Make & Model Number can be found on the inside wall of the firebox.
- These bi-fold fireplace doors are made with clear, 3/16” tempered glass with safe finished edges, in matte black anodized aluminum. Arrive fully assembled and ready to snap into your Superior fireplace. Made in the USA
- For these doors to fit properly, the fireplace must already have tracks and clips installed. We do not provide detailed measurements to ensure that customers only select models compatible with their existing setup, since parts, tension pins, and track sizes vary by model.
- Do Not Order Unless Your Model Matches One Listed. Please contact us with any questions.
- Saftey Notice: Fireplace doors must be fully opened while fire is burning.
Pleasant Hearth Carlisle Fireplace Glass Door, Large (CL-3002)
- Dimensions: 43 ½” W x 33″ H
- Fits Opening Width: 36″ ~ 43″ || Fits Opening Height: 25 ½” ~ 32 ½”
- Black Finish with Smoked Glass
- Premium/Fine Mesh Panel. Beveled frame
- Cabinet style doors
- 5-Inch”easy grip” handles
- Doors open completely for a full view of the fireplace
- Easy-grip handles and air damper control slide – No more burnt fingers from touching hot parts! these easy grips allow you to open and close with ease
Fireplace Glass Doors for Marco Fireplace (Black Finish)
- Fits B36CF, B36HC, A36STD, D36, 792774, 792775, 792776, 792777, 792778, 792779, 792805, 792806, 792807, 792808, 792809, 792810, 792811, 792812
- Please Do Not Order Unless Your Model Matches One Listed. These doors will not fit your unit unless you have one of the models listed. Sometimes A Tag Containing Model#, Make, Date Of Manufacture Can Sometimes Be Found On Inside Sheet Metal Wall Of Firebox.
- Available In 2 Finishes (Black or Silver)
- For Installation Instructions Visit https://youtu.be/6JVdCl6X-7Y
Pleasant Hearth AR-1022 Arrington Fireplace Glass Door, Black, Large
- Black finish with moonlight gold trim , Bifold style doors
- 1 in frame , Clear glass panels
- Rigid mesh firescreen panels , Doors open completely for full view of fireplace
- Made in the USA
- 43.5” L x 31” H x 1” W
Stanbroil Fireplace Glass Cabinet-Style Door, Black Finish, Large, Decorative Fireplace Screen Door for Fireplace Accessories
- A fireplace door is designed to provide a safety barrier between the room and the fireplace.
- Cabinet-Style Door, increase safety and efficiency.
- Black powder-coated finish: The versatile black color also comprehensively matches any furnishing style, being perfect for indoor decoration.
- Large size dimensions: The overall frame dimensions is 43.5-33″. The width of firebox opening is 36-43 Inch, the height of firebox opening is 25.5-32.5 Inch.
- Perfect gift choice: Great fire place door choice, perfect for home decor, fireplace grates, also an excellent gift.
Product prices and availability are accurate as of the date/time indicated and are subject to change. Any price and availability information displayed on Amazon.com at the time of purchase will apply to the purchase of this product.
Buying Guide
FAQs
What should I look for when buying fireplace doors?
Look for durable materials like tempered glass or steel to ensure longevity and safety. Check for proper insulation and a tight seal to improve energy efficiency and prevent heat loss.
How do different types of fireplace doors compare?
Bifold doors fold inward for easy access, while cabinet doors swing open like traditional doors. Trackless designs offer a cleaner look but may be less secure than tracked options.
Are fireplace doors worth the investment?
Yes, they enhance safety by containing sparks and improve heating efficiency by reducing drafts. High-quality doors can also add aesthetic value to your fireplace and home.
What features should I prioritize for energy efficiency?
Opt for doors with airtight seals and insulated glass to minimize heat loss. Look for adjustable vents to control airflow and maximize heat retention.
How do I measure my fireplace for the right fit?
Measure the width and height of the fireplace opening at the widest and tallest points. Ensure the doors overlap the opening slightly for a secure fit.
What are the pros and cons of glass vs. metal doors?
Glass doors provide a clear view of the fire and improve insulation, while metal doors are more durable and often cheaper. However, glass can require more cleaning to maintain visibility.
Do fireplace doors require maintenance?
Regularly clean the glass with a non-abrasive cleaner to remove soot buildup. Inspect hinges and seals periodically to ensure they remain functional and secure.
Are there safety certifications to look for?
Choose doors certified by organizations like UL or CSA for compliance with safety standards. This ensures the doors are tested for heat resistance and durability.
How much should I expect to spend on quality fireplace doors?
Prices range from $200 to $1,000, depending on materials, size, and features. Investing in higher-end options often provides better insulation and durability.
Can I install fireplace doors myself?
Many models are designed for DIY installation with basic tools, but complex setups may require professional help. Always follow the manufacturer’s instructions for safe and proper installation.