Comparison: Best Fireplace For Heat (Updated | Dec 17th)
When winter’s chill sets in, nothing beats the cozy warmth of a crackling fireplace. But with so many options on the market, how do you choose the best one for heating your home? We’ve done the legwork, testing everything from traditional wood-burning hearths to modern electric models. Our comprehensive guide will help you navigate the world of fireplaces, comparing efficiency, heating capacity, and style to find the perfect match for your space. Get ready to transform your home into a warm, inviting sanctuary with our top picks.
Editor’s Choice
Best for a specific purpose
- Best for infrared heating power: duraflame Freestanding Electric Fireplace Stove Heater with 3D Flame Effect for 1
- Best for smart safety features: Sweetcrispy Freestanding Electric Fireplace Heater
- Best for vintage style heating: ZAFRO Electric Fireplace Stove
- Best for infrared heating power: duraflame Freestanding Electric Fireplace Stove Heater with 3D Flame Effect for 1
- Best for remote control convenience: Sweetcrispy Freestanding Electric Fireplace Heater
- Best for compact vintage design: ZAFRO Freestanding Electric Fireplace Stove with Realistic Flame
- Best for portable zone heating: duraflame® Electric Fireplace Portable Space Heater
- Best for crackling sound experience: Shinic Electric Fireplace Heaters for Indoor Use
- Best for infrared quartz heating: duraflame® Infrared Quartz Electric Fireplace Stove Heater
- Best for energy-efficient timer: Sweetcrispy Freestanding Electric Fireplace
Product Comparison: Best Fireplace For Heat
Infrared Heating Power
duraflame Freestanding Electric Fireplace Stove Heater with 3D Flame Effect for 1,000 Sq. Ft. Room, Black
Duraflame
- Charming Design: Includes side viewing windows, a glass door that really opens, and a brick-style back panel. This stove heater not only enhances your décor but delivers infrared heat in any room up to 1,000 square feet. Easily carry this portable heater to any room you wish.
- Money-Saving Heater: Supplemental heating is an effective way to provide comfort to your home, without having to warm every room. Save money on your next energy bill by lowering the thermostat and using this using this heater when and where you need it most.
- Glowing Logs and 3D Flames: Bring the cozy cabin vibes to your home with the realistic flame effect. The glowing logs and soothing flames help you unwind as you relax on the couch and sip your favorite beverage; or, turn down the brightness levels for a perfect nightlight while you slumber.
- Year-Round Glow: With independent flame and heat controls, you can enjoy the cozy glow of your fireplace even while the heat is off for a beautiful ambiance in every season.
- Adjustable Settings:. Enjoy an adjustable thermostat and flame dial that will customize your fire to the ideal look and temperature.
Smart Safety Features
Sweetcrispy Freestanding Electric Fireplace Heater, 26”Two Door Fireplace with 3D Flame Effect, Overheating Safe Design, Energy Saving Space Heater with 12H Timer&Remote for Living Room, Bedroom,Black
Sweetcrispy
- Powerful Fireplace Heater: This freestanding electric fireplace heater offers adjustable heat settings ranging from 750W for a gentle warmth to 1500W for a powerful heat. Whether it’s chilly mornings or cold nights, the powerful heater provides consistent and efficient warmth, keeping your space comfortable throughout the seasons
- Safety Features: For your peace of mind, Sweetcrispy electric fireplace includes built-in overheating protection that automatically turns off the unit if it gets too hot. The child lock function ensures safety in homes, preventing accidental adjustments. Enjoy a safe and secure environment while relaxing by the fire
- Free Control: Take complete control with the included remote or use the easy-to-operate control panel on the unit itself. Adjust the temperature, flame intensity, and other settings effortlessly from across the room or directly at the stove. The flexibility of both options provides maximum convenience
- Various Flame Effects: With the dazzling 3D flame effect of this led fireplace, you can personalize your atmosphere. There are various flame lightness to choose from to suit your mood or decoration style, turning any room into a cozy and pleasant place to relax
- Energy-Saving Timer: Sweetcrispy fireplace heater is designed with energy-saving in mind. The built-in timer allows you to set it to automatically turn off after a preset time, reducing unnecessary energy consumption
Vintage Style Heating
ZAFRO Electric Fireplace Stove, 5100 BTU Quick Heating Electric Fireplace Heater with Adjustable Flame Brightness, 1000W/1500W Thermostat, for Living Room, Bedroom
ZAFRO
- Charming Design: This electric fireplace stove adopts a vintage – style stove body design, paired with highly realistic simulated flames and transparent glass viewing windows. And it blends classic stove rack and door – shape details in an ebony finish. The exquisite design infuses a retro-romantic vibe into your home space
- High-Efficiency Heating: This fireplace heater has a powerful 5100 BTU heating function with two modes of 1000W and 1500W, quickly providing you with a warm environment
- Realistic flame effect: This electric fireplace adopts 3D dancing flame technology with freely adjustable flame brightness from dim to bright, creating a lifelike flame effect to infuse your home life with a warmer and more vibrant atmosphere
- Dual Safety Protection: Equipped with an overheat protection mechanism, the electric stove automatically shuts off when overheated, effectively preventing potential safety hazards. And its outwardly expanding feet widen the contact area with the ground, forming a more stable support structure to reduce tipping risks, ensuring a safer home environment for you
- Compact&Freestanding: This electric fireplace boasts a space-saving compact design and a freestanding structure with dimensions of 15.35”Wx9.45”Dx22”H. It is easy to move and flexibly place, effortlessly fitting into various spaces
Infrared Heating Power
duraflame Freestanding Electric Fireplace Stove Heater with 3D Flame Effect for 1,000 Sq. Ft, Bronze
Duraflame
- Charming Design: Includes side viewing windows, a glass door that really opens, and a brick-style back panel. This stove heater not only enhances your décor but delivers infrared heat in any room up to 1,000 square feet. Easily carry this portable heater to any room you wish.
- Money-Saving Heater: Supplemental heating is an effective way to provide comfort to your home, without having to warm every room. Save money on your next energy bill by lowering the thermostat and using this using this heater when and where you need it most.
- Glowing Logs and 3D Flames: Bring the cozy cabin vibes to your home with the realistic flame effect. The glowing logs and soothing flames help you unwind as you relax on the couch and sip your favorite beverage; or, turn down the brightness levels for a perfect nightlight while you slumber.
- Year-Round Glow: With independent flame and heat controls, you can enjoy the cozy glow of your fireplace even while the heat is off for a beautiful ambiance in every season.
- Adjustable Settings:. Enjoy an adjustable thermostat and flame dial that will customize your fire to the ideal look and temperature.
Remote Control Convenience
Sweetcrispy Freestanding Electric Fireplace Heater, 26” Indoor Fireplace with 3D Flame Effect, Overheating Safe Design, Energy Saving Space Heater with 12H Timer&Remote for Living Room, Bedroom, Black
Sweetcrispy
- Powerful Fireplace Heater: This freestanding electric fireplace heater offers adjustable heat settings ranging from 750W for a gentle warmth to 1500W for a powerful heat. Whether it’s chilly mornings or cold nights, the powerful heater provides consistent and efficient warmth, keeping your space comfortable throughout the seasons
- Safety Features: For your peace of mind, Sweetcrispy electric fireplace includes built-in overheating protection that automatically turns off the unit if it gets too hot. The child lock function ensures safety in homes, preventing accidental adjustments. Enjoy a safe and secure environment while relaxing by the fire
- Free Control: Take complete control with the included remote or use the easy-to-operate control panel on the unit itself. Adjust the temperature, flame intensity, and other settings effortlessly from across the room or directly at the stove. The flexibility of both options provides maximum convenience
- Various Flame Effects: With the dazzling 3D flame effect of this led fireplace, you can personalize your atmosphere. There are various flame lightness to choose from to suit your mood or decoration style, turning any room into a cozy and pleasant place to relax
- Energy-Saving Timer: Sweetcrispy fireplace heater is designed with energy-saving in mind. The built-in timer allows you to set it to automatically turn off after a preset time, reducing unnecessary energy consumption
Compact Vintage Design
ZAFRO Freestanding Electric Fireplace Stove with Realistic Flame, 5100 BTU Electric Fireplace Heater with Retro Design, 1000W/1500W, Dual Safety Protection for Living Room, Bedroom
ZAFRO
- “Charming Design: This electric fireplace stove adopts a vintage – style stove body design, paired with highly realistic simulated flames and transparent glass viewing windows. And it blends classic stove rack and door – shape details in an ebony finish. The exquisite design infuses a retro-romantic vibe into your home space.
- High-Efficiency Heating: This fireplace heater has a powerful 5100 BTU heating function with two modes of 1000W and 1500W, quickly providing you with a warm environment.
- Realistic flame effect: This electric fireplace adopts 3D dancing flame technology with freely adjustable flame brightness from dim to bright, creating a lifelike flame effect to infuse your home life with a warmer and more vibrant atmosphere.
- Dual Safety Protection: Equipped with an overheat protection mechanism, the electric stove automatically shuts off when overheated, effectively preventing potential safety hazards. And its outwardly expanding feet widen the contact area with the ground, forming a more stable support structure to reduce tipping risks, ensuring a safer home environment for you.
- Compact&Freestanding: This electric fireplace boasts a space-saving compact design and a freestanding structure with dimensions of 22.83”Wx11.02”Dx20.08”H. It is easy to move and flexibly place, effortlessly fitting into various spaces.
Portable Zone Heating
duraflame® Electric Fireplace Portable Space Heater
Duraflame
- 4,600 BTU heater provides supplemental zone heating for up to 400 square feet and helps save you money on heating costs
- 2 comfort settings: low heat and high heat – using 750 watt and 1500 watt settings
- Realistic flame effect with glowing log set and ember bed
- Flame effect can be operated with or without heat, providing the ambiance of a gentle rolling fire all year long
- No assembly required, ready to use out of the box
- Eco-friendly and energy efficient with long-lasting LED technology
- Safe for use around children and pets
- Legs can be removed for customizable style
Crackling Sound Experience
Shinic Electric Fireplace Heaters for Indoor Use,1500W Space Heater with Crackling Sound & 3D Realistic Flame, Safety Protection, Portable Fireplace Heater for Home Office Christmas Decoration, Oak
shinic
- 【High-Efficiency Heating】5,118 BTUS heat output provides you with endless warmness. 3 heating modes: 750w low heat, 1500w high heat for faster heating, and cool air. With a manual adjustment thermostat, the electric fireplace heater will auto cycle on and off according to the room’s ambient temperature to maintain a comfortable temperature.
- 【Crackling Sound and Realistic Flame Effect】3D dancing flame with relaxing fire crackling sound provides an immersive experience for you and your family. Enjoy the flame and sound with or without heating. This electric fireplace heater is a fabulous addition to your lovely home and also a warm gift for your family and friends
- 【Tip-over and Overheat Protection】This space heater fireplace will automatically shut off when the temperature is too high or tipped over. The shell is made of V0 Flame Retardant, COOL-TO TOUCH Material for higher safety. Furthermore, The faux fireplace heater has ETL certification. You can use it safely with your family around kids and pets
- 【Portable and Durable Design】This small electric fireplace is portable(11.8in x 5.9in× 14.6in) and lightweight(8.2 lbs), easy to move from room to room to keep you warm anywhere in your home.
- 【Wide Application】 Free of dust, smoke, and noise, this mini fireplace offers you clean and quiet living space. And the elegant appearance and various color options enable this electric stove heater to fit well on multiple occasions, such as the living room, bedroom, and office. Moreover, both the flame effect and sound effect can be operated independently without heating, making the fireplace to be used all year around.
Infrared Quartz Heating
duraflame® Infrared Quartz Electric Fireplace Stove Heater, Cream
Duraflame
- 5,200 BTU heater provides supplemental zone heating for up to 1,000 square feet to help you save money on heating bills
- Infrared quartz technology adds warmth instantly without making the room feel excessively dry
- Lifelike fireplace look includes dancing flames with glowing logs and ember bed
- The flame effect can be used with or without heat for a cozy, year-round atmosphere
- Classic silhouette includes operational door and arched frame detailing
Energy-Efficient Timer
Sweetcrispy Freestanding Electric Fireplace, 26”Two Door Fireplace Heater with 3D Flame Effect, Overheating Safe Design, Energy Saving Space Heater with 12H Timer&Remote for Living Room, Bedroom,Black
Sweetcrispy
- Various Flame Effects: With the dazzling 3D flame effect of this led fireplace, you can personalize your atmosphere. There are various flame lightness to choose from to suit your mood or decoration style, turning any room into a cozy and pleasant place to relax
- Energy-Saving Timer: Sweetcrispy fireplace heater is designed with energy-saving in mind. The built-in timer allows you to set it to automatically turn off after a preset time, reducing unnecessary energy consumption
- Powerful Fireplace Heater: This freestanding electric fireplace heater offers adjustable heat settings ranging from 750W for a gentle warmth to 1500W for a powerful heat. Whether it’s chilly mornings or cold nights, the powerful heater provides consistent and efficient warmth, keeping your space comfortable throughout the seasons
- Safety Features: For your peace of mind, Sweetcrispy electric fireplace includes built-in overheating protection that automatically turns off the unit if it gets too hot. The child lock function ensures safety in homes, preventing accidental adjustments. Enjoy a safe and secure environment while relaxing by the fire
- Free Control: Take complete control with the included remote or use the easy-to-operate control panel on the unit itself. Adjust the temperature, flame intensity, and other settings effortlessly from across the room or directly at the stove. The flexibility of both options provides maximum convenience
Product prices and availability are accurate as of the date/time indicated and are subject to change. Any price and availability information displayed on Amazon.com at the time of purchase will apply to the purchase of this product.
Buying Guide
FAQs
What should I look for when choosing a fireplace for heat?
Consider the heating capacity measured in BTUs to ensure it can warm your space efficiently. Look for features like adjustable thermostats, remote controls, and energy-saving modes for convenience and cost-effectiveness.
How do electric and gas fireplaces compare for heating?
Electric fireplaces are easy to install and energy-efficient but may heat smaller areas. Gas fireplaces provide more consistent and powerful heat but require professional installation and ventilation.
Are wood-burning fireplaces good for heating?
Wood-burning fireplaces offer high heat output and a traditional ambiance but require regular maintenance and a chimney. They’re best for those who prioritize authenticity and have access to firewood.
What safety features should I prioritize?
Look for overheat protection, cool-touch glass, and automatic shut-off features to prevent accidents. Ensure the fireplace meets safety certifications like UL or ETL for peace of mind.
How do I determine the right size fireplace for my room?
Measure your room’s square footage and match it to the fireplace’s BTU rating for optimal heating. A general rule is 20 BTUs per square foot, but insulation and ceiling height also affect performance.
Are ventless fireplaces a good option for heating?
Ventless fireplaces are efficient and easy to install but may produce moisture and require proper ventilation. They’re ideal for supplemental heating but not as a primary heat source in large spaces.
What’s the most energy-efficient fireplace type?
Electric fireplaces are the most energy-efficient, converting nearly all electricity into heat. Gas fireplaces are also efficient but may lose some heat through venting.
How do I balance cost and performance when buying a fireplace?
Electric fireplaces are budget-friendly upfront but may have higher operational costs. Gas fireplaces cost more initially but offer lower long-term expenses and better heating performance.
Can a fireplace replace my central heating system?
Fireplaces are great for supplemental heating but rarely replace central heating entirely. Choose a high-BTU model or a fireplace insert for better coverage if you plan to rely on it heavily.
What additional features enhance a fireplace’s heating value?
Features like zone heating, programmable timers, and fan-forced heat improve efficiency and convenience. Look for models with eco modes to reduce energy consumption while maintaining warmth.