Comparison: Best Fireplace Mantels (Updated | Dec 18th)
Transform your living space into a cozy haven with the perfect fireplace mantel! Whether you’re drawn to rustic reclaimed wood or sleek modern designs, the right mantel can instantly elevate your room’s character and functionality. We’ve scoured the market to bring you the top contenders that blend style, durability, and value. From statement pieces that steal the show to subtle designs that complement your existing decor, our guide will help you discover the mantel that’ll make your fireplace the heart of your home.
Editor’s Choice
Best for a specific purpose
- Best for handcrafted elegance: Eshoma Fireplace Mantel – Handcrafted Wood Mantles for Over Fireplace – Wall Mounted Fireplace Mantel Shelf – Floating Fireplace Mantel for Living Room Decor – 72 Inch – Walnut
- Best for modern electric mantel: HOMCOM Modern Fireplace Mantel
- Best for rustic natural beauty: ABSWHLM 72x8x3 Fireplace Mantel – Handcrafted Hollow Rustic Solid Wood Wall Mounted Floating Shelf with Invisible Heavy Duty Wood Bracket (Weathered Brown)
- Best for holiday stocking solution: Christmas Stocking Holders for Mantle Set 4
- Best for farmhouse charm mantel: Avana Fireplace Mantel – Wall-Mounted Mantles for Over Fireplace – Farmhouse Fireplace Mantle Shelves – Handcrafted Wood Fireplace Mantels – Floating Mantel 72 Inches X 8 X 5 – Rustic Natural
- Best for heat protection shelf: GoCampDirect Fireplace Mantle Shelf – 60×8×5Inch Handcrafted Wall Floating Mantel Shelf for Over Fireplace – Rustic Traditional Wooden Fireplace Mantels with Invisible Heavy Duty Wood Bracket
- Best for deep rustic mantel: ABSWHLM 72x8x5 Fireplace Mantel – Handcrafted Rustic Solid Wood Wall Mounted Floating Shelf with Invisible Heavy Duty Wood Bracket (Natural)
- Best for compact tv fireplace: 43 Inch Fireplace TV Stand with Mantel – Electric Fireplace Heater
- Best for freestanding modern mantel: HOMCOM Modern Fireplace Mantel
- Best for storage fireplace solution: Naice 72″ Electric Fireplace with Mantel and Cabinets
Product Comparison: Best Fireplace Mantels
Handcrafted Elegance
Eshoma Fireplace Mantel – Handcrafted Wood Mantles for Over Fireplace – Wall Mounted Fireplace Mantel Shelf – Floating Fireplace Mantel for Living Room Decor – 72 Inch – Walnut
Eshoma
- Elevate Your Living Room: Enhance your space with this elegant fireplace mantel 72 inches. Its clean, minimal design and traditional wood element bring a refined touch to any room, perfectly complementing your fireplace.
- Protect Your Valuables: This hollow faux fireplace mantel acts as a barrier, shielding your valuables from smoke and heat damage. Enjoy the warmth of your fireplace without worrying about your possessions.
- Solid Strength & Design: Crafted from solid pine, the natural grain of this handcrafted floating mantel shelf adds classic charm to your home. Sealed with a water-resistant finish, it combines rustic beauty with durability.
- Versatile Display: Showcase your books, awards, photos, or decor on this wood mantle Ideal for positioning a wall-mounted mirror, television, or artwork above your fireplace, this long floating shelves for wall 72 inch provides a stylish stage for your cherished items.
- Easy Installation: Your 72 inch floating shelf comes with a complete mounting kit, including wall anchors, screws, invisible shelf brackets, and easy-to-follow instructions. Suitable for wood-burning, gas, or electric fireplaces, this fireplace mantel is a perfect fit for any fireplace setup.
Modern Electric Mantel
HOMCOM Modern Fireplace Mantel, Surround Mantels for Fireplace with Decorative Pattern Interior Width 29″ White
HOMCOM
- Add Charm to Your Fireplace: Now you can make your fireplace stand out and bring elegance to your living room. Decorate your hearth and finally have that mantel piece when you add this beautiful MDF mantel to your space.
- Add Room to Decorate: This fireplace mantel has a 45.25″ wide top, so you can display large pictures, holiday décor, and plants.
- Easy Cleaning: Our mantels for fireplace have an MDF frame that wipes down smoothly for easy maintenance and holds up to 66 lbs.
- Safety First: An anti-tipping mechanism is on the back of the mantel surround, stopping it from falling over. It’s quick and easy to assemble, just attach the legs to the header and mount it on the wall.
- Fireplace Surround Info: Overall Dimensions: 45.25″ W x 9.25″ D x 39.25″ H. Overall Weight Capacity: 66 lbs. Assembly required. Note: This is for electric fireplaces only, not gas.
Rustic Natural Beauty
ABSWHLM 72x8x3 Fireplace Mantel – Handcrafted Hollow Rustic Solid Wood Wall Mounted Floating Shelf with Invisible Heavy Duty Wood Bracket (Weathered Brown)
ABSWHLM
- Handcrafted Hollow Rustic Solid Wood: Our fireplace mantels are handmade from pine wood, featuring a minimalist design and a fashionable silhouette that complements your modern living space. Its clean lines and neat design effortlessly add a refined elegance to any of your spaces
- Charm of Natural Wood Grain: We preserve every natural mark of the wood, making each piece unique. At the same time, we use a unique natural dyeing process that not only enriches the wooden texture, creating a stunning finish, but also ensures its durability and protection
- Wall-Mounted Design: The fireplace mantels feature an elegant floating design, offering a clean and tidy appearance, making them the perfect choice for displaying decorations or storing daily items. These mantels are not only furniture, they are a lasting investment in the beauty of natural wood, carefully processed to suit your home even better
- Easy Installation: Our solid wood mantels come with hidden wood brackets, which can be easily fixed to the wall. Our hollow structure design ensures easy installation. The package includes installation instructions and two sets of accessories, compatible with hollow walls (drywalls) and solid walls (brick walls). For any installation issues, feel free to contact us at any time
- The Choice for Creative Gifts: This solid wood mantel is also a perfect gift choice, whether it’s Christmas, Mother’s Day, birthdays, weddings, anniversaries, or Thanksgiving, it’s the ideal gift for friends and family. Decorate with a simple fireplace mantel and bring the purest joy
Holiday Stocking Solution
Christmas Stocking Holders for Mantle Set 4,Lightweight Stocking Holder No-slip Stocking Hangers for Mantel Fireplace,Adjustable Mantel Stocking Hooks
FINMOR
- Upgraded Christmas Stocking Holder, 4 Pack Clean and elegant stocking holders for mantle. Blends seamlessly with our Christmas decor, it’s a stylish way to bring on the holiday cheer on holiday season.The simple design will save space and won’t influence other Christmas decorations on mantel, fireplace and table
- Stocking Holders for Mantle Set 4, including 4 pieces Christmas stocking holders for mantle for Mom, Dad and Babies. Made from thicken and durable bronze metal, anti-rust and corrosion resistant, holds heavy Christmas stocking with gifts and other decorations up to 10 pounds
- Easy to Use Stocking Holder, These stocking hooks are easy to use and install, no need any tools, nails or any tapes. Each of hooks with scratch-free design can prevent it from sliding and damaging to the surface of Fireplace or table. Simple yet practical, can be used to hang your Christmas stockings, lights, garland, Christmas decoration, handbags and so on
- Adjustable and Universal Stocking Holder, The mantel stocking hangers can adjust from 0.5″ to 3″ which allows it to fit almost any size or shape of a mantel and Fireplace. The thickness of the stocking holder is 0.11″, the length of the Metal Clip for Christmas stocking is 4.72″”, width is 0.9″, weight: only 0.11 lbs. Not only fits square edge of Fireplace, but also works really well for sloped, shallow and complex edges of mantel
- Friendly Stocking Holder for Kids & Pets, The lightweight design makes it’s a sensible option for homes with curious children or pets. Compared to heavy, counter-balance stocking holders for Fireplace, this simple Christmas stocking holder is a wise choice. Great to add some festive atmosphere at home, also for Christmas party decorations. Good as a gift to your family and friends
Farmhouse Charm Mantel
Avana Fireplace Mantel – Wall-Mounted Mantles for Over Fireplace – Farmhouse Fireplace Mantle Shelves – Handcrafted Wood Fireplace Mantels – Floating Mantel 72 Inches X 8 X 5 – Rustic Natural
Avana
- A Touch of Refinement — Accessorize your living room with a stately wood mantle mount. The shelf wood rustic natural finish and sleek lines of this fireplace shelf 72 inch creates a grounding sense of richness to your space
- Special Spotlight — The proudest and most precious moments of your life deserve a beautiful seat in your home. These fireplace mantels shelves have an 8 inch deep shelf, making 72 inch shelf the perfect spot to display your family photos, awards and artwork
- A Wall of Protection — This floating fireplace mantel shelf 72 inches is not only a beautiful display space, but this floating mantel also a protective barrier between your valuables and the fire beneath them. Your modern floating shelves keep the heat and smoke at bay while preserving your belongings
- Rustic Natural Wood Mantel — The natural grain of your wood mantle for fireplace brings a gracious charm to your interior design. Your 72 inch floating shelf is handcrafted from solid pine with a fireplace mantle shelf 72 espresso, water-resistant finish
- Smooth Installation — This fireplace shelf mantel 72 inches comes with a mounting kit complete with wall anchors, round head screws, flat head screws, invisible brackets and instructions. Your fireplace mantles wood 72 is suitable for wood-burning, gas, or electric fireplaces
Heat Protection Shelf
GoCampDirect Fireplace Mantle Shelf – 60×8×5Inch Handcrafted Wall Floating Mantel Shelf for Over Fireplace – Rustic Traditional Wooden Fireplace Mantels with Invisible Heavy Duty Wood Bracket
GoCampDirect
- [ STRONG AND DURABLE ] Wood floating mantel is handcrafted from natural solid wood, using pine, which is sturdy and durable, not easy to break. Decorative fireplace mantel design is simple and stylish can add an elegant touch to any space. Its smooth surface features a unique natural pattern, making it durable and the ideal choice for your home.
- [ Multi-purpose ] The natural wood grain of our product retains every mark of the wood, making each product unique. This rustic style natural floating fireplace mantel seamlessly fits above the fireplace, beneath the TV, or functions as a standalone wall shelf to add an elegance to your home and make refinement the focus.
- [ Heat Protector ] Fireplace mantel shelves is a barrier between your valuables and the fire. The 8-inch deep mantel provides a place to keep items safe from the smoke and heat produced by your active fireplace.Its wall-mounted design features an elegant suspended style, giving it a clean and tidy appearance. It is the perfect choice for displaying decorations or storing daily necessities.
- [ Multi-size ] The wooden fireplace mantel shelf is available in multiple sizes and two colors for you to choose from. The sizes are: 54×8×5inch, 60×8×5inch, 66×8×5inch, 60×8×3inch, 54×8×3inch 72×8×5inch. Please measure the size of the fireplace before purchasing.
- [ Easy to install ] Our solid wood fireplace shelves comes with a hidden wood bracket that can be easily attached to the wall. Our hollow structure design makes for easy installation. The packaging includes installation instructions and accessories. The 60-inch fireplace mantel is suitable for wood, gas, or electric fireplaces.
Deep Rustic Mantel
ABSWHLM 72x8x5 Fireplace Mantel – Handcrafted Rustic Solid Wood Wall Mounted Floating Shelf with Invisible Heavy Duty Wood Bracket (Natural)
ABSWHLM
- Handcrafted Hollow Rustic Solid Wood: Our fireplace mantels are handmade from pine wood, featuring a minimalist design and a fashionable silhouette that complements your modern living space. Its clean lines and neat design effortlessly add a refined elegance to any of your spaces
- Charm of Natural Wood Grain: We preserve every natural mark of the wood, making each piece unique. At the same time, we use a unique natural dyeing process that not only enriches the wooden texture, creating a stunning finish, but also ensures its durability and protection
- Wall-Mounted Design: The fireplace mantels feature an elegant floating design, offering a clean and tidy appearance, making them the perfect choice for displaying decorations or storing daily items. These mantels are not only furniture, they are a lasting investment in the beauty of natural wood, carefully processed to suit your home even better
- Easy Installation: Our solid wood mantels come with hidden wood brackets, which can be easily fixed to the wall. Our hollow structure design ensures easy installation. The package includes installation instructions and two sets of accessories, compatible with hollow walls (drywalls) and solid walls (brick walls). For any installation issues, feel free to contact us at any time
- The Choice for Creative Gifts: This solid wood mantel is also a perfect gift choice, whether it’s Christmas, Mother’s Day, birthdays, weddings, anniversaries, or Thanksgiving, it’s the ideal gift for friends and family. Decorate with a simple fireplace mantel and bring the purest joy
Compact TV Fireplace
43 Inch Fireplace TV Stand with Mantel – Electric Fireplace Heater, Wooden Entertainment Center, Adjustable LED Flame, Freestanding (750W/1500W),Black
ZAFRO
- Classic Elegance for Any Home: Boasting a fluid, decorative design and high-quality craftsmanship, this electric fireplace TV stand brings a touch of elegant, vintage atmosphere. Featuring realistic LED flames and burning log effects，it serves as a versatile centerpiece that complements both classic and warm, cozy living spaces.
- Effortless Control with a Remote from Anywhere:Operate your freestanding electric fireplace with ultimate convenience. The included remote control allows you to adjust the flame brightness, turn the heater on/off, and set the timer from the comfort of your couch, creating the perfect environment .
- Multi-functional:Enjoy complete control over your comfort with dual heating options (750W & 1500W) and 5-level adjustable flame brightness. Having a high power output of 5,100BTU,you can enjoy a warm and comfortable environment.
- Built-in Safety:Equipped with advanced overheat protection, the electric fireplace automatically shuts off to prevent hazards, ensuring peace of mind for you and your family.
- Dimensions & Thoughtful Packaging:Electric Fireplace with Mantel is 43.39″W*13.7″D*39.68″H.For the complete and safe delivery of the fireplace, it will be sent out in two packages. Please wait patiently for both packages to arrive.
Freestanding Modern Mantel
HOMCOM Modern Fireplace Mantel, Freestanding Fireplace Surround with Leg for Electric Fireplaces, Exquisite Floral Pattern, 44.7″ W x 40″ H, White
HOMCOM
- Clean Minimalist Design: Enhance your home’s ambiance with this fireplace mantel, featuring a streamlined, modern frame with subtle detailing. Great for pairing with electric fireplaces or as a sleek, standalone decorative piece
- Decorative Top Surface: The spacious top board of this fireplace mantel surround is optimal for showcasing your favorite photos, vases, and decorative treasures, making your room feel more personalized and refined
- Quality Craftsmanship: Built from robust fir wood, this fireplace surround features a sleek, painted finish. It ensures lasting use and easy maintenance, preserving its exquisite appearance
- Simple Setup, Secure Fit: Assembly takes just a few minutes—simply attach the legs to the top piece and secure the fireplace mantel to the wall. Once in place, the included back anti-tipping kit keeps it stable, so you can enjoy it safely and worry-free
- Fireplace Surround Information: Overall Dimensions: 44.7″ W x 9.3″ D x 40″ H. Weight Capacity: 66 lbs. Assembly required
Storage Fireplace Solution
Naice 72″ Electric Fireplace with Mantel and Cabinets, Fireplace TV Stand for Living Room Bedroom, Stacked Stone Surround and Remote Control 3D Realistic Flame, Black
Naice
- 【Large Storage Space】2 storage cabinets and large tabletop keep TVs media, CDs and books organized. Adjustable shelves inside cabinet make it easy to customize the space for your ornaments.
- 【Farmhouse Fireplace with Mantel】 Surround Realistic Stacked Stone finish, and serpentine shaped edge design, the wood mantel adds rustic charm flair to any room. Whether heated or not, you can enjoy the relaxing and romantic atmosphere of dancing flames all year round.
- 【Efficient Heating】 Both safe and convenient, the 1400W fireplace heater has a high power output of 5,000 BTU, warming up to 400 square foot room to enjoy the constant warmth and beauty without the smoke and ashes. Overheat protection and flame failure protection makes more safety.
- 【Realistic 3D flame】This electric fireplace heater features realistic 3D flame effects. You can control different flame brightness, heating and timer by remote control or touching buttons, providing a cozy and warm atmosphere to your room.
- 【Easy to Assemble】The package with step-by-step illustrated instruction and a complete set, so you can easily assemble your new fireplace. 📩 We’re glad to provide you with premium Pre-Sales And After-Sales Customer Services.
Product prices and availability are accurate as of the date/time indicated and are subject to change. Any price and availability information displayed on Amazon.com at the time of purchase will apply to the purchase of this product.
Buying Guide
FAQs
What materials are best for fireplace mantels?
Wood mantels offer a classic, warm look and are easy to customize, while stone or marble provide durability and a luxurious feel. Consider your home’s style and maintenance preferences—wood may require more upkeep, while stone is long-lasting but heavier.
How do I choose the right size mantel for my fireplace?
Measure the width of your fireplace opening and select a mantel that extends at least 3-6 inches on each side for balance. Ensure the height complements your room’s proportions—too tall can overwhelm, while too short may look underwhelming.
What are the differences between floating and traditional mantels?
Floating mantels mount directly to the wall, creating a modern, minimalist look, while traditional mantels rest on legs or a surround for a more classic appearance. Floating styles work well in small spaces, while traditional ones add grandeur to larger rooms.
Are prefabricated mantels worth it compared to custom ones?
Prefabricated mantels are budget-friendly and quick to install, ideal for standard-sized fireplaces. Custom mantels offer unique designs and perfect fit but come at a higher cost and longer lead time.
What features should I prioritize for a functional mantel?
Look for sturdy construction to support decor, heat-resistant materials if near a working fireplace, and built-in storage like shelves or cabinets. Some mantels also include integrated lighting or hidden wire management for a polished look.
How do mantel styles differ between modern and traditional homes?
Modern mantels often feature sleek lines, minimal ornamentation, and materials like concrete or metal, while traditional mantels showcase intricate carvings, rich woods, or ornate stone. Choose a style that aligns with your home’s overall aesthetic for cohesion.
What’s the average cost of a quality fireplace mantel?
Basic wood or MDF mantels start around $200-$500, while high-end materials like marble or custom woodwork can exceed $2,000. Factor in installation costs, especially for heavy or custom designs.
Can I install a mantel myself, or should I hire a professional?
DIY installation is possible for lightweight, prefabricated mantels with basic tools, but heavy or custom mantels may require professional help to ensure safety and proper mounting. Always check local building codes for clearance requirements.