Comparison: Best Fireplace Pellet Insert (Updated | Dec 16th)
We’ve tested the top contenders to bring you the ultimate guide to pellet inserts that deliver exceptional warmth while slashing your heating bills. From installation ease to heat output and maintenance requirements, we’ll help you navigate the options to find the perfect match for your home and lifestyle. Get ready to cozy up to your new favorite heating solution!
Editor’s Choice
Comfortbilt HP22i Pellet Stove Fireplace Insert Heats 2800 sq.ft 47 lb Hopper Capacity
High-Efficiency Heating
Best for a specific purpose
- Best for high-efficiency heating: Comfortbilt HP22i Pellet Stove Fireplace Insert Heats 2800 sq.ft 47 lb Hopper Capacity
- Best for pellet basket adapter: Large Pellet Basket
- Best for vent-free large insert: Buck Stove Model ZCBBXL 42″ Fireplace Insert | 40
- Best for smart electric fireplace: ROVSUN 23” Electric Fireplace Insert w/Remote & WiFi Control
- Best for glass cleaner solution: MEECO’S RED DEVIL 701 Wood Stove Glass Cleaner – Removes Creosote
- Best for dual window wood stove: New FENGXCXY Wood-Burning Stove with dual viewing windows
- Best for cast iron baffle: QuadraFire Mt. Vernon AE Cast Iron Baffle – SRV7034-263
- Best for compact vent-free insert: Buck Stove Model 1110 Fireplace Insert | 10
- Best for dual fuel gas insert: Duluth Forge Dual Fuel Ventless Gas Fireplace Insert
- Best for ultra-thin electric insert: 50 in Electric Fireplace Inserts – 1500/750W Ultra Narrow Frame Wall Mounted Fireplaces with 3 Heating Modes – 12 Flame Colors
Product Comparison: Best Fireplace Pellet Insert
High-Efficiency Heating
Comfortbilt HP22i Pellet Stove Fireplace Insert Heats 2800 sq.ft 47 lb Hopper Capacity
Comfortbilt
- Requires Ventilation
- High efficiency/110 Volt/Programmable Heat Settings/Auto Ignition
- EPA Approved. Heats up to 2,800 sq ft
- Large View Area-Bay Design-Easy Install Into Exsisting Fireplace
- Beautiful Black Finsh. Qualifies for a 30% IRS Stove Tax Credit
- 47 lbs hopper Capacity/Ash Pan
Pellet Basket Adapter
Large Pellet Basket, Heating Source Using Wood Pellets in Your Wood Stove or Fireplace
burn
Vent-Free Large Insert
Buck Stove Model ZCBBXL 42″ Fireplace Insert | 40,000 BTU Heating | Vent-Free Liquid Propane with Blower
Buck
- Flexible Installation: This Model is designed to be installed in a wood-framed cavity in new construction, remodeling, or if you have an empty mantel cabinet
- Size Designs: Two sizes are available, 36″ and 42″ viewing window. The inches pertains to the total width of the windows on the doors through which you can observe the fire burning inside the unit.
- Heating and Control: Operating at 99.9% efficiency with 40,000 BTU, this fireplace uses natural gas or propane. It includes a variable speed blower and features a reliable standing pilot ignition system that can work with a remote control or thermostat.
- Warranty: Backed by a 2-Year Factory Warranty from Buck Stove, headquartered in America. Registration with the manufacturer is required for warranty activation. Installation must adhere to local and state codes for eligibility.
- More Information: Feel free to check out the Fourth Photo or the Product Description section for valuable details on this unit’s specifications.
Smart Electric Fireplace
ROVSUN 23” Electric Fireplace Insert w/Remote & WiFi Control, Faux Fireplace Logs w/Timer, Overheat Protection, Adjustable Flame and Brightness, CSA Listed for Home Living Room Bedroom, 1400W
ROVSUN
- 🔥Fast Heating: With powerful heating filaments, this 1400W & 23” wide fireplace heater can deliver 62-82℉ warm air, heating room more efficiently than a typical fan-forced heater. Provides cozy warmth on cold winter days
- 🔥Adjustable Flame: The flame can be switched between 6 colors and 5 brightness modes, making the heater more suitable for all seasons and occasions. The bright and roaring flames during large gatherings further enhance the atmosphere and complement the Christmas spirit
- 🔥Muti Control Mode: With a responsive remote control and a simplified control panel, you can install these glowing logs and blow out heat in minutes. You can also open your faux fireplace logs with APP on your phone. With 0-6H timer function, low noise <45db design, more convenient and quieter to use at night
- 🔥Realistic Design: Our electric fireplace uses exquisite craftsmanship and durable materials to look like the real thing, and the dancing flames and glowing embers provide an immersive experience for you and your guests
- 🔥Overheat Protection: Once the internal temperature is too high, the electric fireplace will automatically shut down to ensure the safety of your family, allowing you to sleep comfortably and warmly at night without worry. Our electric heater is CSA certified, proving that it is safe and reliable
Glass Cleaner Solution
MEECO’S RED DEVIL 701 Wood Stove Glass Cleaner – Removes Creosote, Soot & Smoke from Wood, Pellet, Coal Stoves & Fireplace Inserts (16 fl oz) – Made in the USA
MEECO’S RED DEVIL
- POWERFUL CLEANING: This Woodstove Glass Cleaner is an industrial-strength formula designed to remove baked-on creosote, smoke, soot, and dirt from the glass on wood, pellet, and coal stoves, as well as fireplace inserts.
- EASY TO USE: Ready-to-use trigger spray delivers effortless cleaning — just spray and wipe for a clear, streak-free finish.
- TOUGH ON RESIDUE, SAFE ON GLASS: Industrial-strength cleaner cuts through buildup without scratching or damaging the surface.
- VERSATILE APPLICATION: Ideal for wood, pellet, and coal stoves, as well as fireplace inserts and glass doors.
- AMERICAN-MADE QUALITY: Proudly manufactured in the USA since 1937 by Meeco’s Red Devil 701, a trusted name in stove and fireplace care.
- IMPORTANT NOTE: Not recommended for use on gas stove glass.
Dual Window Wood Stove
New FENGXCXY Wood-Burning Stove with dual viewing windows, 4-leg multifunctional fireplace, and pellet stove thermostat. Heats homes and offices up to 540 square feet. Easy to clean. Black.
FENGXCXY
- 1.High-Efficiency Heating The FENGXCXY indoor wood-burning stove utilizes triple combustion technology for high thermal efficiency, rapidly heating spaces. It’s ideal for areas between 20 and 50 square meters, delivering instant warmth while maintaining comfort. The stove’s top features a circular opening that can be opened when heating is needed or to keep food and beverages warm—a truly convenient and thoughtful design.
- 2. Safe Construction The stove body is constructed from thick steel plates coated with heat-resistant metallic paint to enhance adhesion and prevent peeling over time. The stove top safely accommodates a kettle (sold separately), providing constant warm water and humidity. Its four-legged support design allows wood and items requiring heating or drying to be placed underneath, while the elevated height protects children and pets, delivering cozy warmth for family health during cold winters.
- 3.Multi-Window Classic Design This heated fireplace features two heat-resistant glass viewing windows, allowing you to capture cozy moments while enjoying the flickering flames—perfect for meditation or yoga in a warm room. Its stainless steel construction and elegant finish complement any interior decor, making it an ideal heating solution for living rooms, cabins, garages, gardens, offices, or hotels and commercial spaces.
- 4.Usage and Maintenance This heated fireplace comes with ash removal tools and an ash drawer. The drawer handle adjusts airflow by sliding left or right to control flame size, simplifying cleaning and operation. The included chimney, elbow, and rain cap can be freely installed according to your environment. They draw in fresh air while expelling excess indoor exhaust, providing safe and reliable warmth. Its modular design simplifies storage and loading, allowing for easy transport when not in use.
- 5.Multi-Function Heating and Insulation This freestanding insulated pellet stove excels in diverse settings—living rooms, entertainment spaces, cabins, and workplaces—blending functionality with aesthetic appeal. It delivers energy-efficient heat without electricity, offering years of repeated use to reduce heating costs.
Cast Iron Baffle
QuadraFire Mt. Vernon AE Cast Iron Baffle – SRV7034-263
Quadra-Fire
- QuadraFire Mt. Vernon AE Replacement Cast Iron Baffle
- Original Quadra-Fire Parts
- Manufacturers Latest Technology & Design to help prevent cracking
- Previous Part #’s 7034-148 & 7034-261
Compact Vent-Free Insert
Buck Stove Model 1110 Fireplace Insert | 10,000 BTU Heating | Vent-Free Liquid Propane with Blower
Buck
- Flexible Installation: The ventless Buck Stove Model 1110 fireplace is built with a lower BTU capacity than the 1127 so that it may be installed into a bedroom (where approved by code). Check local regulations, as some areas restrict vent-free appliances.
- Petite Design: It’s small profile makes this an ideal wall mounted center piece that adds class and elegance to any room with the benefit of fitting a variety of home décor styles!
- Heating and Control: Operating at 99.9% efficiency with 10,000 BTUs, this fireplace uses natural gas or propane. This heater has a thermostat sensing bulb and will modulate the flame on or off based on the setting of the control dial.
- Warranty: Backed by a 2-Year Factory Warranty from Buck Stove, headquartered in America. Registration with the manufacturer is required for warranty activation. Installation must adhere to local and state codes for eligibility.
- More Information: Feel free to check out the Third Photo or the Product Description section for valuable details on this unit’s specifications.
Dual Fuel Gas Insert
Duluth Forge Dual Fuel Ventless Gas Fireplace Insert, Remote Control, 9 Fire Logs, Use with Natural Gas or Liquid Propane, 32000 BTU, Heats up to 1500 Sq. Ft., Black
Duluth Forge
- VENTLESS DUAL FUEL TECHNOLOGY: Patented technology gives the option to fuel the Fireplace Insert with either Natural Gas or Liquid Propane; 32000 BTU Vent Free gas heater is 99.9% efficient; No outside duct or chimney is needed to heat up to 1500 sq. ft.
- REMOTE CONTROL FEATURES: The gas fireplace insert includes a remote control with LCD screen to turn the Natural Gas or Liquid Propane burner on and off; A standing pilot allows the remote to turn the flame on and off; Manual flame adjustment control
- STYLISH: 9 hand-painted realistic ceramic fiber faux fireplace logs ensure a long life for the indoor fireplace insert; Mesh Screen completes the look
- DIMENSIONS & INCLUDED ITEMS: 18.38″ H x 33.27″ W x 36.38″ D; Clearance from the top of the fireplace to the ceiling must not be less than 42”; Includes 9 ceramic logs, iron grate, 1 AAA battery, remote control & receiver; Weight – 88.2 lbs.
- SAFETY FEATURES: Push button Piezo ignition; Zero-Clearance Firebox can be installed against or recessed into any wall accessible to a gas line
Ultra-Thin Electric Insert
50 in Electric Fireplace Inserts – 1500/750W Ultra Narrow Frame Wall Mounted Fireplaces with 3 Heating Modes – 12 Flame Colors, Remote Control/Timer, Touch Screen, Low Noise
EliteEdge
- 【Versatile Installation Options: Wall Recessed or Wall Mounted】This electric fireplace offers flexible installation to suit your space, whether recessed into the wall for a sleek, built-in look or mounted on the surface for easy setup. Its slim profile creates a modern focal point while saving valuable floor space in any room.
- 【12 Adjustable Flame Colors for Customized Ambiance】Choose from 12 vibrant flame colors to match your mood or interior decor. The adjustable settings allow you to create various lighting effects—from warm amber to cool blues—adding a unique, dynamic visual element that enhances the atmosphere year-round.
- 【Convenient Remote Control and Touch Screen Operation】Operate the fireplace effortlessly with either the intuitive touch screen panel or the included remote control. Adjust flame brightness, heat levels, and timer settings from across the room, providing user-friendly control without interrupting your relaxation or activities.
- 【Dual Heat Settings with Efficient 1500W and 750W Modes】Enjoy supplemental warmth with two heat output options—1500 watts for high heat and 750 watts for energy-saving mode. The efficient heating system quickly raises room temperature, making it suitable for living rooms, bedrooms, or offices during cooler months.
- 【Built-In Timer for Hassle-Free Automation】Set the fireplace timer to run for up to 9 hours, allowing you to enjoy warmth and ambiance without worrying about turning it off manually. The automatic shutoff enhances safety and convenience, helping manage energy usage effectively while you focus on comfort.
Product prices and availability are accurate as of the date/time indicated and are subject to change. Any price and availability information displayed on Amazon.com at the time of purchase will apply to the purchase of this product.
Buying Guide
FAQs
What should I look for in a pellet fireplace insert?
Consider the heating capacity to match your room size, as measured in BTUs. Look for features like programmable thermostats, remote controls, and easy-to-clean ash pans for convenience. Check the efficiency rating (usually 70-85%) to ensure optimal heat output and fuel savings.
How do pellet inserts compare to traditional wood-burning fireplaces?
Pellet inserts are more efficient and produce less smoke, making them eco-friendlier than wood-burning options. They also require less maintenance since pellets burn cleaner and produce less creosote. However, wood-burning fireplaces offer a more authentic ambiance and don’t rely on electricity for operation.
Are pellet inserts cost-effective in the long run?
While pellet inserts have higher upfront costs, they save money over time due to lower fuel expenses and higher efficiency. Pellets are often cheaper and more readily available than firewood, especially in bulk. Additionally, many models qualify for tax credits or rebates, further reducing long-term costs.
What features are worth paying extra for?
Auto-ignition systems and self-cleaning glass doors add convenience but may increase the price. Quiet operation modes and variable speed fans are great for noise-sensitive households. Look for models with large hoppers to reduce refueling frequency, especially for extended use.
How do I choose the right size insert for my home?
Measure the square footage of the area you want to heat and match it to the insert’s BTU rating. Oversized units can overheat small spaces, while undersized ones may struggle to warm larger areas. Consult a professional to ensure proper fit and ventilation for your existing fireplace.
What maintenance do pellet inserts require?
Regular cleaning of the ash pan, burn pot, and glass door is essential for optimal performance. Annual professional servicing is recommended to inspect the exhaust system and ensure safety. Using high-quality pellets reduces maintenance frequency and improves efficiency.
Are pellet inserts environmentally friendly?
Pellets are made from compressed sawdust and other biomass, making them a renewable energy source. They produce fewer emissions than wood, reducing your carbon footprint. Look for EPA-certified models to ensure compliance with environmental standards.
Can I install a pellet insert myself?
DIY installation is possible but not recommended due to complex venting and electrical requirements. Improper installation can lead to safety hazards or void warranties. Hiring a certified installer ensures compliance with local codes and optimal performance.