ProGardenReview is reader-supported, which means when you buy through links on this site, I may earn a small commission. Read full disclosure.

Comparison: Best Fireplace Pellet Stove Insert (Updated | Dec 16th)

ByAlexis

These clever units convert your existing hearth into a highly effective heating source that’s both eco-friendly and easy on your wallet. We’ve done the homework for you, comparing the top models that deliver maximum heat output, impressive efficiency ratings, and convenient features like programmable thermostats. Whether you’re looking to slash your heating bills or reduce your environmental footprint, our guide will help you find the perfect pellet insert that combines timeless charm with modern heating technology.

Editor’s Choice

Comfortbilt HP22i Pellet Stove Fireplace Insert Heats 2800 sq.ft 47 lb Hopper Capacity

Comfortbilt HP22i Pellet Stove Fireplace Insert Heats 2800 sq.ft 47 lb Hopper Capacity
Efficient Heating Powerhouse

Best for a specific purpose

Product Comparison: Best Fireplace Pellet Stove Insert

Efficient Heating Powerhouse

Comfortbilt HP22i Pellet Stove Fireplace Insert Heats 2800 sq.ft 47 lb Hopper Capacity

Comfortbilt HP22i Pellet Stove Fireplace Insert Heats 2800 sq.ft 47 lb Hopper Capacity

Comfortbilt
The Comfortbilt HP22i Pellet Stove Fireplace Insert transforms your existing fireplace into an efficient heating powerhouse. With its impressive 2,800 sq ft heating capacity, it’s perfect for large homes or open-concept living spaces. The 47-pound hopper capacity means less frequent refueling, while the programmable heat settings and auto ignition provide ultimate convenience. Its bay design offers a large viewing area to enjoy the flames, and the sleek black finish complements any decor. EPA approved and eligible for a 30% IRS tax credit, this insert combines eco-friendliness with cost savings. Installation is straightforward, making it an excellent upgrade for homeowners looking to reduce heating costs.

✓ Reasons to Buy

  • Massive heating area
  • Large hopper capacity
  • Programmable settings
  • Tax credit eligible
  • Easy installation

✗ Reasons Not to Buy

  • Requires ventilation
  • Higher initial cost
  • Regular maintenance needed

Check price

Smart WiFi Control

Bayfront Pellet Stove – 66lb Hopper

Bayfront Pellet Stove - 66lb Hopper

Cleveland Iron Works
The Cleveland Iron Works Bayfront Pellet Stove combines efficiency with modern convenience, featuring a massive 66-pound hopper that provides extended heating periods without constant refilling. This powerful insert efficiently warms spaces between 1,800-2,500 square feet, making it ideal for medium to large homes. The built-in WiFi and smart home technology allow you to control temperature settings remotely via your smartphone. Best of all, this EPA-certified stove qualifies for a 30% tax credit, helping offset the initial investment. The sleek bayfront design adds a touch of elegance while providing consistent, eco-friendly warmth throughout your living space.

✓ Reasons to Buy

  • Large 66lb hopper
  • WiFi smart control
  • Heats up to 2500 sq ft
  • 30% EPA tax credit
  • Eco-friendly heating

✗ Reasons Not to Buy

  • Higher initial cost
  • Requires professional installation
  • Needs regular maintenance

Check price

Wood Stove Pellet Adapter

Large Pellet Basket, Heating Source Using Wood Pellets in Your Wood Stove or Fireplace

Large Pellet Basket, Heating Source Using Wood Pellets in Your Wood Stove or Fireplace

burn
Transform your existing wood stove or fireplace into an efficient pellet heating system with this large pellet basket from burn. Designed to hold approximately 30 pounds of wood pellets, this basket provides consistent heat for 8-10 hours without electricity. Simply fill the basket with pellets, place it in your fireplace or wood stove, and light it. The open-flame design creates a mesmerizing ambiance while delivering steady warmth. Perfect for power outages or as a supplemental heating source, this basket eliminates the need for expensive pellet stove installations while maintaining the traditional charm of your existing fireplace.

✓ Reasons to Buy

  • Converts existing fireplace
  • No electricity required
  • Long burn time
  • Cost-effective heating
  • Easy to install and use

✗ Reasons Not to Buy

  • Requires manual loading
  • Less efficient than pellet stoves
  • Limited heat control

Check price

Compact Vent-Free Design

Buck Stove Model 1110 Fireplace Insert | 10,000 BTU Heating | Vent-Free Liquid Propane with Blower

Buck Stove Model 1110 Fireplace Insert | 10,000 BTU Heating | Vent-Free Liquid Propane with Blower

Buck
The Buck Stove Model 1110 Fireplace Insert offers a perfect blend of functionality and elegance for homeowners seeking supplemental heating. With its compact design and 10,000 BTU output, this vent-free liquid propane unit efficiently heats small spaces, including bedrooms where code permits. The thermostat-controlled flame automatically adjusts to maintain your desired temperature, while the built-in blower distributes warmth evenly throughout the room. Its versatile installation options and attractive appearance make it suitable for various decor styles. Operating at 99.9% efficiency, this American-made insert provides reliable heating with the peace of mind of a 2-year manufacturer warranty.

✓ Reasons to Buy

  • Compact space-saving design
  • High energy efficiency
  • Thermostat-controlled flame
  • Built-in circulation blower
  • 2-year manufacturer warranty

✗ Reasons Not to Buy

  • Limited heating capacity
  • Installation restrictions in some areas
  • Requires professional installation

Check price

Elegant Traditional Heating

Buck Stove Fireplace Insert Model 21 | Non-Catalytic, 28,901 BTUs (Covers 1,800 Square Feet) | Wood Burning with Heat Activated Blower | Black Door with 9″ Faceplate Trim Kit

Buck Stove Fireplace Insert Model 21 | Non-Catalytic, 28,901 BTUs (Covers 1,800 Square Feet) | Wood Burning with Heat Activated Blower | Black Door with 9

Buck
The Buck Stove Fireplace Insert Model 21 is a powerful heating solution for small to medium spaces, delivering 28,901 BTUs to warm up to 1,800 square feet efficiently. This non-catalytic pellet stove insert combines traditional elegance with modern functionality, featuring customizable door colors in Black, Pewter, or Gold to match your decor. The large viewing area creates a captivating ambiance while providing substantial heat. Installation is flexible with customizable black trim kits that can be cut to size, ensuring a perfect fit in various fireplace openings. Backed by a 1-year replacement and 5-year limited parts warranty, this American-made insert offers both reliability and style for homeowners seeking an efficient heating alternative.

✓ Reasons to Buy

  • Powerful heating capacity
  • Customizable appearance options
  • Flexible installation kit
  • Large viewing area
  • Solid warranty coverage

✗ Reasons Not to Buy

  • Higher price point
  • Professional installation required
  • Limited color choices

Check price

Budget Pellet Solution

Small Pellet Basket, Heating Source Using Wood Pellets in Your Wood Stove or Fireplace

Small Pellet Basket, Heating Source Using Wood Pellets in Your Wood Stove or Fireplace

burnwoodpellets
The burnwoodpellets Small Pellet Basket transforms your existing wood stove or fireplace into an efficient pellet heating system without the expense of a full pellet stove installation. This innovative metal basket allows you to use cost-effective wood pellets as your primary heating source. Simply place the basket inside your wood stove, fill it with pellets, and ignite with a gel fire starter. The adjustable design enables continuous burning by scooping hot pellets to one side while adding fresh pellets to the other. Its durable metal construction ensures longevity and compatibility with various wood stove sizes, making it a versatile heating solution for any home.

✓ Reasons to Buy

  • Cost-effective heating solution
  • Easy to use and maintain
  • Converts existing fireplace
  • Durable metal construction
  • Continuous burning capability

✗ Reasons Not to Buy

  • Requires manual pellet management
  • Limited to smaller spaces
  • Not as efficient as dedicated pellet stoves

Check price

Whisper Quiet Technology

Canyon Lodge Bayfront Pellet Stove heats up to 2500 sq ft

Canyon Lodge Bayfront Pellet Stove heats up to 2500 sq ft

Canyon Lodge
The Canyon Lodge Bayfront Pellet Stove Insert is a powerful heating solution designed to warm large spaces efficiently. With its impressive heating capacity of 1,800 to 2,500 square feet, it’s perfect for spacious homes or open-concept living areas. The 66-pound hopper capacity allows for extended burn times, reducing the frequency of refueling. This smart pellet stove features built-in WiFi connectivity for convenient control through your smartphone, along with a digital control panel and remote. Its Whisper Quiet Blower Technology ensures minimal noise operation while distributing heat effectively. The EPA certification guarantees clean, efficient burning, and the included fresh air supply kit enhances combustion. Best of all, this stove qualifies for a 30% IRS Biomass Stove Tax Credit, making it an economically smart choice for environmentally conscious homeowners.

✓ Reasons to Buy

  • Large heating area coverage
  • High capacity hopper
  • WiFi smart home control
  • Quiet blower technology
  • Tax credit eligible

✗ Reasons Not to Buy

  • Higher initial investment
  • Requires electricity to operate
  • Professional installation needed

Check price

Powerful Heating Solution

Comfortbilt Wood Pellet Stove HP22 2,800 Sq Ft. Pellet Fuel EPA Cert. 55 Pound Hopper

Comfortbilt Wood Pellet Stove HP22 2,800 Sq Ft. Pellet Fuel EPA Cert. 55 Pound Hopper

Comfortbilt
The Comfortbilt HP22 pellet stove insert efficiently heats up to 2,800 square feet, making it perfect for large living spaces. Its sleek bay design offers a generous viewing area to enjoy the flames, while the powerful 110-volt blower distributes warmth evenly throughout your home. The 55-pound hopper capacity allows for extended burn times, reducing the frequency of refueling. Features like auto ignition, programmable thermostat, and easy-to-clean design enhance convenience. EPA and CSA certified, this insert ensures clean, efficient combustion. The carbon black finish adds a modern touch to any fireplace opening, combining functionality with aesthetic appeal.

✓ Reasons to Buy

  • Heats large areas
  • Large viewing window
  • Extended burn time
  • Auto ignition system
  • Programmable thermostat

✗ Reasons Not to Buy

  • Requires ventilation
  • Higher initial cost
  • Regular maintenance needed

Check price

Glass Cleaning Specialist

MEECO’S RED DEVIL 701 Wood Stove Glass Cleaner – Removes Creosote, Soot & Smoke from Wood, Pellet, Coal Stoves & Fireplace Inserts (16 fl oz) – Made in the USA

MEECO'S RED DEVIL 701 Wood Stove Glass Cleaner - Removes Creosote, Soot & Smoke from Wood, Pellet, Coal Stoves & Fireplace Inserts (16 fl oz) - Made in the USA

MEECO’S RED DEVIL
MEECO’S RED DEVIL 701 Wood Stove Glass Cleaner is a powerful solution designed specifically for wood, pellet, and coal stove owners. This industrial-strength formula effectively removes stubborn creosote, soot, and smoke buildup from glass surfaces without scratching or damaging them. The convenient ready-to-use spray bottle makes application effortless – simply spray and wipe for a crystal-clear, streak-free finish. Made in the USA since 1937, this trusted cleaner is perfect for maintaining the visibility of your fireplace insert or stove glass, ensuring you can enjoy the full beauty of your fire while keeping maintenance simple and effective.

✓ Reasons to Buy

  • Powerful cleaning formula
  • Easy spray application
  • Streak-free results
  • Made in USA
  • Versatile for multiple stoves

✗ Reasons Not to Buy

  • Not for gas stoves
  • Can be expensive
  • May require multiple applications

Check price

Maximum Efficiency Champion

Comfortbilt HP42-Alpine Modern Pellet Stove 2800 SQFT Heating 120 Hopper EPA Cert

Comfortbilt HP42-Alpine Modern Pellet Stove 2800 SQFT Heating 120 Hopper EPA Cert

Comfortbilt
The Comfortbilt HP42-Alpine Modern Pellet Stove offers exceptional heating performance for spaces up to 2800 square feet. With an impressive 42,370 BTU output and North America’s highest efficiency rating at 86.1%, this stove delivers powerful warmth while conserving energy. The spacious 120-pound hopper capacity allows for extended operation between refills, perfect for overnight heating or busy households. The modern design complements various home aesthetics, while the EPA certification ensures environmentally friendly operation. Maintenance is simplified with the removable ash pan, and the large hopper opening makes pellet loading effortless. Best of all, it qualifies for the 30% EPA Federal Tax Rebate, making it an economical heating solution.

✓ Reasons to Buy

  • Powerful 42,370 BTU output
  • Highest efficiency rating at 86.1%
  • Large 120lb hopper capacity
  • Qualifies for 30% tax rebate
  • Easy maintenance features

✗ Reasons Not to Buy

  • Higher initial investment
  • Requires pellet supply storage
  • Needs electricity to operate

Check price

Product prices and availability are accurate as of the date/time indicated and are subject to change. Any price and availability information displayed on Amazon.com at the time of purchase will apply to the purchase of this product.

Buying Guide

Buying Guide: Best Fireplace Pellet Stove Insert

Heating Capacity & Size

  • Measure the width, height, and depth of your existing fireplace opening to ensure a proper fit.
  • Determine the square footage of the area you need to heat to select a stove with an appropriate BTU output.
  • Check the stove’s hopper size, which determines how much fuel it can hold and affects its burn time.
  • Consider the overall physical dimensions of the insert to ensure it fits within your hearth and allows for required clearances.

Efficiency & Performance

  • Look for a high EPA (Environmental Protection Agency) certified efficiency rating, which indicates less fuel waste and lower emissions.
  • Compare the BTU (British Thermal Unit) output to understand the stove’s maximum heating power.
  • Check for features like variable speed fans and thermostatic controls for consistent and customizable heat distribution.
  • Investigate the stove’s heat exchanger design, as a more efficient one will transfer more warmth into your home.

Installation & Venting

  • Determine if your existing chimney is suitable for use with a pellet insert or if a new liner (typically stainless steel) is required.
  • Assess whether you have access to an outside wall for direct venting, which is often a simpler and more efficient option.
  • Consider the complexity of the installation and whether you will need to hire a professional certified installer.
  • Check the manufacturer’s requirements for clearances to combustible materials around the insert.

Features & Convenience

  • Look for an automatic ignition system for easy, push-button start-ups.
  • Consider a model with a programmable thermostat or remote control for hands-off operation.
  • Evaluate the ease of cleaning, including access to the burn pot, heat exchangers, and ash pan.
  • Check for a large, self-cleaning glass door for an unobstructed view of the fire with less maintenance.

Construction & Materials

  • Opt for a unit with a heavy-duty, fully welded steel body for durability and long-term performance.
  • Ensure the firebox is lined with high-quality refractory brick or steel for optimal heat retention.
  • Examine the quality of the door gasket to ensure an airtight seal for maximum efficiency.
  • Check the warranty offered by the manufacturer as an indicator of the product’s reliability.

Aesthetics & Style

  • Choose a finish (e.g., black, nickel, bronze) that complements your existing fireplace surround and home decor.
  • Consider the style of the door and trim options to match your interior design, whether modern or traditional.
  • Look for customizable options like different leg styles or a decorative front panel.
  • Decide if you want a large viewing window to showcase the flames.

FAQs

What is the difference between a pellet stove insert and a freestanding pellet stove?

An insert is designed to fit inside an existing masonry or factory-built fireplace, using the chimney as a venting pathway. A freestanding stove is a self-contained unit that can be installed anywhere with proper venting. An insert is the ideal choice if you want to retrofit an old, inefficient fireplace.

How do I choose the right size (BTU) for my room?

Calculate the square footage of the area you want to heat and check the stove’s heating rating in BTUs (British Thermal Units). A common rule of thumb is about 25-30 BTUs per square foot, but you should also consider ceiling height and insulation quality. It’s better to slightly oversize the unit than to choose one that is too small to adequately heat your space.

What key features should I look for in a pellet stove insert?

Look for a programmable thermostat for consistent, automated heat and a large hopper capacity to reduce refueling frequency. An automatic ignition is a major convenience, and a self-cleaning or easy-access ash pan simplifies maintenance. Modern models often include Wi-Fi connectivity for remote control via a smartphone app.

How much installation and maintenance is required?

Installation is complex and should be done by a certified professional to ensure proper venting and safety, which can add to the initial cost. Regular maintenance includes daily ash removal and weekly cleaning of the glass and burn pot. You should also have the entire unit and venting system professionally inspected and serviced at least once a year.

What is the efficiency rating and why does it matter?

The efficiency rating indicates how much heat is produced from the pellets versus how much is lost up the chimney. Higher-efficiency models (over 80%) produce more heat for your home from the same amount of fuel, saving you money on pellets. Look for EPA certification, which guarantees the stove meets strict standards for clean-burning and high efficiency.

How do I compare different brands and models?

Compare key specifications like BTU output, heating capacity, hopper size, and efficiency ratings side-by-side. Read professional reviews and user feedback regarding reliability, customer support, and ease of maintenance. Consider the warranty length and the availability of local service technicians for the brand you are considering.

What is the overall value compared to other heating options?

While the upfront cost of an insert and installation is significant, pellets are often a more cost-effective and stable fuel source than heating oil or propane. They offer a high level of heating efficiency and the cozy ambiance of a real fire. The value comes from long-term fuel savings, increased home comfort, and potentially boosting your home’s value.

Similar Posts