Comparison: Best Fireplace Starter (Updated | Dec 18th)
Nothing beats the cozy ambiance of a crackling fireplace on a chilly evening, but getting that fire started can be frustrating without the right tool. Whether you’re a seasoned fire-maker or a beginner, finding the perfect fireplace starter can transform your experience from struggle to success. We’ve tested the top options on the market to bring you an honest comparison of the **best fireplace starter**s available.
Editor’s Choice
10lb Fatwood Fire Starter Sticks | 100% Natural Fire Starters for Campfires
Premium Resin Firestarter
Best for a specific purpose
- Best for premium resin firestarter: 10lb Fatwood Fire Starter Sticks | 100% Natural Fire Starters for Campfires
- Best for odorless natural firestarter: WH 185 pcs Natural Fire Starters for Indoor Fireplace – 5lb Large Box – Long-Burning Charcoal Starters – Odorless Firestarters for Wood Stove
- Best for quick burn squares: Fire Starter Squares 64 – Fire Starters for Fireplace
- Best for all-weather fatwood: Fatwood Fire Starter Sticks 10lb Box – Indoor or Outdoor 100% All Natural Pine Fire Starters for Campfires
- Best for weather-resistant firestarter: Inflame Fire Starters 130 pcs Fire Starters for Campfires
- Best for bulk fatwood supply: Fatwood Fire Starter Sticks 25lb Box – Indoor or Outdoor 100% All Natural Pine Fire Starters for Campfires
- Best for mess-free ignition: Duraflame Fire Starter for Indoor and Outdoor Use – Quick Ignition Logs for BBQ
- Best for long-lasting firestarter: WH 370 pcs Natural Fire Starters for Indoor Fireplace – 10lb Large Box – Long-Burning Charcoal Starters – Odorless Firestarters for Wood Stove
- Best for quick ignition firelighters: Duraflame Firestart Indoor/Outdoor Firelighters – Quick Ignition for BBQ
- Best for compact firestart cubes: Duraflame Firestart Cubes Firelighters
Product Comparison: Best Fireplace Starter
Premium Resin Firestarter
10lb Fatwood Fire Starter Sticks | 100% Natural Fire Starters for Campfires, Firepit, Fireplaces, BBQ, Wood Stoves | Easy Ignition w/Just 2 Sticks | Camping Essentials by Billy Buckskin (10lb Box)
BILLY BUCKSKIN HOME & BEAUTY
Billy Buckskin’s 10-pound box of premium fatwood fire starter sticks is the ultimate solution for effortlessly starting fires in fireplaces, fire pits, wood stoves, and campfires. Sourced from naturally fallen pine stumps in Mexican jungles, these 8-inch sticks are rich in natural resin, ensuring instant ignition without chemicals or additives. Each stick produces a strong, clean-burning flame with a naturally aromatic scent, creating a warm, inviting atmosphere. With just 2-3 sticks, you can start a robust blaze. These reliable fire starters work in all weather conditions, even when wet, making them perfect for year-round use and emergency preparedness.
✓ Reasons to Buy
- 100% natural
- Works when wet
- Long-lasting supply
- Easy to use
- Aromatic scent
✗ Reasons Not to Buy
- Expensive upfront
- Variable stick sizes
- Limited availability
Odorless Natural Firestarter
WH 185 pcs Natural Fire Starters for Indoor Fireplace – 5lb Large Box – Long-Burning Charcoal Starters – Odorless Firestarters for Wood Stove, Chimney, Campfires & Grill – Quick Ignite
WH
WoodHot’s 185-piece natural fire starter set comes in a 5-pound box, offering exceptional value for indoor and outdoor fire starting needs. Made from eco-friendly pine wood mixed with natural fatty and lauric acid, these chemical-free starters ensure a healthy cooking experience without affecting food flavor. They ignite instantly with just one touch and are completely odorless and smoke-free, making them perfect for grilling and pizza ovens. These water-resistant starters work in all seasons and conditions, eliminating the need for newspapers or other aids. Each piece burns for an extended time, providing sufficient flame to start fires in BBQs, chimneys, lump charcoal, and outdoor fire pits with minimal effort.
✓ Reasons to Buy
- Chemical-free formula
- Odorless burning
- Water-resistant design
- Large quantity
- Quick ignition
✗ Reasons Not to Buy
- Bulky packaging
- Shorter burn time
- Limited availability
Quick Burn Squares
Fire Starter Squares 64 – Fire Starters for Fireplace,Chimney,BBQ Grill,Camping Fire,Wood Stove – Water Resistant and Safe Odourless – Camping Accessories
AWEASROY
AWEASROY’s fire starter squares offer a convenient and reliable solution for all your fire-starting needs. This pack contains 64 squares made from paraffin and sawdust, using only organic materials without glue or harmful chemicals. These waterproof, portable, and lightweight squares make lighting fires fast and easy, even in challenging conditions like wind, dampness, and rain. Each square burns for 6-8 minutes, providing ample time to start fires in BBQ grills, fireplaces, wood stoves, campfires, and more. Just one or two squares are sufficient to get your fire going immediately. The compact size makes them perfect for camping and hiking trips, fitting easily into your backpack.
✓ Reasons to Buy
- Long burn time
- Weather-resistant
- Compact packaging
- No harmful chemicals
- Versatile use
✗ Reasons Not to Buy
- Paraffin content
- Limited per box
- Square shape limitation
All-Weather Fatwood
Fatwood Fire Starter Sticks 10lb Box – Indoor or Outdoor 100% All Natural Pine Fire Starters for Campfires, Fireplace, Firepit, Wood Stove, or BBQ Grill – Kindling Wood Firewood Lighter by Pure Garden
Trademark Global
Trademark Global’s Fatwood Fire Starter Sticks come in a 10lb box, offering a reliable solution for both indoor and outdoor fire needs. Made from 100% all-natural pine wood, these resin-rich sticks ignite quickly and burn hot, making them perfect for fireplaces, fire pits, and campfires. Their easy-to-light nature means you only need 2-3 sticks to start a roaring fire, even in damp conditions. The natural composition ensures no harmful chemicals or additives, making them safe for cooking. With a long shelf life, these fire starters won’t rot or go bad, providing consistent performance whenever you need them.
✓ Reasons to Buy
- 100% natural pine
- Easy to light
- Works when damp
- Long shelf life
- Multipurpose use
✗ Reasons Not to Buy
- Relatively expensive
- Requires storage space
Weather-Resistant Firestarter
Inflame Fire Starters 130 pcs Fire Starters for Campfires, Grill, BBQ, Fireplace, Woodstove – Charcoal Starter – Waterproof, Weather-Resistant – Natural Wood Fireplace Starters
Inflame
Inflame Fire Starters offer a convenient and reliable solution for all your fire-starting needs. This pack contains 130 individual starters made from natural wood shavings and high-quality Dutch food-grade wax, ensuring a clean burn with no odor or impact on food. These versatile starters work perfectly for fireplaces, grills, wood stoves, fire pits, pizza ovens, and campfires. Their weather-resistant design ensures reliable performance even in challenging conditions. The compact packaging requires minimal storage space, making them ideal for both home use and outdoor adventures. Simply place one or two starters under your wood or charcoal, light the side, and enjoy a consistently warm fire every time.
✓ Reasons to Buy
- Weather-resistant design
- Natural food-grade wax
- Compact packaging
- Long-lasting supply
- No chemical odor
✗ Reasons Not to Buy
- Smaller individual pieces
- Requires careful handling
Bulk Fatwood Supply
Fatwood Fire Starter Sticks 25lb Box – Indoor or Outdoor 100% All Natural Pine Fire Starters for Campfires, Fireplace, Firepit, Wood Stove, or BBQ Grill – Kindling Wood Firewood Lighter by Pure Garden
Pure Garden
Pure Garden’s Fatwood Fire Starter Sticks come in a generous 25lb box, providing an abundant supply for frequent fire builders. These 100% natural pine wood sticks are resin-rich, ensuring quick ignition and a hot, sustained burn perfect for fireplaces, fire pits, and campfires. Their all-natural composition means no harmful chemicals or additives, making them safe for cooking applications. The sticks perform reliably even in damp conditions, ensuring you can start a fire whenever needed. With their long shelf life, these fire starters won’t rot or deteriorate over time. The large quantity makes this an economical choice for those who regularly enjoy fires both indoors and outdoors.
✓ Reasons to Buy
- Large 25lb quantity
- Economical bulk option
- 100% natural pine
- Reliable in damp conditions
- Long shelf life
✗ Reasons Not to Buy
- Requires significant storage
- Heavy to transport
Mess-Free Ignition
Duraflame Fire Starter for Indoor and Outdoor Use – Quick Ignition Logs for BBQ, Fireplace, Fire Pit and Campfires (24 Pack)
Duraflame
Duraflame Fire Starters offer a hassle-free solution for igniting indoor and outdoor fires. These quick ignition logs eliminate the need for traditional kindling or fuel, making fire starting effortless. Simply place one starter in your woodpile, light it with a match, and watch as it creates a crackling flame that ignites your logs in seconds. Made with a sustainable blend of wax and renewable biomass, these eco-friendly starters help reduce emissions while providing reliable performance. Their water-resistant design and individual wrapping ensure convenience in various weather conditions. Perfect for BBQs, fireplaces, fire pits, and campfires, these starters provide extended ignition time, allowing you to enjoy your fire without constant relighting. Whether you’re hosting an outdoor gathering or creating a cozy atmosphere indoors, Duraflame Fire Starters deliver consistent, long-lasting flames for maximum enjoyment.
✓ Reasons to Buy
- Effortless fire starting
- Mess-free operation
- Eco-friendly materials
- Water-resistant design
- Extended burning time
✗ Reasons Not to Buy
- Higher price point
- Individual packaging creates waste
- Contains wax
Long-Lasting Firestarter
WH 370 pcs Natural Fire Starters for Indoor Fireplace – 10lb Large Box – Long-Burning Charcoal Starters – Odorless Firestarters for Wood Stove, Chimney, Campfires & Grill – Quick Ignite
WH
WH Natural Fire Starters provide an all-natural solution for igniting fires in your indoor fireplace or outdoor grill. Made from eco-friendly pine wood mixed with natural fatty and lauric acid, these starters ensure a healthy and safe cooking experience. Unlike chemical alternatives, these wood wool fire starters are completely odorless and smoke-free, making them perfect for grilling and pizza ovens without affecting your food’s flavor. They ignite quickly with just one touch, regardless of the method used, providing a reliable flame every time. Each starter offers long-lasting burn time thanks to their all-natural composition, making them sufficient to start fires in BBQs, chimines, lump charcoal, and outdoor fire pits. These water-resistant starters are safe for both indoor and outdoor use, performing consistently through all four seasons without the need for additional materials like newspapers. The 10lb large box contains 370 pieces, ensuring you’ll have plenty of starters for all your fire-starting needs.
✓ Reasons to Buy
- All-natural ingredients
- Odorless and smoke-free
- Quick ignition
- Long-lasting burn time
- Large quantity per box
✗ Reasons Not to Buy
- Bulkier packaging
- Slightly longer ignition time
- Not individually wrapped
Quick Ignition Firelighters
Duraflame Firestart Indoor/Outdoor Firelighters – Quick Ignition for BBQ, Fireplace, Fire Pit and Campfires
Duraflame
Duraflame Firestart Indoor/Outdoor Firelighters provide a convenient solution for quickly igniting fires in various settings. This 12-pack of fire starters eliminates the hassle of traditional kindling materials or fuel, making fire starting effortless. Simply place one starter in your woodpile, light it with a match, and watch as it creates a crackling flame that ignites your logs in seconds. These eco-friendly fire starters are crafted with a sustainable blend of wax and renewable biomass, helping to reduce emissions while ensuring reliable performance. Their water-resistant design and individual wrapping provide convenience in various weather conditions. These versatile fire starters work equally well for BBQs, fireplaces, fire pits, and campfires, delivering consistent ignition power wherever you need it. Whether you’re hosting an outdoor gathering or creating a cozy atmosphere indoors, Duraflame Firestart Firelighters offer a mess-free, reliable solution for all your fire-starting needs.
✓ Reasons to Buy
- Quick ignition capability
- Mess-free operation
- Eco-friendly composition
- Versatile indoor/outdoor use
- Individually wrapped for convenience
✗ Reasons Not to Buy
- Limited quantity per pack
- Contains wax
- Higher cost per starter
Compact Firestart Cubes
Duraflame Firestart Cubes Firelighters, 18 Pack (1 Pack)
Duraflame
Duraflame Firestart Cubes offer a convenient and efficient solution for igniting wood or charcoal quickly and easily. This 18-pack of firelighters is perfect for both indoor and outdoor fires, providing reliable ignition whenever you need it. Made from renewable natural wood and wax, these eco-friendly cubes offer a sustainable alternative to chemical-based fire starters. Their compact design makes them ideal for camping trips, BBQs, or home fireplaces, ensuring you can start a fire anywhere without hassle. These cubes are clean-burning and produce no odor, making them pleasant to use and handle. Simply place a cube under your wood or charcoal, light it, and watch as it quickly spreads flame to start your fire. Their mess-free design eliminates the need for newspapers or kindling, reducing cleanup time and effort. Whether you’re preparing for a camping adventure or simply enjoying a cozy evening by the fireplace, Duraflame Firestart Cubes provide a reliable, convenient fire-starting solution.
✓ Reasons to Buy
- Fast ignition capability
- Compact cube design
- Eco-friendly materials
- No mess or odor
- Convenient 18-pack quantity
✗ Reasons Not to Buy
- Contains wax
- Smaller than other starters
- May need multiple for large fires
Product prices and availability are accurate as of the date/time indicated and are subject to change. Any price and availability information displayed on Amazon.com at the time of purchase will apply to the purchase of this product.
Buying Guide
FAQs
What should I look for in a fireplace starter?
Look for a starter that is easy to use, safe, and durable. Consider the type of fuel it uses, such as electric, gas, or manual, and ensure it suits your fireplace setup.
How do electric and manual fireplace starters compare?
Electric starters are convenient and quick but require a power source, while manual starters are portable and reliable but need more effort. Electric models are better for frequent use, whereas manual ones are great for occasional or outdoor use.
Are gas fireplace starters worth the investment?
Gas starters offer consistent ignition and are ideal for gas fireplaces, but they can be more expensive upfront. They provide excellent value for those who prioritize ease of use and reliability.
What features make a fireplace starter high-quality?
A high-quality starter should have a sturdy build, safety certifications, and a long warranty. Additional features like adjustable flame control or automatic shut-off enhance usability and safety.
How do I choose the right starter for my fireplace type?
Match the starter to your fireplace—electric for wood-burning, gas for gas fireplaces, and manual for portable or outdoor setups. Always check compatibility with your fireplace’s fuel source and design.
What’s the best way to maintain a fireplace starter?
Regularly clean the starter to remove soot or debris, and inspect it for wear and tear. Follow the manufacturer’s guidelines for storage and usage to prolong its lifespan.
Are budget-friendly fireplace starters reliable?
Budget starters can be reliable if they meet safety standards and have good reviews. Look for reputable brands and avoid overly cheap models that compromise on quality or safety.
How long does a typical fireplace starter last?
With proper maintenance, most starters last 3-5 years, though electric models may last longer. Durability depends on usage frequency and build quality.