Comparison: Best Fireplace Wood Burning Insert (Updated | Dec 19th)
Imagine transforming your chilly living room into a cozy haven with the perfect wood-burning fireplace insert. We’ve done the legwork, comparing top models to help you find the ideal balance of heat output, eco-friendliness, and style. Whether you’re looking to reduce heating bills or create a gathering spot for family, our guide will lead you to the best fireplace insert for your home.
Editor’s Choice
Best for a specific purpose
- Best for compact heating solution: Buck Stove Fireplace Insert Model 21 | Non-Catalytic
- Best for flexible installation: Buck Stove Fireplace Insert Model 21 | Non-Catalytic
- Best for realistic flame effect: LegendFlame 23″ W Free Standing Electric Fireplace Log Set (EF290)
- Best for powerful catalytic heating: Buck Stove Fireplace Insert Model 91 | Catalytic
- Best for infrared remote control: Electric Fireplace Logs Inserts Heater with Infrared Remote Controller 5 Flame Brightness 24 H Timer Overheating Protection for Home and Office Decor Black
- Best for heat powered efficiency: VODA Wood Stove Fan Heat Powered Fireplace Fans Non Electric
- Best for remote controlled comfort: LegendFlame 25″ W Free Standing Electric Fireplace Log Set (EF484)
- Best for lifelike flame effects: Electric Fireplace Insert Log Heater 21 Inches
- Best for versatile flame colors: PuraFlame 27″ Free Standing Electric Fireplace Log Set Insert
- Best for quartz infrared heating: Riseon Electric Fireplace Logs Inserts Heater 20-Inch
Product Comparison: Best Fireplace Wood Burning Insert
Compact Heating Solution
Buck Stove Fireplace Insert Model 21 | Non-Catalytic, 28,901 BTUs (Covers 1,800 Square Feet) | Wood Burning with Heat Activated Blower | Black Door with 9″ Faceplate Trim Kit
Buck
The Buck Stove Fireplace Insert Model 21 offers powerful heating with 28,901 BTUs, efficiently warming spaces up to 1,800 square feet. Its non-catalytic design ensures clean burning while maintaining high efficiency. The insert features customizable trim kits that can be cut to size, allowing for seamless installation in various fireplace openings. With its traditional aesthetic and large viewing area, it adds elegance to any room. The door comes in three color options: Black, Pewter, or Gold. Backed by a 1-year replacement and 5-year limited parts warranty, this American-made product combines performance with durability. Installation must comply with local codes for warranty validity.
✓ Reasons to Buy
- Powerful heating capacity
- Customizable trim options
- Elegant traditional design
- Large viewing area
- Reliable warranty coverage
✗ Reasons Not to Buy
- Professional installation required
- Limited door color options
- Non-catalytic design
Flexible Installation
Buck Stove Fireplace Insert Model 21 | Non-Catalytic, 28,901 BTUs (Covers 1,800 Square Feet) | Wood Burning with Heat Activated Blower | Black Door with 12″ Faceplate Trim Kit
Buck
The Buck Stove Fireplace Insert Model 21 delivers exceptional warmth with its 28,901 BTU output, capable of heating areas up to 1,800 square feet efficiently. This non-catalytic wood-burning insert combines traditional charm with modern functionality. The customizable black trim kit can be cut to fit various fireplace openings, ensuring a perfect installation regardless of your existing space. Its elegant design features a large viewing area and comes with door color options in Black, Pewter, or Gold to complement your home decor. Made in America, this insert includes a comprehensive 1-year replacement and 5-year limited parts warranty when properly installed according to local regulations.
✓ Reasons to Buy
- High heating efficiency
- Flexible installation options
- Customizable appearance
- Durable construction
- Excellent warranty protection
✗ Reasons Not to Buy
- Requires professional installation
- Limited heating range
- Specific ventilation requirements
Realistic Flame Effect
LegendFlame 23″ W Free Standing Electric Fireplace Log Set (EF290), Fireplace Insert, Heater 750W/1500W, Crackling Sound, Remote Control
Legend Flame
The LegendFlame 23″ W Free Standing Electric Fireplace Log Set offers the perfect blend of ambiance and convenience. Measuring 23″ W x 20″ H x 10″ D, it fits easily into existing fireplace openings or can be used as a freestanding unit. The realistic resin logs and ember bed create stunning flames that rival traditional wood-burning fireplaces, while the energy-efficient LED technology keeps electricity costs low. This unit provides supplemental heating for rooms up to 400 square feet with its 750W heater. Enjoy the flame effect year-round with or without heat. CSA certified and backed by a one-year limited warranty, it operates on standard 120V with a polarized plug.
✓ Reasons to Buy
- Realistic flame effect
- Easy installation process
- Year-round enjoyment option
- Energy-efficient LED technology
- No ventilation required
✗ Reasons Not to Buy
- Limited heating capacity
- Not primary heat source
- Smaller viewing area
Powerful Catalytic Heating
Buck Stove Fireplace Insert Model 91 | Catalytic, 62,745 BTUs (Covers 3,200 Square Feet) | Wood Burning with Heat Activated Blower | Pewter Door/Windows with 9″ Faceplate Trim Kit
Buck
The Buck Stove Fireplace Insert Model 91 is a powerful heating solution capable of warming up to 3,200 square feet with its impressive 62,745 BTU output. This catalytic wood-burning insert combines efficiency with elegant design, featuring customizable door and window colors in Black, Pewter, or Gold. The large viewing area enhances the traditional aesthetic while providing substantial warmth. Installation is flexible with customizable black trim kits that can be cut to size, concealing gaps in larger spaces. Backed by a 1-year replacement and 5-year limited parts warranty, this American-made insert is designed for durability and long-lasting performance when installed according to local codes.
✓ Reasons to Buy
- Powerful heating capacity
- Covers large areas
- Customizable appearance options
- Flexible installation
- Reliable warranty coverage
✗ Reasons Not to Buy
- Professional installation required
- Higher initial investment
- Requires regular maintenance
Infrared Remote Control
Electric Fireplace Logs Inserts Heater with Infrared Remote Controller 5 Flame Brightness 24 H Timer Overheating Protection for Home and Office Decor Black
Riseon
The Riseon Electric Fireplace Logs Insert offers the ambiance of a real fireplace without the hassle of wood or ashes. Its realistic 3D flame effect mimics burning logs with rolling and pulsating movements, creating an authentic atmosphere. The unit features five adjustable flame brightness levels and two heating modes, allowing you to customize both visual and thermal comfort. The fan heating function includes an automatic cooldown cycle that continues for 60 seconds after shutting off. With overheating protection and ETL certification, safety is prioritized. The remote control and timer function (1-24 hours) add convenience, while its portable design allows for freestanding or built-in installation in any room.
✓ Reasons to Buy
- Realistic flame effects
- No wood or ashes
- Adjustable flame brightness
- Remote control operation
- Energy efficient heating
✗ Reasons Not to Buy
- Limited heating capacity
- Requires electricity
- Not as authentic as wood
Heat Powered Efficiency
VODA Wood Stove Fan Heat Powered Fireplace Fans Non Electric, Heat Activated Thermal Fan for Wood Burning Stove/Log Burner, Stove Accessories Thermometer
VODA
The VODA Wood Stove Fan is an innovative, heat-powered accessory designed to maximize the efficiency of your wood or pellet stove. With its upgraded 8-blade design, this thermal fan circulates warm air horizontally throughout your room, distributing heat more effectively than traditional stoves alone. Operating without electricity or batteries, it activates automatically at 140°F and reaches optimal performance around 482°F. The package includes a magnetic stove thermometer for temperature monitoring and a fragrance dispenser for adding pleasant scents to your space. This energy-saving solution helps reduce heating costs by ensuring every bit of warmth generated by your stove is utilized effectively.
✓ Reasons to Buy
- No electricity needed
- Improves heat distribution
- Includes stove thermometer
- Adds fragrance capability
- Energy saving design
✗ Reasons Not to Buy
- Limited temperature range
- Not suitable for all stoves
- Reduced efficiency at extremes
Remote Controlled Comfort
LegendFlame 25″ W Free Standing Electric Fireplace Log Set (EF484), Fireplace Insert, Heater 750W/1500W, Crackling Sound, Remote Control…
Legend Flame
The LegendFlame 25″ W Free Standing Electric Fireplace Log Set offers a perfect blend of warmth and ambiance for any room. Measuring 25″ W x 20″ H x 10″ D, it fits seamlessly into both small and large existing openings or cabinets with minimal installation effort. The realistic resin logs with ember bed create stunning flame effects that rival traditional wood-burning fireplaces, while the energy-efficient LED technology helps reduce electricity bills. This unit provides supplemental heat for rooms up to 400 square feet without the hassle of dust, smoke, or local wood burning regulations. The included remote control with batteries ensures convenient operation, and the one-year limited warranty provides peace of mind for your investment.
✓ Reasons to Buy
- Realistic flame effects
- Energy-efficient LED
- Easy installation
- Remote included
- Heats 400 sq ft
✗ Reasons Not to Buy
- Not primary heat source
- Limited heat settings
Lifelike Flame Effects
Electric Fireplace Insert Log Heater 21 Inches, 5 Flame Brightness, Multiple Flicker Speed, 750w/1500w Heating, Remote Control, Auto Shut Off
Electactic
This 21-inch Electric Fireplace Insert Log Heater by Electactic brings warmth and charm to any space with its lifelike flame effects. Featuring 5 adjustable flame brightness levels and multiple flicker speed settings, you can customize the perfect ambiance for any mood or occasion. The ETL certification ensures safety with overheat protection and auto shutoff features, making it safe for homes with children and pets. The independent flame and heat control allows you to enjoy the visual effects year-round, while the two heat modes (750W or 1500W) provide efficient heating when needed. Installation is hassle-free with no chimneys or venting required—just plug it in and enjoy. The intuitive controls, accessible via the side panel or remote, make operation effortless.
✓ Reasons to Buy
- Multiple flame settings
- ETL certified safe
- Two heat modes
- No venting needed
- Remote control included
✗ Reasons Not to Buy
- Limited heating area
- Plastic construction
Versatile Flame Colors
PuraFlame 27″ Free Standing Electric Fireplace Log Set Insert, 750W/1500W Heater, 6 Flame Colors with 5 Brightness, Crackling Sound, Remote Control
PuraFlame
The PuraFlame 27″ Free Standing Electric Fireplace Log Set Insert combines functionality with aesthetic appeal to enhance any living space. Designed to fit most existing fireplace openings, this unit requires minimal setup—simply place it in and plug it in. What sets it apart is the variety of flame options, with 6 different colors and 5 brightness levels, plus a crackling sound effect that mimics a real wood-burning fireplace. The 750W/1500W heater can warm a 400 square feet room, with or without the flame effect, but isn’t intended as a primary heat source. The thermostat can be set from 60 to 82℉, and the timer function ranges from 0.5 to 9 hours, all clearly displayed on the LED panel. Backed by a one-year warranty and responsive customer service.
✓ Reasons to Buy
- Six flame colors
- Crackling sound effect
- Dual heat settings
- Built-in thermostat
- Timer function
✗ Reasons Not to Buy
- Not primary heat source
- Limited warranty period
Quartz Infrared Heating
Riseon Electric Fireplace Logs Inserts Heater 20-Inch, Remote Controller Fireplace Heater, Adjustable Flame Colors, Realistic Fake firewood Flame, Overheat Protection, Timer, Thermostat, 1500W Black
Riseon
The Riseon Electric Fireplace Logs Inserts Heater delivers powerful heating performance with its upgraded 1500W quartz tube infrared heating technology that quickly warms rooms. The 20-inch unit features realistic resin logs with a birch appearance that authentically replicates the burning effect of a traditional fireplace. With 5 flame options and 5 air speed adjustments, you can create the perfect romantic and cozy ambiance without the mess of real wood. Safety features include overheat protection that automatically shuts off at 230°F, a sleep mode, and timer function, all operating at a whisper-quiet ≤40dB noise level. The flame function works independently of the heater, making it suitable for year-round use. Its classic design complements most furniture styles, making it ideal for living rooms, bedrooms, offices, or stores.
✓ Reasons to Buy
- Infrared heating technology
- Five flame options
- Overheat protection
- Quiet operation
- Independent flame function
✗ Reasons Not to Buy
- Smaller 20-inch size
- Limited heating coverage
Product prices and availability are accurate as of the date/time indicated and are subject to change. Any price and availability information displayed on Amazon.com at the time of purchase will apply to the purchase of this product.
Buying Guide
FAQs
What should I look for in a wood-burning fireplace insert?
Consider the heating capacity (measured in BTUs) to match your room size, and ensure it’s EPA-certified for efficiency and low emissions. Look for features like adjustable airflow controls, a glass door for safety, and easy-to-clean ash pans for convenience.
How do wood-burning inserts compare to traditional fireplaces?
Wood-burning inserts are more efficient, as they trap heat and radiate it into the room, unlike traditional fireplaces that lose most heat up the chimney. They also produce less smoke and require less wood, making them a cost-effective and eco-friendly option.
What are the key differences between budget and premium models?
Budget models often have basic features and lower BTU outputs, while premium models offer advanced controls, higher efficiency ratings, and durable materials like cast iron. Premium inserts may also include extras like blowers for better heat distribution.
Are wood-burning inserts worth the investment?
Yes, they can significantly reduce heating costs by providing supplemental heat and improving energy efficiency. Over time, the savings on fuel bills can offset the initial purchase and installation costs.
How do I choose the right size insert for my home?
Measure your fireplace opening and room size to ensure a proper fit and adequate heating capacity. A professional installer can help you select an insert that balances efficiency and comfort without overheating your space.
What maintenance is required for a wood-burning insert?
Regular cleaning of the glass door, ash pan, and chimney is essential to maintain performance and safety. Annual inspections by a certified technician are recommended to check for creosote buildup and ensure optimal operation.
Can I install a wood-burning insert myself?
While some DIY enthusiasts may attempt installation, it’s best to hire a certified professional to ensure proper venting and safety compliance. Incorrect installation can lead to poor performance or fire hazards.
What features enhance the value of a wood-burning insert?
Look for features like a blower fan for even heat distribution, a programmable thermostat, and a large glass window for ambiance. These additions improve convenience and overall performance, making the insert a better long-term investment.