ProGardenReview is reader-supported, which means when you buy through links on this site, I may earn a small commission. Read full disclosure.

Comparison: Best Home Fire Pit (Updated | Jan 12th)

There’s nothing quite like gathering around a crackling fire under the stars. Whether you’re roasting s’mores with the kids or sharing stories with friends, a good fire pit turns any backyard into a cozy retreat. But with so many options out there, finding the right one can feel overwhelming. That’s why we’ve done the homework for you. We’ve tested and compared the best home fire pits on the market to help you pick the perfect fit for your space, style, and budget. Let’s dive in!

Key Takeaways

  • High 58,000 BTU output and convertible design are key strengths of the Editor’s Choice.
  • Choose fire pits with versatile features like table conversion for added functionality.
  • Prioritize modern designs with hidden propane tanks for aesthetic appeal.
  • Look for push-button ignition for easy and reliable operation.
Editor’s Choice

28-Inch Gas Fire Pit with Propane Tank Cover

28-Inch Gas Fire Pit with Propane Tank Cover
High-Heat Bowl

Why we choose:

  • High 58,000 BTU output
  • Converts to functional table
  • Hidden propane tank cover

Product Comparison: Best Home Fire Pit

Elegant Tile Table

BAIDE HOME Outdoor Propane Fire Pit Table, Round Porcelain Tile Top 22″ Fire Bowl Column W/ 40,000 BTU Firepit Table Auto-Ignition 400D Cover Glass Rocks for Outside Patio

BAIDE HOME Outdoor Propane Fire Pit Table, Round Porcelain Tile Top 22

BAIDE HOME

The BAIDE HOME Outdoor Propane Fire Pit Table combines style and functionality with its porcelain tile top and faux stacked stone base, creating a cozy ambiance for any patio or backyard. It features a durable 304-grade stainless steel burner and bowl, ensuring long-lasting outdoor use.

The 40,000 BTU heat output provides clean, smokeless warmth, while the included glass rocks enhance the visual appeal. With electronic ignition and a thermocouple safety feature, it’s easy to start and safe to use.

The 22-inch round design doubles as a coffee table, making it versatile for outdoor gatherings. Requires a standard 20 lb propane tank (sold separately).

✓ Reasons to Buy

  • Durable porcelain tile top
  • Easy electronic ignition
  • Smokeless 40,000 BTU heat
  • Thermocouple safety feature
  • Doubles as coffee table

✗ Reasons Not to Buy

  • Heavy at 68.9 lbs
  • Propane tank not included

Check price

High-Heat Bowl

28-Inch Gas Fire Pit with Propane Tank Cover, 58,000 BTU Round Propane Fire Pit Table, Patio Fire Bowl Firepit with Lid, Lava Rocks, Cover, Pre-Attached 10FT Propane Hose, Gray

28-Inch Gas Fire Pit with Propane Tank Cover, 58,000 BTU Round Propane Fire Pit Table, Patio Fire Bowl Firepit with Lid, Lava Rocks, Cover, Pre-Attached 10FT Propane Hose, Gray

BAIDE HOME

This 28-inch gas fire pit offers a powerful 58,000 BTU heat output, perfect for warming up your patio or poolside on cool evenings. The unique bowl-shaped design and gray finish add a modern touch, while the included metal lid converts it into a functional table for drinks or snacks.

It features a hidden propane tank cover for a clean look and a push-button ignition for easy flame adjustment. The 10-foot commercial-grade hose ensures flexibility in tank placement.

With its contemporary flair and high heat output, this fire pit is an ideal centerpiece for outdoor gatherings. Requires a standard 20 lb propane tank (sold separately).

✓ Reasons to Buy

  • High 58,000 BTU output
  • Converts to functional table
  • Hidden propane tank cover
  • Push-button ignition
  • Modern bowl-shaped design

✗ Reasons Not to Buy

  • Propane tank not included
  • Separate tank cover shipment

Check price

Classic Wood Burner

GasOne 23 in Outdoor– Wood Burning Fire Pit – Durable Alloy Steel Fire Pits for Outside – Small Fire Pit for Backyard, Porch, Deck, Camping, BBQ

GasOne 23 in Outdoor– Wood Burning Fire Pit – Durable Alloy Steel Fire Pits for Outside – Small Fire Pit for Backyard, Porch, Deck, Camping, BBQ

Gas One

The GasOne 23-inch Outdoor Fire Pit is perfect for creating cozy gatherings in your backyard or camping trips. Made from durable, rust-resistant alloy steel with high-temperature paint, it withstands prolonged use and weather conditions.

Its compact yet spacious design is ideal for small parties or reunions on decks, porches, or gardens. The fire pit ensures optimal airflow to keep the fire burning safely.

Measuring 23 inches in diameter and 10.65 inches in height, it’s portable and practical. Enjoy roasting marshmallows and endless conversations with family and friends around this reliable fire pit.

✓ Reasons to Buy

  • Durable alloy steel construction
  • Rust-resistant and weatherproof
  • Compact and portable design
  • Optimal airflow for safety

✗ Reasons Not to Buy

  • Small size for large groups
  • No protective cover included

Check price

Product prices and availability are accurate as of the date/time indicated and are subject to change. Any price and availability information displayed on Amazon.com at the time of purchase will apply to the purchase of this product.

Buying Guide

Buying Guide: Best Home Fire Pit

Size & Capacity

  • Consider the available space in your yard or patio
  • Match the fire pit size to your typical group size
  • Check the dimensions to ensure proper clearance from structures
  • Evaluate the depth of the fire bowl for firewood capacity

Fuel Type

  • Wood-burning pits provide a traditional campfire experience
  • Propane models offer convenience and easy ignition
  • Natural gas pits require a permanent gas line hookup
  • Gel or ethanol options are smokeless and portable

Material & Durability

  • Cast iron offers excellent heat retention and durability
  • Stainless steel provides rust resistance and modern aesthetics
  • Copper develops a natural patina over time
  • Look for heavy-gauge steel for long-lasting performance
  • Check for weather-resistant coatings

Safety Features

  • Ensure the pit includes a spark screen to contain embers
  • Look for a sturdy lid to protect the fire bowl when not in use
  • Check for heat-resistant handles to prevent burns
  • Verify the base is stable and non-flammable
  • Consider models with automatic shut-off for gas types

Design & Portability

  • Decide between a built-in or portable style based on your needs
  • Tabletop models are great for small spaces and drinks
  • Fire bowls offer a classic look and focal point
  • Check the weight if you plan to move the pit frequently
  • Choose a design that complements your outdoor decor

Maintenance & Assembly

  • Review the assembly difficulty and required tools
  • Consider how easy it is to clean ash and debris
  • Check if replacement parts are readily available
  • Look for models with drainage holes to prevent water accumulation
  • Evaluate the warranty coverage for peace of mind

FAQs

What should I consider when choosing a home fire pit?

Think about the size of your outdoor space and the type of fuel you prefer, such as wood, propane, or natural gas. Wood offers a traditional experience, while gas or propane provides convenience and easier cleanup. Also, check for safety features like spark screens or sturdy construction to ensure durability and protection.

How do wood-burning fire pits compare to gas ones?

Wood-burning pits create a classic campfire ambiance with crackling sounds and smoky aromas, but they require more maintenance. Gas fire pits are cleaner, easier to ignite, and offer adjustable flames, making them ideal for quick, hassle-free use. Consider your preference for convenience versus the authentic feel of a real fire.

What features should I prioritize for safety and convenience?

Look for fire pits with included spark screens to contain embers and heat-resistant handles for safe portability. Automatic shut-off valves and stable bases are essential for gas models to prevent accidents. Additionally, models with easy-to-clean ash pans or drainage systems can save time and effort.

Are smokeless fire pits worth the extra cost?

Smokeless fire pits are designed to improve airflow and reduce smoke, making them more comfortable for people sitting nearby. They’re especially useful in windy conditions or if you want to minimize irritation from smoke. While they’re often pricier, the added comfort and efficiency can justify the investment for frequent users.

How do I determine the right size fire pit for my space?

Measure your outdoor area to ensure there’s at least 10 feet of clearance from flammable objects like furniture or structures. Smaller pits are great for intimate settings, while larger models suit bigger gatherings. Also, consider the fire pit’s diameter to ensure it balances warmth output with available space.

What’s the difference between portable and built-in fire pits?

Portable fire pits are versatile, easy to move, and perfect for renters or those who like rearranging their outdoor space. Built-in models are permanent installations, often more stylish, and can be customized to match your landscaping. Choose based on whether you value flexibility or a seamless, permanent addition to your home.

How can I get the best value for my money?

Compare materials like stainless steel or cast iron, which offer durability but vary in price and maintenance needs. Look for multi-functional designs, such as fire pits with grilling capabilities or tabletops, to maximize utility. Reading customer reviews and checking warranty terms can also help gauge long-term value.

Similar Posts