Comparison: Best Quality Electric Fireplace Insert (Updated | Dec 16th)

A fireplace insert is a complete, self-contained heater designed to be inserted into an existing fireplace opening, often with a glass front. A log set is a more basic option that consists of realistic-looking logs placed inside your fireplace, typically without a glass enclosure or a dedicated heating unit. Inserts offer better heating efficiency and a more polished, built-in look.

First, measure the interior width, height, and depth of your fireplace opening at its narrowest points. It’s crucial to leave a small gap (usually 1-2 inches) on each side and at the top for proper ventilation and heat dissipation. Always check the manufacturer’s specific installation requirements for the model you are considering.

The required BTU output depends on the size of the room you want to heat, with a general guideline of about 10 BTUs per square foot. For a standard living room (around 400 sq ft), an insert with 4,000 to 5,000 BTUs is usually sufficient. Most quality inserts also include a thermostat and adjustable heat settings for better control.

Yes, high-quality inserts use advanced technology like LED lighting and mirrored refractors to create incredibly realistic and multi-dimensional flame effects. Look for features like adjustable flame brightness and speed, as well as ember bed lighting, to customize the ambiance. Premium models often include crackling sound effects for an even more authentic experience.

Beyond realistic flames, look for a unit with a powerful, quiet fan-forced heater and an adjustable thermostat. A multi-function remote control is essential for convenience, allowing you to adjust heat, flames, and timers from your seat. Consider additional features like an automatic shutoff for safety and different flame color options.

Operating costs are surprisingly low, as electric fireplaces are highly efficient at converting electricity into heat. The main cost is electricity, which varies by location, but running the flames without heat costs only a few cents per hour. When using the heater, the cost is comparable to running a standard electric space heater for the same amount of time.

Installation is generally very straightforward and can be a simple DIY project for most homeowners, as it typically just involves sliding the unit into place and plugging it into a standard outlet. However, you should consult a professional if you need to modify your fireplace opening or install a dedicated electrical circuit. Always follow the manufacturer’s installation and safety guidelines carefully.

A plug-in insert is the most common and convenient type, designed to be used with any standard household electrical outlet. A hardwired unit is permanently connected to your home’s electrical system, offering a cleaner, more seamless look without visible cords. Hardwiring is usually more complex and may require an electrician.