Comparison: Best Quality Fireplace Inserts (Updated | Dec 16th)
We’ve done the legwork, testing top models to bring you the ultimate guide to quality fireplace inserts. From stunning aesthetics to impressive heat output, we’ll help you discover which insert offers the perfect blend of performance and value for your home.
Editor’s Choice
Best for a specific purpose
- Best for realistic fire experience: RICHFLAME 33 Inches
- Best for customizable ambiance: Dreamflame 36 inch Electric Fireplace
- Best for compact log set: LegendFlame 23″ W Free Standing Electric Fireplace Log Set (EF290)
- Best for versatile temperature control: Giantex 28.5″ Electric Fireplace Insert
- Best for ideal replacement unit: Innoflame 23″ Electric Fireplace Insert
- Best for traditional western design: PuraFlame Western 30″ Electric Fireplace Insert with Trim Kit
- Best for antique glass door style: PuraFlame Klaus Electric Fireplace Insert with Fire Crackling Sound Glass Door and Mesh Screen
- Best for speaker enhanced flames: Valuxhome Electric Fireplace
- Best for 3d realistic flames: Electric Fireplace Logs Inserts Heater with Infrared Remote Controller 5 Flame Brightness 24 H Timer Overheating Protection for Home and Office Decor Black
- Best for powerful gas heating: Buck Stove Model ZCBBXL 42″ Fireplace Insert | 40
Product Comparison: Best Quality Fireplace Inserts
Realistic Fire Experience
RICHFLAME 33 Inches, Edward Electric Fireplace Insert with Fire Crackling Sound, Weathered Concrete Interior, Remote Control, 750/1500W, Black
RICHFLAME
The RICHFLAME 33-inch Edward Electric Fireplace Insert offers a perfect blend of warmth and ambiance for any room. With its weathered concrete interior, this unit adds a modern touch while maintaining a classic fireplace feel. The standout feature is the realistic flame effect combined with fire crackling sound, creating an authentic fireside experience without the mess of a traditional fireplace. The insert operates on standard 120V power and requires no gas or cleaning. With two heat settings (750W and 1500W), it can efficiently warm spaces up to 400 square feet. The CSA certification ensures safety, while the energy-saving LED technology helps reduce electricity costs.
✓ Reasons to Buy
- Realistic flame effects
- Fire crackling sound
- Two heat settings
- Energy efficient LED
- CSA certified safety
- No gas required
✗ Reasons Not to Buy
- Limited heating area
- Concrete finish varies
- Right-side power cord
Customizable Ambiance
Dreamflame 36 inch Electric Fireplace, Wall Fireplace Electric with Remote Control, Realistic Log and Crackling Sound, Overheating Protection and Timer, 750/1500W Black
Dreamflame
The Dreamflame 36-inch Electric Fireplace combines practical heating with stylish decoration for your home. This versatile unit offers two heat settings (750W and 1500W) to create a comfortable environment while its realistic logs and flames with customizable spotlights and cracking sound establish a fashionable atmosphere. The classic brick wall design preserves traditional fireplace aesthetics while utilizing modern LED technology for a smokeless, dust-free experience. Installation is straightforward as a recessed unit that fits perfectly in mantels, TV stands, or existing wall openings. With both remote and touch controls, you can easily adjust heating, flame colors, brightness, and timer settings to create your ideal ambiance.
✓ Reasons to Buy
- Customizable flame colors
- Multiple brightness settings
- Remote control operation
- Timer function
- Realistic brick design
- Built-in safety features
✗ Reasons Not to Buy
- Specific opening requirements
- Limited to 110-120V
- Front glass cleaning needed
Compact Log Set
LegendFlame 23″ W Free Standing Electric Fireplace Log Set (EF290), Fireplace Insert, Heater 750W/1500W, Crackling Sound, Remote Control
Legend Flame
The LegendFlame 23-inch Free Standing Electric Fireplace Log Set offers a compact yet powerful heating solution for spaces up to 400 square feet. This versatile unit features stunning flames rising from realistic resin logs with an ember bed that rivals the appearance of traditional wood-burning fireplaces. The energy-efficient LED technology allows you to enjoy the beautiful flame effect year-round, with or without heat. Installation is remarkably simple—just place the unit into an existing opening or cabinet. While it provides supplemental heating, it’s important to note this isn’t designed as a primary heat source. The CSA certification ensures safety and reliability, backed by a one-year limited warranty and responsive customer service.
✓ Reasons to Buy
- Compact free-standing design
- Realistic resin logs
- Energy efficient LED
- Simple installation
- Use with or without heat
- CSA certified
✗ Reasons Not to Buy
- Not primary heat source
- Limited to 400 sq ft
- Basic flame settings
Versatile Temperature Control
Giantex 28.5″ Electric Fireplace Insert, Wall Recessed/Mounted, Freestanding Fireplace with Remote Control, 3 Color Adjustable Flames, 2 Modes Heat, 8 H Timer, 5 Brightness Settings, 750/1500W Heater
Giantex
The Giantex 28.5″ Electric Fireplace Insert offers a perfect blend of functionality and aesthetics for your living space. With its realistic flame effect through tempered glass, you can enjoy three flame color options and five brightness levels to create the perfect ambiance. The intelligent thermostat allows temperature settings from 62°F to 82°F, while the timer function offers convenience with 0-8 hour operation. Choose between low (750W) and high (1500W) heat settings for optimal comfort. This ETL-certified fireplace features overheat protection and can be installed in multiple ways—recessed, wall-mounted, or freestanding—making it versatile for any room.
✓ Reasons to Buy
- Realistic flame effects
- Multiple heat settings
- Remote control included
- Timer function
- Flexible installation options
✗ Reasons Not to Buy
- Limited heating area
- Requires careful measurement
- No crackling sound
Ideal Replacement Unit
Innoflame 23″ Electric Fireplace Insert, Fireplace Heater with Remote, Adjustable 4 Flame Brightness, Log Set, Low Noise, 8H Timer, Overheating Protection, 1400W (23″ X 19 3/4″)
Innoflame
The Innoflame 23″ Electric Fireplace Insert is specifically designed to replace old fireplaces, fitting perfectly into openings of W 23″ x H 19 3/4″. This versatile unit works well in TV stands, mantels, or other furniture pieces. It features a realistic log set with dancing flames and four adjustable brightness levels to create the perfect atmosphere. The fireplace provides 5000 BTU of heat output, effectively warming rooms up to 400 sq ft. The built-in thermostat allows precise temperature control from 64°F to 82°F. With CSA/UL certification, dual safety protection including overheat protection, and an included remote control, this fireplace combines safety, convenience, and functionality.
✓ Reasons to Buy
- Perfect for retrofitting
- Realistic flame effect
- Effective room heating
- Easy remote operation
- Dual safety features
✗ Reasons Not to Buy
- Limited to specific dimensions
- Not suitable for large rooms
- Basic flame customization
Traditional Western Design
PuraFlame Western 30″ Electric Fireplace Insert with Trim Kit, Fire Crackling Sound, Resin Log, Remote Control, 750/1500W Heater, Black
PuraFlame
The PuraFlame Western 30″ Electric Fireplace Insert with Trim Kit brings authentic fireplace ambiance to your home without the mess. Measuring 40.9″ wide x 29.1″ high x 8.8″ deep, this unit features a sleek three-sided interior brick wall design with clean glass front trim. Enjoy three flame settings with variable intensity and brightness that can be used with or without heat year-round. The life-like 11 13/16″ high resin log sits on a grate above an ember bed, perfectly mimicking a wood-burning fireplace. With adjustable thermostat functionality, it provides supplemental heat for up to 400 sq ft. The included remote control and easy installation make this fireplace both convenient and functional.
✓ Reasons to Buy
- Realistic resin logs
- Fire crackling sound
- Three-sided brick design
- Can use flames without heat
- Complete trim kit included
✗ Reasons Not to Buy
- Comes in separate packages
- Not a primary heat source
- Cannot be hardwired
Antique Glass Door Style
PuraFlame Klaus Electric Fireplace Insert with Fire Crackling Sound Glass Door and Mesh Screen, 750/1500W, Black, 26 Inches Wide, 23 3/16 Inches High, 26 W X 23 3/16 H X 7 51/64 D
PuraFlame
The PuraFlame Klaus Electric Fireplace Insert combines traditional aesthetics with modern convenience. Measuring 27.95″ x 24.61″ x 8.78″, it features three flame settings with adjustable intensity and brightness, all powered by energy-efficient LED technology. The lifelike resin log sits atop a realistic ember bed, creating the authentic appearance of a wood-burning fireplace without the maintenance. The antique design includes a glass door and mesh screen for added realism. With an adjustable thermostat, it provides supplemental heat for rooms up to 400 sq. ft. The remote control ensures easy operation, while the flat bottom allows for simple installation. One-year warranty included.
✓ Reasons to Buy
- Realistic flame effects
- Fire crackling sound
- Energy-efficient LED
- Remote control operation
- Easy installation
✗ Reasons Not to Buy
- Limited heating area
- Cannot be hardwired
- Glass door can get hot
Speaker Enhanced Flames
Valuxhome Electric Fireplace, 33 Inches Electric Fireplace Insert, Fireplace Heater with Overheating Protection, Fire Crackling Sound, Remote Control, 750/1500W, Black
Valuxhome
The Valuxhome Electric Fireplace Insert offers a perfect blend of functionality and modern design. With front dimensions of 33″W x 8.84″D x 24.9″H, it fits seamlessly into various spaces. This unit features multiple flame modes with three color atmosphere lights and variable brightness, creating a customizable ambiance. The innovative log speaker design enhances the realistic experience. It provides supplemental heating for rooms up to 400 sq. ft. with two heat options (750W/1500W). The built-in timer allows for automatic shut-off between 1-9 hours. Safety features include overheating protection, and the LED technology ensures energy efficiency without smoke or ash.
✓ Reasons to Buy
- Multiple flame colors
- Built-in log speaker
- Two heat settings
- Timer function
- Overheat protection
✗ Reasons Not to Buy
- Remote control range limited
- Requires specific wall opening
- Installation complexity
3D Realistic Flames
Electric Fireplace Logs Inserts Heater with Infrared Remote Controller 5 Flame Brightness 24 H Timer Overheating Protection for Home and Office Decor Black
Riseon
The Riseon Electric Fireplace Logs Insert Heater delivers a realistic 3D flame effect that mimics burning logs with rolling and pulsating movements. This energy-efficient unit features five brightness levels for the flame and two heating modes that can be operated independently, making it suitable for year-round use. The fan heating function allows precise temperature control while remaining quiet enough not to disturb reading or sleeping. Safety features include ETL certification and automatic shutdown when overheating occurs. The timer function can be set between 1-24 hours. This versatile fireplace insert can be freestanding or built-in, perfect for living rooms, bedrooms, or offices.
✓ Reasons to Buy
- Realistic 3D flame effect
- Five brightness levels
- Quiet fan operation
- 24-hour timer
- ETL certified safety
✗ Reasons Not to Buy
- Limited heating capacity
- Basic remote design
- Plastic construction
Powerful Gas Heating
Buck Stove Model ZCBBXL 42″ Fireplace Insert | 40,000 BTU Heating | Vent-Free Liquid Propane with Blower
Buck
The Buck Stove Model ZCBBXL Fireplace Insert represents the pinnacle of vent-free heating technology. Available in 36″ and 42″ viewing window sizes, this unit operates at an impressive 99.9% efficiency with 40,000 BTU heating capacity. Designed for flexible installation in wood-framed cavities, it works with both natural gas and liquid propane. The variable speed blower ensures optimal heat distribution, while the standing pilot ignition system can be controlled via remote or thermostat. This American-made product is backed by a 2-Year Factory Warranty, though installation must comply with local and state codes. The large viewing window provides an impressive display of the realistic flames.
✓ Reasons to Buy
- Powerful 40,000 BTU
- 99.9% efficiency rating
- Variable speed blower
- Large viewing window
- 2-year warranty
✗ Reasons Not to Buy
- Professional installation required
- Higher fuel consumption
- Limited remote features
Product prices and availability are accurate as of the date/time indicated and are subject to change. Any price and availability information displayed on Amazon.com at the time of purchase will apply to the purchase of this product.
Buying Guide
FAQs
What should I look for in a high-quality fireplace insert?
Look for inserts with high efficiency ratings, typically above 75%, to ensure optimal heat output. Consider the fuel type—wood, gas, or electric—based on your convenience and heating needs. Check for durable materials like cast iron or steel and a warranty that covers at least 5-10 years.
How do wood, gas, and electric fireplace inserts compare?
Wood inserts offer the most authentic experience but require more maintenance and venting. Gas inserts are convenient, clean, and provide consistent heat with minimal effort. Electric inserts are the easiest to install but may lack the heating power of wood or gas options.
What features should I prioritize for better value?
Opt for inserts with adjustable thermostats and blowers to maximize heat distribution and efficiency. Look for models with realistic flame effects and remote controls for added convenience. Energy-saving modes and programmable timers can also enhance long-term value.
Are fireplace inserts energy-efficient?
Yes, high-quality inserts are designed to be more efficient than traditional fireplaces, converting more fuel into usable heat. Look for EPA-certified wood inserts or high-efficiency gas models to minimize energy waste. Proper installation and insulation further improve efficiency.
How do I choose the right size insert for my space?
Measure your fireplace opening and ensure the insert fits snugly for optimal heat retention. Consider the square footage of the room to match the insert’s BTU output—larger spaces need higher BTUs. Consult a professional to avoid undersizing or oversizing.
What are the maintenance requirements for fireplace inserts?
Wood inserts require regular cleaning of ash and chimney inspections to prevent creosote buildup. Gas inserts need annual servicing to check valves and burners, while electric inserts need minimal upkeep. Always follow the manufacturer’s guidelines for maintenance.
Are fireplace inserts worth the investment?
Yes, they can significantly reduce heating costs by improving efficiency and providing supplemental heat. High-quality models also add resale value to your home. Over time, the energy savings and comfort often outweigh the initial cost.
What safety features should I look for?
Choose inserts with automatic shut-off features to prevent overheating or gas leaks. Look for tempered glass doors and cool-touch exteriors, especially if you have children or pets. Ensure the model meets safety certifications like UL or CSA.